MCPE-47940Third Person View punching/mining animation is broken
Current animation:
- The body's rotation isn't pronounced enough, making the offhand move forward a bit too much;
- The main hand's rotation range is not wide enough, it doesn't ever get close to the center of the screen;
- The main hand is barely raised, regardless of the direction the player is looking at (MCPE-54697);
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is not smooth (MCPE-133777).
Original animation:
- The body rotates enough for the motion to be more lively without the offhand being too distracting;
- The main hand's movement is way more pronounced, starting wide and hitting the center of the screen before finishing;
- The main hand's motion is obvious, and also matches whichever direction the player is currently facing;
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is seamless.
Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: This can be fixed by changing the animation from this...
{{code}}
"animation.player.attack.rotations" : {
"loop" : true,
"bones" : {
"body" : {
"rotation" : [ 0.0, "variable.attack_body_rot_y", 0.0 ]
},
"leftarm" : {
"rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 10.0", 0.0, 0.0 ]
},
"rightarm" : {
"rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 30.0", "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) ? (-90.0 * math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180)) + 30.0 : 0.0)", 0.0 ]
}
}
}
to this:
"animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(1.0 - math.pow(1.0 - variable.attack_time, 3.0) * 180.0) * 68.75 - math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -(query.target_x_rotation - 40.10) * 0.75", "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46 * 2.0", "math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -22.91" ] } } }
The expression math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46 is repeated in all three limbs, and can be reduced to a variable. In this case, the variable variable.attack_body_rot_y found in player.entity.json should be changed from this...
Math.sin(360*Math.sqrt(variable.attack_time)) * 5.0
to this:
math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46
Linked Issues
![[Mod] LateLag](../../../data/avatars/users/92884.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Third Person View punching/breaking animation is broken
Since the release of 1.13.0.1 beta, the punching/breaking animation broke.
Expected results:
The torso shakes and the arm moves.Observed results:
The entire body shakes and the head does it in a different direction, looking really odd while mining.
![[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells)](../../../data/avatars/users/92696.png){kind=small}
relates to
Since the release of 1.13.0.1 beta, the punching/breaking animation broke.
Expected results:
The torso shakes and the arm moves.Observed results:
The entire body shakes and the head does it in a different direction, looking really odd while mining.
Since the release of 1.13.0.1 beta, the punching/breaking animation broke.
Expected results:
The torso shakes and the arm moves.
Observed results:
Theentire body shakes and the head does it in a different direction, looking really odd while mining.Observed results:
The offhand moves forward a bit too much and the mainhand is rotating too far from the center of the screen.Expected results:
The offhand moves forward just a bit and the mainhand rotates closer to the center of the screen.Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: below here are attached two videos: one for the animation was expected and used to be played in older versions and one for the
Observed results:
The offhand moves forward a bit too much and the mainhand is rotating too far from the center of the screen.Expected results:
The offhand moves forward just a bit and the mainhand rotates closer to the center of the screen.Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: below here are attached two videos: one for the animation was expected and used to be played in older versions and one for the animation that is currently played in the beta.
Observed results:
The offhand moves forward a bit too muchandthe mainhand is rotating too far from the center of the screen.Expected results:
The offhand moves forward just a bitandthe mainhand rotates closer to the center of the screen.Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: below here are attached two videos: one for the animation was expected and used to be played in older versions and one for the animation that is currently played in the beta.
Observed results:
The offhand moves forward a bit too much, the mainhand is rotating too far from the center of the screen and too low.Expected results:
The offhand moves forward just a bit, the mainhand rotates closer to the center of the screen and it goes higher.Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: below here are attached two videos: one for the animation was expected and used to be played in older versions and one for the animation that is currently played in the beta.
Third Person View punching/breaking animation is brokenThird Person View punching/mining animation is broken
![[Mod] Umija5895M](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
Observed results:
The offhand moves forward a bit too much, the mainhand is rotating too far from the center of the screen and too low.Expected results:
The offhand moves forward just a bit, the mainhand rotates closer to the center of the screen and it goes higher.Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: below here are attached two videos: one for the animation was expected and used to be played in older versions and one for the animation that is currently played in the beta.
Observed results:
The offhand moves forward a bit too much, the mainhand is rotating too far from the center of the screen and too low.Expected results:
The offhand moves forward just a bit, the main hand rotates closer to the center of the screen and it goes higher depending on the direction (MCPE-54697).Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: below here are attached two videos: one for the animation was expected and used to be played in older versions and one for the animation that is currently played in the beta.
Observed results:
The offhand moves forward a bit too much, the mainhand is rotating too far from the center of the screen and too low.Expected results:
The offhand moves forward just a bit, the main hand rotates closer to the center of the screen and it goes higher depending on the direction (MCPE-54697).Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: below here are attached two videos: one for the animation was expected and used to be played in older versions and one for the animation that is currently played in the beta.
