Josiah Taylor
- Elnar_Ingolmo
- elnar_ingolmo
- America/Chicago
- Yes
- No
MC-111726It used to be that when you dismount from a minecart it puts you to one side. Now it puts you in the same space as the cart. This might seem good at first, but it breaks old-school minecart elevators. Please fix!
When dismounting from a minecart by pressing shift
Expected behavior: When dismounting from a minecart by pressing shift, the player should be deposited on an adjacent block if one is available.
Behavior that occurred: When dismounting from a minecart that is NOT on a rail, the player is deposited directly above the minecart, even when other valid spaces are available. This renders minecart elevators inoperable and can cause suffocation damage to the player if there is a solid block two blocks above the minecart.
Note: A minecart that is sitting on any type of rail is not affected by this bug, whether dismounting by pressing shift, breaking the cart with cactus, or using an activator rail. Only minecarts not placed on rails are affected.
Steps to reproduce:
1) Place any rail, then a minecart on the rail (with a ladder underneath the block with the rail if you are testing a minecart elevator).
2) Break the rail (and the block beneath if you want the cart sitting on a ladder).
3) Get in the minecart, then get out of the minecart.
4) Place a solid block above the block where the minecart is sitting with two air block in between to see the suffocation damage.
From the minecraft wiki: "When a minecart is exited, it searches for an adjacent or diagonal 2×2×3 area to put the player 1.5 blocks away from the cart. If none are available, the player is deposited directly above the minecart. Consequently, the player falls inside the minecart." In 1.11.2, even when there are clearly spots available, it always deposits the player directly above the minecart.
MC-110474is not applicable to this problem, since this new bug occurs in rooms higher than 2 blocks. This is NOT resolved.Thanks for the reopen, and sorry about using the wiki like that, didn't realize it wasn't official. I guess I should probably read the rules or something
Wait, what causes suffocation damage exactly?
Ah, I see what you mean. I also noticed that the bug does not occur if the minecart is on any type of rail, but only if the cart is on a block, ladder, etc. So as far as I can tell it won't affect ejecting mobs/players with activator rails or by breaking the cart with cactus, but only getting out of the top of a minecart elevator.
Henry Berger, you are not crazy. I hear the same sound and find it very annoying. I might be crazy though, as according to the official wiki this is the actual "Idle" skeleton sound and the sounds for skeletons have not been changed since 1.4.2, but I did not notice musical skeletons until 1.13. So I guess we can't report this as a bug since it is apparently the intended sound, but it's a stupid sound. I can't imagine why skeletons should make note sounds. I also have no idea why I just now noticed it if it's actually been there forever, but now that I've noticed it it's driving me mad.