MC-115936Narrator does not properly read output from /say, /tell and /tellraw command
Tellraw
extra
Whenever an extra component is used (or the short version of it), the narrator will only say the first part:
/tellraw @p {"text":"Hello ","extra":[{"text":"there."}]}
/tellraw @p [{"text":"Hello "},{"text":"there."}]
Result: narrator only says "Hello ".
Expected result: the narrator says "Hello there." in both situations.
translate with
It work fine with the with component of translate.
/tellraw @p {"translate":"Hello %s","with":[{"text":"there."}]}
Result: Narrator says "Hello there."
selector
The narrator doesn't say selector results.
/tellraw @p {"translate":"Hello %s","with":[{"selector":"@p"}]}
Result: narrator says "Hello ".
Expected result: narrator says "Hello <PLAYER>".
Say
The /say command only makes the narrator say the executor's name
/say Hello there.
Result: narrator says: "<PLAYER>"
Expected Result: narrator says: "<PLAYER> Hello there."
Tell/Msg/Wisper
The /tell command only makes the narrator say the executor's name and the "wispers to you:". Put this in a command block:
/tell @p Hello there.
Result: narrator says: "@ wispers to you:"
Expected Result: narrator says: "@ wispers to you: Hello there."
Side note:
user-f2760: /say and /tell internally get converted to the JSON text component, meaning
/say Hello there.
will internally be converted to the following:
{"translate":"chat.type.announcement","with":[{"text":"<PLAYER>"},{"text":"Hello there"}]}
and of course
/tell @p Hello there.
will internally be converted to the following:
{"translate":"commands.message.display.incoming","with":[{"text":"@"},{"text":"Hello there."}]}
So their cause is not the same as tellraw's (as tellraw works with with translate with).
Linked Issues
is duplicated by1
Created Issue:
Narrator does not read text output from /say command
As of 17w15a, the narrator can now read the unformatted text output from commands (including /tellraw). However, when attempting to readout the output from /say, the narrator fails, reading out <player>, as opposed to <player> <message>.
To reproduce:
1. create a new creative world
2. activate the narrator to narrates all or narrates system
3. type the command /say <message>the narrator should read only the player name, not the message.
Narrator does notread textoutput from /say commandNarrator does not properly read output from /say command
Narrator does not properly read output from /say, /tell and /tellraw command
is duplicated by
As of 17w15a, the narrator can now read the unformatted text output from commands (including /tellraw). However, when attempting to readout the output from /say, the narrator fails, reading out <player>
, as opposed to<player> <message>.To reproduce:
1. create a new creative world
2. activate the narrator to narrates all or narrates system
3. type the command/say <message>
the narrator should read only the player name, not the message.Tellraw
extra
Whenever an extra component is used (or the short version of it), the narrator will only say the first part:
/tellraw @p {"text":"Hello ","extra":[{"text":"there."}]} /tellraw @p [{"text":"Hello "},{"text":"there."}]Result: narrator only says "Hello ".
Expected result: the narrator says "Hello there." in both situations.translate with
It work fine with the with component of translate.
/tellraw @p {"translate":"Hello %s","with":[{"text":"there."}]}Result: Narrator says "Hello there."
selector
The narrator doesn't say selector results.
/tellraw @p {"translate":"Hello %s","with":[{"selector":"@p"}]}Result: narrator says "Hello ".
Expected result: narrator says "Hello <PLAYER>".Say
The /say command only makes the narrator say the executor's name
/say Hello there.Result: narrator says: "<PLAYER>"
Expected Result: narrator says: "<PLAYER> Hello there."Tell/Msg/Wisper
The /tell command only makes the narrator say the executor's name and the "wispers to you:". Put this in a command block:
/tell @p Hello there.Result: narrator says: "@ wispers to you:"
Expected Result: narrator says: "@ wispers to you: Hello there."Side note:
user-f2760: /say and /tell internally get converted to the JSON tekst component, meaning
/say Hello there.will internally be converted to the following:
{"translate":"chat.type.announcement","with":[{"text":"<PLAYER>"},{"text":"Hello there"}]}and of course
/tell @p Hello there.will internally be converted to the following:
{"translate":"commands.message.display.incoming","with":[{"text":"@"},{"text":"Hello there."}]}So their cause is not the same as tellraw's (as tellraw works with with translate with).
