MC-151395Farmers create Bread ONLY when they pick up at least 3 wheat AT ONCE
After some experimantation I found that farmers will only creat bread whe they pick up 3 pices of wheat in one go. Also they will ONLY use THIS wheat for bread creation, ignoring everything in the inventory (yes even the same stack). Whenever a farmer picks up less the 3 wheats at once he will simply keep it forever.
Examples (for clarification):
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 0 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 1 bread and 0 wheat)
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 2 wheat)
- Farmer has 2 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 4 wheat)
- Farmer has 4 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 4 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 2 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 2 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 3 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 3 bread and 7 wheat)
- Farmer has 7 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 10 wheat --> he creates 3 bread (has now 6 bread and 8 wheat)
Since farmers will rarely get a chance to pick up 3 wheat at once and will never use the wheat previously stored in their inventory, this will lead (at least in a wheat only scenario) to a builtup of wheat (and seads) until the inventory is full and the farmer permanently stops working.
I do not believe this is an intended behavior
Linked Issues
Created Issue:
Farmers create Bread ONLY when they pick up at least 3 wheat AT ONCE
After some experimantation I found that farmes will only creat bread whe they pick up 3 pices of wheat in one go. Also they will ONLY unse this wheat for bread creation, ignoring everything in the inventory (yes even the same stack).Whenever a farmer picks up less the 3 wheats at once he will simply keep it forever.
Examples (for clarification):
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 0 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 1 bread and 0 wheat)
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 2 wheat)
- Farmer has 2 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 4 wheat)
- Farmer has 4 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 4 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 2 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 2 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 3 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 3 bread and 7 wheat)
- Farmer has 7 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 10 wheat --> he creates 3 bread (has now 6 bread and 8 wheat)
Since farmes will rarely get a chance to pick up 3 wheat at once and will never use the wheat previously stored in their inventory, this will lead (at least in a wheat only scenario) to a builtup of wheat (and seads) until the inventory is full and the farmer permanently stops working.
I do not believe this is an intended behavior
Environment
Single player Minecraft without any mods (tested in new world and converted world)
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
Single player Minecraft without any mods (tested in new world and converted world)
relates to
After some experimantation I found that farmers will only creat bread whe they pick up 3 pices of wheat in one go. Also they will ONLY unse this wheat for bread creation, ignoring everything in the inventory (yes even the same stack).Whenever a farmer picks up less the 3 wheats at once he will simply keep it forever.
Examples (for clarification):
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 0 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 1 bread and 0 wheat)
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 2 wheat)
- Farmer has 2 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 4 wheat)
- Farmer has 4 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 4 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 2 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 2 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 3 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 3 bread and 7 wheat)
- Farmer has 7 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 10 wheat --> he creates 3 bread (has now 6 bread and 8 wheat)
Since farmers will rarely get a chance to pick up 3 wheat at once and will never use the wheat previously stored in their inventory, this will lead (at least in a wheat only scenario) to a builtup of wheat (and seads) until the inventory is full and the farmer permanently stops working.
I do not believe this is an intended behavior
After some experimantation I found that farmers will only creat bread whe they pick up 3 pices of wheat in one go. Also they will ONLY u
nsethiswheat for bread creation, ignoring everything in the inventory (yes even the same stack).Whenever a farmer picks up less the 3 wheats at once he will simply keep it forever.Examples (for clarification):
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 0 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 1 bread and 0 wheat)
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 2 wheat)
- Farmer has 2 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 4 wheat)
- Farmer has 4 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 4 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 2 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 2 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 3 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 3 bread and 7 wheat)
- Farmer has 7 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 10 wheat --> he creates 3 bread (has now 6 bread and 8 wheat)
Since farmers will rarely get a chance to pick up 3 wheat at once and will never use the wheat previously stored in their inventory, this will lead (at least in a wheat only scenario) to a builtup of wheat (and seads) until the inventory is full and the farmer permanently stops working.
I do not believe this is an intended behavior
After some experimantation I found that farmers will only creat bread whe they pick up 3 pices of wheat in one go. Also they will ONLY use THIS wheat for bread creation, ignoring everything in the inventory (yes even the same stack). Whenever a farmer picks up less the 3 wheats at once he will simply keep it forever.
Examples (for clarification):
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 0 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 1 bread and 0 wheat)
- Farmer has 0 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 2 wheat)
- Farmer has 2 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 1 bread and 4 wheat)
- Farmer has 4 wheat and 1 bread and picks up 4 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 2 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 2 bread and picks up 3 wheat --> he creates 1 bread (has now 3 bread and 5 wheat)
- Farmer has 5 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 2 wheat --> he creates 0 bread (has now 3 bread and 7 wheat)
- Farmer has 7 wheat and 3 bread and picks up 10 wheat --> he creates 3 bread (has now 6 bread and 8 wheat)
Since farmers will rarely get a chance to pick up 3 wheat at once and will never use the wheat previously stored in their inventory, this will lead (at least in a wheat only scenario) to a builtup of wheat (and seads) until the inventory is full and the farmer permanently stops working.
I do not believe this is an intended behavior
![[Bot] Piston](../../../data/avatars/users/31202.png){kind=small}
I have automated bread, carrot, potato and beetroot farms that relies on the farmer villager to throw food to other villagers behind minecarts with hoppers.
Carrot, beetroot and potato work fine, hoppers intercept and transport the thrown food to chest below.
My bread chest is empty
the farmer working the wheat field does not throw any bread to his hungry friends. Several hours played already on 1,14,2 pre-release 3, not a single bread thrown 
This is not resolved. My villager farmer still does not create bread/share with his friends. (I am on 1.14.2 release). Or does the "Fix Version/s:Future Version - 1.14+" mean that a patch is still to come?
Yes
Thank you for quick reply