Current animation:
- The body's rotation isn't pronounced enough, making the offhand move forward a bit too much;
- The main hand's rotation range is not wide enough, it doesn't ever get close to the center of the screen;
- The main hand is barely raised, regardless of the direction the player is looking at (MCPE-54697);
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is not smooth (
MCPE-50236).Original animation:
- The body rotates enough for the motion to be more lively without the offhand being too distracting;
- The main hand's movement is way more pronounced, starting wide and hitting the center of the screen before finishing;
- The main hand's motion is obvious, and also matches whichever direction the player is currently facing;
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is seamless.
Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: This can be fixed by changing the animation from this...
{{code}} "animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "variable.attack_body_rot_y", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 10.0", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 30.0", "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) ? (-90.0 * math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180)) + 30.0 : 0.0)", 0.0 ] } } }to this:
"animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(1.0 - math.pow(1.0 - variable.attack_time, 3.0) * 180.0) * 68.755 - math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -(query.target_x_rotation - 40.107) * 0.75", "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 22.9183", "math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -22.9183" ] } } }The expression math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46 is repeated in all three limbs, and can be reduced to a variable. In this case, the variable variable.attack_body_rot_y found in player.entity.json should be changed from this...
Math.sin(360*Math.sqrt(variable.attack_time)) * 5.0to this:
math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46
Current animation:
- The body's rotation isn't pronounced enough, making the offhand move forward a bit too much;
- The main hand's rotation range is not wide enough, it doesn't ever get close to the center of the screen;
- The main hand is barely raised, regardless of the direction the player is looking at (MCPE-54697);
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is not smooth (
MCPE-50236).Original animation:
- The body rotates enough for the motion to be more lively without the offhand being too distracting;
- The main hand's movement is way more pronounced, starting wide and hitting the center of the screen before finishing;
- The main hand's motion is obvious, and also matches whichever direction the player is currently facing;
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is seamless.
Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: This can be fixed by changing the animation from this...
{{code}} "animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "variable.attack_body_rot_y", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 10.0", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 30.0", "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) ? (-90.0 * math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180)) + 30.0 : 0.0)", 0.0 ] } } }to this:
"animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(1.0 - math.pow(1.0 - variable.attack_time, 3.0) * 180.0) * 68.755 - math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -(query.target_x_rotation - 40.107) * 0.75", "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 22.9183", "math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -22.9183" ] } } }The expression math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46 is repeated in all three limbs, and can be reduced to a variable. In this case, the variable variable.attack_body_rot_y found in player.entity.json should be changed from this...
Math.sin(360*Math.sqrt(variable.attack_time)) * 5.0to this:
math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46Current animation:
- The body's rotation isn't pronounced enough, making the offhand move forward a bit too much;
- The main hand's rotation range is not wide enough, it doesn't ever get close to the center of the screen;
- The main hand is barely raised, regardless of the direction the player is looking at (MCPE-54697);
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is not smooth (MCPE-133777).
Original animation:
- The body rotates enough for the motion to be more lively without the offhand being too distracting;
- The main hand's movement is way more pronounced, starting wide and hitting the center of the screen before finishing;
- The main hand's motion is obvious, and also matches whichever direction the player is currently facing;
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is seamless.
Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: This can be fixed by changing the animation from this...
{{code}} "animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "variable.attack_body_rot_y", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 10.0", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 30.0", "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) ? (-90.0 * math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180)) + 30.0 : 0.0)", 0.0 ] } } }to this:
"animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(1.0 - math.pow(1.0 - variable.attack_time, 3.0) * 180.0) * 68.755 - math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -(query.target_x_rotation - 40.107) * 0.75", "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 22.9183", "math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -22.9183" ] } } }The expression math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46 is repeated in all three limbs, and can be reduced to a variable. In this case, the variable variable.attack_body_rot_y found in player.entity.json should be changed from this...
Math.sin(360*Math.sqrt(variable.attack_time)) * 5.0to this:
math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46
Current animation:
- The body's rotation isn't pronounced enough, making the offhand move forward a bit too much;
- The main hand's rotation range is not wide enough, it doesn't ever get close to the center of the screen;
- The main hand is barely raised, regardless of the direction the player is looking at (MCPE-54697);
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is not smooth (MCPE-133777).
Original animation:
- The body rotates enough for the motion to be more lively without the offhand being too distracting;
- The main hand's movement is way more pronounced, starting wide and hitting the center of the screen before finishing;
- The main hand's motion is obvious, and also matches whichever direction the player is currently facing;
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is seamless.
Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: This can be fixed by changing the animation from this...
