MC-13962Brewing Stand doesn't change output when brewing/not brewing
When you place water bottles in your brewing stand, a comparator will give you a redstone signal with the strength of 4, 8 or 11. But the redstone signal doesn't change when you place an item to brew in the brewing stand.
I know, it will change, if you insert more brewing items (10) than one, but most of the time people brew one recipe not 10 or 64. Many designs have gotten useless after this change and I don't understand, why it was made.
There should be a signal change when brewing, even with one ingredient, so it's possible to use with a circuit. Why not changing it to a layout like this:
Empty brewing stand: 0 (redstone power)
1 bottle: 3
2 bottles: 6
3 bottles: 9
+ 1 to 13 10
+ 13 to 26 11
+ 27 to 39 12
+ 40 to 52 13
+ 53 to 63 14
+ 64 15
or this
Empty brewing stand: 0 (redstone power)
1 bottle: 4
2 bottles: 8
3 bottles: 12
+ 1 to 31 13
+ 32 to 63 14
+ 64 15
At least some kind of solution where you can detect a working brewing stand with 1 item.
Created Issue:
Brewing Stand doesn't change output when brewing/not brewing
When you place water bottles in your brewing stand, a comparator will give you a redstone signal with the strength of 4, 8 or 11. But the redstone signal doesn't change when you place an item to brew in the brewing stand.
I know, it will change, if you insert more brewing items (10) than one, but most of the time people brew one recipe not 10 or 64. Many designs have gotten useless after this change and I don't understand, why it was made.
There should be a signal change when brewing, even with one ingredient, so it's possible to use with a circuit. Why not changing it to a layout like this:
Empty brewing stand: 0 (redstone power)
1 bottle: 3
2 bottles: 6
3 bottles: 9
+ 1 to 13 10
+ 13 to 26 11
+ 27 to 39 12
+ 40 to 52 13
+ 53 to 63 14
+ 64 15or this
Empty brewing stand: 0 (redstone power)
1 bottle: 4
2 bottles: 8
3 bottles: 12
+ 1 to 31 13
+ 32 to 63 14
+ 64 15At least some kind of solution where you can detect a working brewing stand with 1 item.
duplicates
Duplicate of
MC-11156, please use the search function to see if your bug has already been submitted. Currently over 54% of tickets are being closed as duplicate.Since for you it's working as intended, is there some kind of "wishlist" where people can vote for their top 10 things for MineCraft?
Minecraft Forums? /r/minecraftsuggestions?