MC-21924Items do not stack on the correct stack
It seems that items put in a chest by the player with normal item move (left click) are treated different than the ones that are put in by a hopper. Items that are moved into the chest using shift however are treated the same.
So a chest' behavior is as follows:
- Items put in using shift-click WILL get topped up by a hopper when it tries to put similar items into the chest.
- Items put in using left click WILL NOT get topped up by a hopper when it tries to put similar items into the chest. This is unexpected behavior, the bug.
However if a chest has no more empty slots available then items put in using left click WILL get topped up by a hopper when it tries to put similar items into the chest.
Chest contents:
Coal (40)
A hopper now puts 1 coal in the chest:
Coal (41)
I now move 1 carrot into the chest using left click (placing it in a slot of my choice):
Coal (41)
Empty slot
Carrot (1)
If a hopper now also puts 1 carrot into the chest the contents look like this:
Coal (41)
Carrot (1) <- hopper's carrot
Carrot (1) <- my carrot
The hopper's carrot is placed in the first available empty slot instead of on top of my carrot.
Environment
Win7, 64bit, Java 64bit 1.7.0_21-b11
Linked Issues
Created Issue:
Items do not stack on the correct stack
It seems that items put in a chest by the player with normal item move (left click) are treated different than the ones that are put in by a hopper. Items that are moved into the chest using shift however are treated the same.
So a chest' behavior is as follows:
- Items put in using shift-click WILL get topped up by a hopper when it tries to put similar items into the chest.
- Items put in using left click WILL NOT get topped up by a hopper when it tries to put similar items into the chest. This is unexpected behavior, the bug.
However if a chest has no more empty slots available then items put in using left click WILL get topped up by a hopper when it tries to put similar items into the chest.
ExampleChest contents:
Coal (40)
A hopper now puts 1 coal in the chest:
Coal (41)
I now move 1 carrot into the chest using left click (placing it in a slot of my choice):
Coal (41)
Empty slot
Carrot (1)If a hopper now also puts 1 carrot into the chest the contents look like this:
Coal (41)
Carrot (1) <- hopper's carrot
Carrot (1) <- my carrotThe hopper's carrot is placed in the first available empty slot instead of on top of my carrot.
Environment
Win7, 64bit, Java 64bit 1.7.0_21-b11
duplicates
duplicates
duplicates
![[Mod] Torabi](../../../data/assets/gravatar/torabi.png){kind=small}
Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.
Duplicate of
MC-7650.