MC-242725Structures are generated too low by cutting themselves into empty worlds
- create a world and use the datapack
- do /locate (structure)
structures spawn too low
Some of its images do show this issue, but MC-128659 really is about structures allowed to be generated without ground (including strongholds and mineshafts, generating in air, rather than in stone); this is about structed which snap to the surface (such as villages) generating the floor out of the world (the bottom of the structure is supposed to replace the surface, but if there's no surface, it shouldn't be deleted).
Attachments8
Created Issue:
structures are generated too low by cutting themselves into empty worlds
- create a world and use the datapack
- do locate (structure)
- structures spawn too low
Attachments4
bug.zip
- create a world and use the datapack
- do /locate (structure)
- structures spawn too low
- create a world and use the datapack
- do /locate (structure)
- structures spawn too low
- create a world and use the datapack
- do /locate (structure)
structures are generated too low by cutting themselves into empty worldsStructures are generated too low by cutting themselves into empty worlds
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
@Dhranios But it doesn't say that the structure spawns bad.
![[Mod] Anthony Cicinelli](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
![[Mod] Les3awe](../../../data/avatars/users/79847.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
- create a world and use the datapack
- do /locate (structure)
Some of its images do show this issue, but MC-128659 really is about structures allowed to be generated without ground (including strongholds and mineshafts, generating in air, rather than in stone); this is about structed which snap to the surface (such as villages) generating the floor out of the world (the bottom of the structure is supposed to replace the surface, but if there's no surface, it shouldn't be deleted).
I don't know if the other versions are affected.
can someone help me? i don't know how to fix this bug
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! If you think it was incorrect, please notify us on Discord or Reddit
I believe that this is a duplicate of MC-128659.
@Avoma No it's relative because the bug is different.
Some of its images do show this issue, but MC-128659 really is about structures allowed to be generated without ground (including strongholds and mineshafts, generating in air, rather than in stone); this is about structed which snap to the surface (such as villages) generating the floor out of the world (the bottom of the structure is supposed to replace the surface, but if there's no surface, it shouldn't be deleted).
The "bug" datapack seem sus. Do you changed anything in it?
The village generation isn't touched by the data pack, only the terrain has been replaced with just air.
i didn't change anything in the datapack and I used the 1.18 multi-noise
also confirmed in super-flat worlds. I am attaching the world to you and screenshots too.
This seems related to or duplicates MC-87522.
I believe it is related
Fixing it, would "fix" this, fixing this doesn't necessarily fix that (eg making it generate 1 block higher when at min_y, or generate floating islands, rather than just disallowing it in general)
sorry guys but i can't keep up the problem. anyone want this ticket?