Tellraw
extra
Whenever an extra component is used (or the short version of it), the narrator will only say the first part:
/tellraw @p {"text":"Hello ","extra":[{"text":"there."}]} /tellraw @p [{"text":"Hello "},{"text":"there."}]Result: narrator only says "Hello ".
Expected result: the narrator says "Hello there." in both situations.translate with
It work fine with the with component of translate.
/tellraw @p {"translate":"Hello %s","with":[{"text":"there."}]}Result: Narrator says "Hello there."
selector
The narrator doesn't say selector results.
/tellraw @p {"translate":"Hello %s","with":[{"selector":"@p"}]}Result: narrator says "Hello ".
Expected result: narrator says "Hello <PLAYER>".Say
The /say command only makes the narrator say the executor's name
/say Hello there.Result: narrator says: "<PLAYER>"
Expected Result: narrator says: "<PLAYER> Hello there."Tell/Msg/Wisper
The /tell command only makes the narrator say the executor's name and the "wispers to you:". Put this in a command block:
/tell @p Hello there.Result: narrator says: "@ wispers to you:"
Expected Result: narrator says: "@ wispers to you: Hello there."Side note:
user-f2760: /say and /tell internally get converted to the JSON te
kst component, meaning/say Hello there.will internally be converted to the following:
{"translate":"chat.type.announcement","with":[{"text":"<PLAYER>"},{"text":"Hello there"}]}and of course
/tell @p Hello there.will internally be converted to the following:
{"translate":"commands.message.display.incoming","with":[{"text":"@"},{"text":"Hello there."}]}So their cause is not the same as tellraw's (as tellraw works with with translate with).
Tellraw
extra
Whenever an extra component is used (or the short version of it), the narrator will only say the first part:
/tellraw @p {"text":"Hello ","extra":[{"text":"there."}]} /tellraw @p [{"text":"Hello "},{"text":"there."}]Result: narrator only says "Hello ".
Expected result: the narrator says "Hello there." in both situations.translate with
It work fine with the with component of translate.
/tellraw @p {"translate":"Hello %s","with":[{"text":"there."}]}Result: Narrator says "Hello there."
selector
The narrator doesn't say selector results.
/tellraw @p {"translate":"Hello %s","with":[{"selector":"@p"}]}Result: narrator says "Hello ".
Expected result: narrator says "Hello <PLAYER>".Say
The /say command only makes the narrator say the executor's name
/say Hello there.Result: narrator says: "<PLAYER>"
Expected Result: narrator says: "<PLAYER> Hello there."Tell/Msg/Wisper
The /tell command only makes the narrator say the executor's name and the "wispers to you:". Put this in a command block:
/tell @p Hello there.Result: narrator says: "@ wispers to you:"
Expected Result: narrator says: "@ wispers to you: Hello there."Side note:
user-f2760: /say and /tell internally get converted to the JSON text component, meaning
/say Hello there.will internally be converted to the following:
{"translate":"chat.type.announcement","with":[{"text":"<PLAYER>"},{"text":"Hello there"}]}and of course
/tell @p Hello there.will internally be converted to the following:
{"translate":"commands.message.display.incoming","with":[{"text":"@"},{"text":"Hello there."}]}So their cause is not the same as tellraw's (as tellraw works with with translate with).
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Nathan Adams
narrator doesn't work
You are probably referring to
MC-114930. The narrator does work on my machine, and this bug pertains only to machines on which the narrator works.Can confirm on 17w15a. Narrator works, but if you set it to narrate all or narrate system and run the /say command, it'll only say the player name, not the actual message. (Setting it to narrate chat, of course, doesn't read any part of the /say command's output, since it's not chat.) It works fine for /tellraw.
Side note: it also doesn't work for the /tell command. It'll say "@ whispers to you:" (or whatever name is executing the command), but then it won't read the actual message.