{{code}} "animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "variable.attack_body_rot_y", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 10.0", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 30.0", "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) ? (-90.0 * math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180)) + 30.0 : 0.0)", 0.0 ] } } }to this:
"animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(1.0 - math.pow(1.0 - variable.attack_time, 3.0) * 180.0) * 68.755- math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -(query.target_x_rotation - 40.107) * 0.75", "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) *22.9183", "math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -22.9183" ] } } }The expression math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46 is repeated in all three limbs, and can be reduced to a variable. In this case, the variable variable.attack_body_rot_y found in player.entity.json should be changed from this...
Math.sin(360*Math.sqrt(variable.attack_time)) * 5.0to this:
math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46Current animation:
- The body's rotation isn't pronounced enough, making the offhand move forward a bit too much;
- The main hand's rotation range is not wide enough, it doesn't ever get close to the center of the screen;
- The main hand is barely raised, regardless of the direction the player is looking at (MCPE-54697);
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is not smooth (MCPE-133777).
Original animation:
- The body rotates enough for the motion to be more lively without the offhand being too distracting;
- The main hand's movement is way more pronounced, starting wide and hitting the center of the screen before finishing;
- The main hand's motion is obvious, and also matches whichever direction the player is currently facing;
- The transition from the attack animation and the base pose is seamless.
Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes: This can be fixed by changing the animation from this...
{{code}} "animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "variable.attack_body_rot_y", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 10.0", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) * 1.2 + math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180)) * 30.0", "-(math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180) ? (-90.0 * math.sin((1 - math.pow((1 - variable.attack_time), 4)) * 180)) + 30.0 : 0.0)", 0.0 ] } } }to this:
"animation.player.attack.rotations" : { "loop" : true, "bones" : { "body" : { "rotation" : [ 0.0, "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0 ] }, "leftarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46", 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "rightarm" : { "rotation" : [ "math.sin(1.0 - math.pow(1.0 - variable.attack_time, 3.0) * 180.0) * 68.75 - math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -(query.target_x_rotation - 40.10) * 0.75", "math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46 * 2.0", "math.sin(variable.attack_time * 180.0) * -22.91" ] } } }The expression math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46 is repeated in all three limbs, and can be reduced to a variable. In this case, the variable variable.attack_body_rot_y found in player.entity.json should be changed from this...
Math.sin(360*Math.sqrt(variable.attack_time)) * 5.0to this:
math.sin(math.sqrt(variable.attack_time) * 360.0) * 11.46
This may relates to MCPE-47940, MCPE-47939. Since the animations for punching or mining has been partially been fixed, I've noticed a problem with it. There is one frame of the punching animation missing/cut off, as it is no longer smooth. Attachment was made before 1.13.0.5.
This issue has gotten worse in 1.13. See MCPE-47940 for updated information.
I've included the fixed animation in MCPE-47940.
The player's animation controller file defines "attack.position" and "attack.rotations" to be used whenever "variable.attack_time" is greater than or equal to 0. However, the inclusion of 0 means the animation is constantly used even when the player isn't attacking, which is not really noticeable with the vanilla animation (because of MCPE-47940) but is an inconvenience for any custom animations. This can be fixed by defining it to be used whenever "variable.attack_time" is greater than 0.
Steps to reproduce
- Apply MCPE-167696.mcpack
to a world, and open the world. - Switch to third person.
- Press attack button.
Expected result
The arm and head look normal when not attacking, then snap to a 45 degree angle during the attack and go back to their default positions after the attack is finished.
Observed result
The arm and head stay at a 45 degree angle for the entire duration of your session.
affects 1.13.0.2
Partially fixed in 1.13.0.4. Updated summary/description to describe what's currently happening.
affects 1.13.0.5
affects 1.13.0.13
still affects 1.14.30 and 1.16.0.55 Beta
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response
Is this still an issue in the latest version? If so, please make sure the ticket description contains the following information:
If your ticket does not look like the example given here, then it's likely to be closed as incomplete.
This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Mojang Support – 📧 Suggestions – 📖 Minecraft Wiki
affects 1.19.30
This report is currently missing crucial information. Please take a look at the other comments to find out what we are looking for.
If you added the required information and a moderator sees your comment, they will reopen and update the report. However, if you think your update to this report has been overlooked or you want to make sure that this report is reopened, you can contact the Mojira staff on Discord or Reddit.
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! If you think it was incorrect, please notify us on Discord or Reddit
Cleaning up old tickets: This ticket had been set to 'Awaiting Response', but has not received a response from the reporter (~3 months+) so is being closed as Incomplete. If you feel this is still a valid issue then please comment, or create a new ticket following the Issue Guidelines which includes steps to reproduce the problem.
For any account or purchasing related issues, please contact Minecraft Customer Support directly, as we cannot assist with those here at the bug tracker.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Mojang Support – 📧 Suggestions – 📖 Minecraft Wiki
Still an issue in the current versions.