MC-87560Possible spawning of entities with same UUID causes entity to not spawn
Relates to:
Introduction
This report is about the fact that (very likely) entities spawning with the same UUID is not well handled by the game. Chances that this happens are very low, but when you search on the internet for "lottery twice" you get enough results that show that rare events can happen.
The problem
I am mostly concerned about boss fights, as for example when you try to summon a WitherBoss and it just won't spawn because by accident it got the same UUID as an already existing entity. The same goes for the /summon command, what is when suddenly an entity does not spawn and the player just can not figure out why.
Evidence (maybe)
When placing for example an ArmorStand with a specific UUID twice, it will only place it once and ignore any other tries:
/give @p armor_stand 1 0 {EntityTag:{CustomName:UUID,CustomNameVisible:1,UUIDLeast:0,UUIDMost:0}}
From [Mod] Skylinerw:
For example, in the in-game test I ran, I created an Enderman with a custom UUID in the End and then respawned the dragon. I exited the world and set the dragon's UUID (both its entity and within DimensionData) equal to the Enderman's using NBTExplorer. When I re-entered the world, the dragon was gone.
Even reloading the world did not cause it to come back, although its health bar remained. However, after I killed the Enderman and reloaded the world, the dragon reappeared with the same UUID it was meant to have.
So there is a failsafe for the dragon specifically.
Possible solutions for the problem
A possible solution would be to have a force parameter for the spawning method that says:
"If there is already an entity with that UUID, the UUID is not preset and forced is true, then continue trying to generate a UUID".
Command feedback
As of MC-82945 the feedback for duplicate UUIDs was removed completely. This makes debugging a lot more complicated. I would suggest at least having a feedback when an entity with a preset UUID can not be spawned.
Linked Issues
Created Issue:
Possible spawning of entities with same UUID causes entity to not spawn
Relates to:
Introduction
This report is about the fact that (very likely) entities spawning with the same UUID is not well handled by the game. Chances that this happens are very low, but when you search on the internet for "lottery twice" you get enough results that show that rare events can happen.
The problem
I am mostly concerned about boss fights, as for example when you try to summon a WitherBoss and it just won't spawn because by accident it got the same UUID as an already existing entity. The same goes for the /summon command, what is when suddenly an entity does not spawn and the player just can not figure out why.
Evidence
When placing for example an ArmorStand with a specific UUID twice, it will only place it once and ignore any other tries:
/give @p armor_stand 1 0 {EntityTag:{CustomName:UUID,CustomNameVisible:1,UUIDLeast:0,UUIDMost:0}}Possible solutions for the problem
A possible solution would be to have a force parameter for the spawning method that says:
"If there is already an entity with that UUID, the UUID is not preset and forced is true, then continue trying to generate a UUID".Command feedback
As of
MC-82945the feedback for duplicate UUIDs was removed completely. This makes debugging a lot more complicated. I would suggest at least having a feedback when an entity with a preset UUID can not be spawned.
Relates to:
Introduction
This report is about the fact that (very likely) entities spawning with the same UUID is not well handled by the game. Chances that this happens are very low, but when you search on the internet for "lottery twice" you get enough results that show that rare events can happen.
The problem
I am mostly concerned about boss fights, as for example when you try to summon a WitherBoss and it just won't spawn because by accident it got the same UUID as an already existing entity. The same goes for the /summon command, what is when suddenly an entity does not spawn and the player just can not figure out why.
Evidence (maybe)
When placing for example an ArmorStand with a specific UUID twice, it will only place it once and ignore any other tries:
/give @p armor_stand 1 0 {EntityTag:{CustomName:UUID,CustomNameVisible:1,UUIDLeast:0,UUIDMost:0}}Possible solutions for the problem
A possible solution would be to have a force parameter for the spawning method that says:
"If there is already an entity with that UUID, the UUID is not preset and forced is true, then continue trying to generate a UUID".Command feedback
As of
MC-82945the feedback for duplicate UUIDs was removed completely. This makes debugging a lot more complicated. I would suggest at least having a feedback when an entity with a preset UUID can not be spawned.
![[Mod] redstonehelper](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
Relates to:
Introduction
This report is about the fact that (very likely) entities spawning with the same UUID is not well handled by the game. Chances that this happens are very low, but when you search on the internet for "lottery twice" you get enough results that show that rare events can happen.
The problem
I am mostly concerned about boss fights, as for example when you try to summon a WitherBoss and it just won't spawn because by accident it got the same UUID as an already existing entity. The same goes for the /summon command, what is when suddenly an entity does not spawn and the player just can not figure out why.
Evidence (maybe)
When placing for example an ArmorStand with a specific UUID twice, it will only place it once and ignore any other tries:
/give @p armor_stand 1 0 {EntityTag:{CustomName:UUID,CustomNameVisible:1,UUIDLeast:0,UUIDMost:0}}Possible solutions for the problem
A possible solution would be to have a force parameter for the spawning method that says:
"If there is already an entity with that UUID, the UUID is not preset and forced is true, then continue trying to generate a UUID".Command feedback
As of
MC-82945the feedback for duplicate UUIDs was removed completely. This makes debugging a lot more complicated. I would suggest at least having a feedback when an entity with a preset UUID can not be spawned.
relates to
Relates to:
Introduction
This report is about the fact that (very likely) entities spawning with the same UUID is not well handled by the game. Chances that this happens are very low, but when you search on the internet for "lottery twice" you get enough results that show that rare events can happen.
The problem
I am mostly concerned about boss fights, as for example when you try to summon a WitherBoss and it just won't spawn because by accident it got the same UUID as an already existing entity. The same goes for the /summon command, what is when suddenly an entity does not spawn and the player just can not figure out why.
Evidence (maybe)
When placing for example an ArmorStand with a specific UUID twice, it will only place it once and ignore any other tries:
/give @p armor_stand 1 0 {EntityTag:{CustomName:UUID,CustomNameVisible:1,UUIDLeast:0,UUIDMost:0}}From [Mod] Skylinerw:
For example, in the in-game test I ran, I created an Enderman with a custom UUID in the End and then respawned the dragon. I exited the world and set the dragon's UUID (both its entity and within DimensionData) equal to the Enderman's using NBTExplorer. When I re-entered the world, the dragon was gone.
Even reloading the world did not cause it to come back, although its health bar remained. However, after I killed the Enderman and reloaded the world, the dragon reappeared with the same UUID it was meant to have.
So there is a failsafe for the dragon specifically.Possible solutions for the problem
A possible solution would be to have a force parameter for the spawning method that says:
"If there is already an entity with that UUID, the UUID is not preset and forced is true, then continue trying to generate a UUID".Command feedback
As of
MC-82945the feedback for duplicate UUIDs was removed completely. This makes debugging a lot more complicated. I would suggest at least having a feedback when an entity with a preset UUID can not be spawned.
![[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/grum.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/searge.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke)A comment with security level 'global-moderators' was removed.
The same Unique ID doesn't spawn? That is Unique.
I just wanted to say that you know that this case is possible but then I noticed you already added the warning message so I am fine with the resolution.