MC-10845Signs on fences/other blocks floating.
Summary:
When you place signs on fences, nether fence, cobblestone wall, mossy cobblestone wall, glass pane, or iron bars, it causes them to float where the fence/other should usually connect. I understand that the fence acts like a normal block, but you could still allow the fence to connect to the sign. I'm not sure if you would count this as a bug though, since it wouldn't happen if it wasn't intended. This has gone unfixed since Alpha 1.0.17 when fences were added.
What I expected to happen was:
The fence to connect properly to the sign.
Describe what you thought should happen here:
The fence should have properly connected to the sign.
What actually happened was:
The sign floated without the fence connecting to it.
Steps to Reproduce:
1. Put a fence (Or another block of that type) block down
2. Put a sign on the side of it.
3. Bug reproduced.
Environment
Windows 7 - Java 6
Linked Issues
duplicates1
Attachments1
Created Issue:
Signs on fences/other blocks floating.
Summary:
When you place signs on fences, nether fence, cobblestone wall, mossy cobblestone wall, glass pane, or iron bars, it causes them to float where the fence should usually connect. I understand that the fence acts like a normal block, but you could still allow the fence to connect to the sign. I'm not sure if you would count this as a bug though, since it wouldn't happen if it wasn't intended. This has gone unfixed since Alpha 1.0.17 when fences were added.What I expected to happen was:
The fence to connect properly to the sign.Describe what you thought should happen here:
The fence should have properly connected to the sign.What actually happened was:
The sign floated without the fence connecting to it.Steps to Reproduce:
1. Put a fence (Or another block of that type) block down
2. Put a sign on the side of it.
3. Bugreproduced.
Environment
Windows 7 - Java 6
Attachments1
Summary:
When you place signs on fences, nether fence, cobblestone wall, mossy cobblestone wall, glass pane, or iron bars, it causes them to float where the fence/other should usually connect. I understand that the fence acts like a normal block, but you could still allow the fence to connect to the sign. I'm not sure if you would count this as a bug though, since it wouldn't happen if it wasn't intended. This has gone unfixed since Alpha 1.0.17 when fences were added.What I expected to happen was:
The fence to connect properly to the sign.Describe what you thought should happen here:
The fence should have properly connected to the sign.What actually happened was:
The sign floated without the fence connecting to it.Steps to Reproduce:
1. Put a fence (Or another block of that type) block down
2. Put a sign on the side of it.
3. Bug
Summary:
When you place signs on fences, nether fence, cobblestone wall, mossy cobblestone wall, glass pane, or iron bars, it causes them to float where the fence/other should usually connect. I understand that the fence acts like a normal block, but you could still allow the fence to connect to the sign. I'm not sure if you would count this as a bug though, since it wouldn't happen if it wasn't intended. This has gone unfixed since Alpha 1.0.17 when fences were added.What I expected to happen was:
The fence to connect properly to the sign.Describe what you thought should happen here:
The fence should have properly connected to the sign.What actually happened was:
The sign floated without the fence connecting to it.Steps to Reproduce:
1. Put a fence (Or another block of that type) block down
2. Put a sign on the side of it.
3. BugSummary:
When you place signs on fences, nether fence, cobblestone wall, mossy cobblestone wall, glass pane, or iron bars, it causes them to float where the fence/other should usually connect. I understand that the fence acts like a normal block, but you could still allow the fence to connect to the sign. I'm not sure if you would count this as a bug though, since it wouldn't happen if it wasn't intended. This has gone unfixed since Alpha 1.0.17 when fences were added.What I expected to happen was:
The fence to connect properly to the sign.Describe what you thought should happen here:
The fence should have properly connected to the sign.What actually happened was:
The sign floated without the fence connecting to it.Steps to Reproduce:
1. Put a fence (Or another block of that type) block down
2. Put a sign on the side of it.
3. Bug reproduced.
Summary:
When you place signs on fences, nether fence, cobblestone wall, mossy cobblestone wall, glass pane, or iron bars, it causes them to float where the fence/other should usually connect. I understand that the fence acts like a normal block, but you could still allow the fence to connect to the sign. I'm not sure if you would count this as a bug though, since it wouldn't happen if it wasn't intended. This has gone unfixed since Alpha 1.0.17 when fences were added.What I expected to happen was:
The fence to connect properly to the sign.Describe what you thought should happen here:
The fence should have properly connected to the sign.What actually happened was:
The sign floated without the fence connecting to it.Steps to Reproduce:
1. Put a fence (Or another block of that type) block down
2. Put a sign on the side of it.
3. Bug reproduced.
duplicates
![[Mod] Ezekiel (ezfe)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/ezekielelin.jpeg){kind=small}
Duplicate of
MC-6382, please use the search function to see if your bug has already been submitted. Currently over 53% of tickets are being closed as duplicate.Related to
MC-9176andMC-2938.With the fixes done on issues
MC-9176andMC-2938, this would not be difficult to change. It wouldn't look good without some additional changes (the upper horizontal bar seems to be too high).Also, since the sign already has a vertical pole when attached as is, it makes me think whether attaching them to fence posts like that is intended. Though I can see the uses for it (and I've tried to do something like that myself).
I had that in mind when I posted this. I noticed that the connector would be a bit too high and would make it look worse than it does when it's floating. But this could also easily be avoided by using a single connector when connecting to a sign or other similar block.