MC-44609/clear Max Count removes less
I was making an Adventure map Concept where if you have 64 iron, you can turn them into 1 diamond. but if you have 63 diamonds, it works aswell, which isn't what I entered.
1st Command Block:
/clear @p iron_ingot 0 64
2nd Command Block (Which gets run if the first one succeed):
/give @p diamond
Command Log:
1st Command Block:
[@: Cleared the inventory of Nusia, removing 63 items]
2nd Command Block:
[@: Given [Diamond] * 1 to Nusia]
so the bug is that it cleared my 63, even that I entered 64 as Max Count.
Created Issue:
/clear Max Count removes less
I was making an Adventure map Concept where if you have 64 iron, you can turn them into 1 diamond. but if you have 63 diamonds, it works aswell, which isn't what I entered.
1st Command Block: /clear @p iron_ingot 0 64
2nd Command Block (Which gets run if the first one succeed): /give @p diamondCommand Log:
1st Command Block: [@: Cleared the inventory of Nusia, removing 63 items]
2nd Command Block: [@: Given [Diamond] * 1 to Nusia]so the bug is that it cleared my 63, even that I entered 64 as Max Count.
![[Mod] Ezekiel (ezfe)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/ezekielelin.jpeg){kind=small}
I was making an Adventure map Concept where if you have 64 iron, you can turn them into 1 diamond. but if you have 63 diamonds, it works aswell, which isn't what I entered.
1st Command Block:/clear @p iron_ingot 0 64
2nd Command Block (Which gets run if the first one succeed): /give @p diamondCommand Log:
1st Command Block: [@: Cleared the inventory of Nusia, removing 63 items]
2nd Command Block: [@: Given[Diamond]* 1 to Nusia]so the bug is that it cleared my 63, even that I entered 64 as Max Count.
I was making an Adventure map Concept where if you have 64 iron, you can turn them into 1 diamond. but if you have 63 diamonds, it works aswell, which isn't what I entered.
1st Command Block:/clear @p iron_ingot 0 642nd Command Block (Which gets run if the first one succeed):
/give @p diamondCommand Log:
1st Command Block:[@: Cleared the inventory of Nusia, removing 63 items]2nd Command Block:
[@: Given [Diamond] * 1 to Nusia]so the bug is that it cleared my 63, even that I entered 64 as Max Count.
The max count argument means it will clear up to 64 items. If you had two stacks of iron ingots and ran that command, only one would be removed. I don't think this is a bug.
Then Mayble add a "Min Count" argument to the command so shops could be possible to make
I posted a suggestion for this on reddit [1] as well as an alternative [2] might be better in general.
I see four different ways Mojang could address this:
• Add a [minCount] argument to the /clear command
• Change [maxCount] to [count] to clear exact amounts
• Add a range spec in the form [min]..[max] instead of [maxCount]
• Add an inventory test to the player filters (@p, etc.)
The first three are mutually exclusive, while the fourth could be added with or without any of the first three.
I like ranges in general because they are more expressive:
• Want to clear up to 64 items? Use: `..64`.
• Want to clear all items as long as they have at least 64? Use: `64..`.
• Want to clear up to 64 items but only if they have at least 32? Use: `32..64`
• Want to clear all items? Use: `..`, or leave blank.
• Want to clear 64 items, but only if they have at least 64 items? Use: `64..64` or just `64`.
Range specs could theoretically be used for x/y/z coords as well instead of how 3D volumes are now specified for player/entity filters or the /clone and /fill commands in the current snapshots.
An inventory test would allow for map makers to test for special items to allow entry to new levels.
Sorry for usurping a bug comment for suggestions!
[1] http://reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/comments/1uxz00/add_mincount_to_clear/
[2] http://reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/comments/1tzptp/add_inventory_test_to_player_filter_in_commands/
Currently having the same problem