MCPE-26901Floating Signs
What was expected to happen:
When the signs only support is broken, the sign should break, too.
What did happen:
The sign stayed suspended in mid air.
Steps to recreate this:
1. Place a sign on any block that signs can be placed on.
2. Destroy the block that the sign is placed on.
3. Observe that the sign is floating without any blocks around it.
I know there are a lot of reports of floating signs, but most of them are actually features in the game (signs attached to fences and other signs seem to be floating), but here the sign floats with nothing attached to it at all.
I took a few pictures at different angles just to prove that there are no invisible blocks and that the signs hit box is visible from the back and bottom. If the sign were attached to a block, the hit box would not be visible from those angles.
As you can see, I did this in mid air, so there's no way there are any blocks anywhere near the sign.
Linked Issues
is duplicated by1
Attachments7
Created Issue:
Floating Signs
What was expected to happen:
When the signs only support is broken, the sign should break, too.What did happen:
The sign stayed suspended in mid air.Steps to recreate this:
1. Place a sign on any block that signs can be placed on.
2. Destroy the block that the sign is placed on.
3. Observe that the sign is floating without any blocks around it.I know there are a lot of reports of floating signs, but most of them are actually features in the game (signs attached to fences and other signs seem to be floating), but here the sign floats with nothing attached to it at all.
I took a few pictures at different angles just to prove that there are no invisible blocks and that the signs hit box is visible from the back and bottom. If the sign were attached to a block, the hit box would not be visible from those angles. I hope I sent the pictures correctly.
Attachments6
- Unresolved
- Open
- Unconfirmed
- Windows
- Windows 10
- 1.2.1.1
What was expected to happen:
When the signs only support is broken, the sign should break, too.What did happen:
The sign stayed suspended in mid air.Steps to recreate this:
1. Place a sign on any block that signs can be placed on.
2. Destroy the block that the sign is placed on.
3. Observe that the sign is floating without any blocks around it.I know there are a lot of reports of floating signs, but most of them are actually features in the game (signs attached to fences and other signs seem to be floating), but here the sign floats with nothing attached to it at all.
I took a few pictures at different angles just to prove that there are no invisible blocks and that the signs hit box is visible from the back and bottom. If the sign were attached to a block, the hit box would not be visible from those angles. I hope I sent the pictures correctly.
By the way, I did this in mid air, so there's no way there are any blocks anywhere near the sign.
What was expected to happen:
When the signs only support is broken, the sign should break, too.What did happen:
The sign stayed suspended in mid air.Steps to recreate this:
1. Place a sign on any block that signs can be placed on.
2. Destroy the block that the sign is placed on.
3. Observe that the sign is floating without any blocks around it.I know there are a lot of reports of floating signs, but most of them are actually features in the game (signs attached to fences and other signs seem to be floating), but here the sign floats with nothing attached to it at all.
I took a few pictures at different angles just to prove that there are no invisible blocks and that the signs hit box is visible from the back and bottom. If the sign were attached to a block, the hit box would not be visible from those angles. I hope I sent the pictures correctly.
By the way, I did this in mid air, so there's no way there are any blocks anywhere near the sign.What was expected to happen:
When the signs only support is broken, the sign should break, too.What did happen:
The sign stayed suspended in mid air.Steps to recreate this:
1. Place a sign on any block that signs can be placed on.
2. Destroy the block that the sign is placed on.
3. Observe that the sign is floating without any blocks around it.I know there are a lot of reports of floating signs, but most of them are actually features in the game (signs attached to fences and other signs seem to be floating), but here the sign floats with nothing attached to it at all.
I took a few pictures at different angles just to prove that there are no invisible blocks and that the signs hit box is visible from the back and bottom. If the sign were attached to a block, the hit box would not be visible from those angles. I hope I sent the pictures correctly.
As you can see, I did this in mid air, so there's no way there are any blocks anywhere near the sign.
What was expected to happen:
When the signs only support is broken, the sign should break, too.What did happen:
The sign stayed suspended in mid air.Steps to recreate this:
1. Place a sign on any block that signs can be placed on.
2. Destroy the block that the sign is placed on.
3. Observe that the sign is floating without any blocks around it.I know there are a lot of reports of floating signs, but most of them are actually features in the game (signs attached to fences and other signs seem to be floating), but here the sign floats with nothing attached to it at all.
I took a few pictures at different angles just to prove that there are no invisible blocks and that the signs hit box is visible from the back and bottom. If the sign were attached to a block, the hit box would not be visible from those angles.I hope I sent the pictures correctly.
As you can see, I did this in mid air, so there's no way there are any blocks anywhere near the sign.
![[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells)](../../../data/avatars/users/92696.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been closed as a Duplicate of MCPE-26901.
Your additional information and observations are very useful, so if you can add them to the comments section of the parent issue it would be appreciated.
If you have not, you might like to make use of the search feature before making a new ticket, as it's likely that the issue has been reported already.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Feedback – 📖 Game Wiki
huh weird, I don't seem to be having this issue on my phone, but maybe it's something that only affects Windows 10?
This bug has been reported to our internal bug tracker for further testing and a fix. It is scheduled to be fixed in one of the future updates (no specific date can be provided).
Finally! Thank you!
Noting it is also happening on Realms for 1.2.3.6 in survival.
EDIT:
).
After resizing the video, and dropping the background audio, (both requiring Google searches to find the flags for ffmpeg,) I finally uploaded it ( x.mp4
When watching the final result, I guessed that it probably uses the same code as Pumpkins, with some additions. (Placed on the ground; floats when block below is removed).
Fixed in 1.2.6.2 Beta
Thank you guys sooo much for what you do!
We could not do it on our own for the life of us!