MC-106324Generated villagers can have impossible Career
Some villagers have Career that their Profession doesn't allow (e.g. a Butcher with Career 3 or 4). This can be found using /entitydata.
These villagers have trades from other random professions, but according their Career (e.g. a Librarian with Career:3 can have Tool Smith's or Shepherd's trades). If Profession of the affected villager allows multiple Careers, then it's name is displayed as a "Villager".
Old description:
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
Created Issue:
When opening the Villager GUI it displays the word "Villager" instead of its respective job.
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "dimwit." While in a Fletcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Fletcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Fletcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village.
Attachments2
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "dimwit." While in a Fletcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Fletcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Fletcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "
dimwit." While in aFletcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Fletcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Fletcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
You can properly trade all villagers except the nitwit. Many have the wrong trade.
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
You can properly trade all villagers except the nitwit. Many have the wrong trade.
Off by one. :/
When opening the Villager GUI it displays the word "Villager" instead of its respective job.Generated villagers can have impossible Career
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
Some villagers have Career that their Profession doesn't allow (e.g. a )
Old description:
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
Some villagers have Career that their Profession doesn't allow (e.g. a )
Old description:
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292Some villagers have Career that their Professions doesn't allow (e.g. a Butcher with Career 3 or 4). These villagers have trades from other random professions, but according their Career (e.g. a Librarian with Career:3 can have Tool Smith's or Shepherd's trades). If Profession of the affected villager allows multiple Careers, then it's name is displayed as a "Villager".
Old description:
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
Some villagers have Career that their Profession
sdoesn't allow (e.g. a Butcher with Career 3 or 4). These villagers have trades from other random professions, but according their Career (e.g. a Librarian with Career:3 can have Tool Smith's or Shepherd's trades). If Profession of the affected villager allows multiple Careers, then it's name is displayed as a "Villager".
Old description:
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
Some villagers have Career that their Profession doesn't allow (e.g. a Butcher with Career 3 or 4). Th
ese villagers have trades from other random professions, but according their Career (e.g. a Librarian with Career:3 can have Tool Smith's or Shepherd's trades). If Profession of the affected villager allows multiple Careers, then it's name is displayed as a "Villager".
Old description:
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292Some villagers have Career that their Profession doesn't allow (e.g. a Butcher with Career 3 or 4). This can be found by using /entitydata.
These villagers have trades from other random professions, but according their Career (e.g. a Librarian with Career:3 can have Tool Smith's or Shepherd's trades). If Profession of the affected villager allows multiple Careers, then it's name is displayed as a "Villager".
Old description:
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
Some villagers have Career that their Profession doesn't allow (e.g. a Butcher with Career 3 or 4). This can be found
byusing /entitydata.These villagers have trades from other random professions, but according their Career (e.g. a Librarian with Career:3 can have Tool Smith's or Shepherd's trades). If Profession of the affected villager allows multiple Careers, then it's name is displayed as a "Villager".
Old description:
While exploring the new 1.11 snapshot. I was observing villagers and any changes including the "nitwit." While in a Butcher villager's GUI, instead of displaying "Butcher" it displayed "Villager." I found other "Butcher" villagers and they displayed the name properly. I attempted to replicate the glitch by spawning in more villagers, but I could not. The villager occurred in a naturally spawned village. The coordinates are -500, 70, -700. The seed is: -7989118705340891292
![[Mojang] Agnes Larsson](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
[Mojang] Agnes LarssonMC-106064 by user-f2760 is about no trades, MC-106324 by Muriel Tuttle is about impossible tier levels, and MC-?????? by possibly Socks will be about tier 1.
Please, add the seed and coordinates of the village
Confirmed using provided seed and coordinates
I didn't find the "Butcher" displaying "Villager", with provided seed and coordinates (may have missed one). But I did find Librarian trading string and Armorer trading wheat as well.
[~Socks], find the house from the screenshot.
Upd. Careers (differeent versions of villagers of the same colored) are set randomly, not depending on the seed. So, you probably should generate the world multiple times and seek for any other villagers of that colour.
The affected villager had it's career set to 4, while the butcher only has 2 careers: a butcher (1) itself and a leatherworker (2). You can't get it via /summon (it defaults to 1), but you can change it using /entitydata. If you do so, you get a villager "Villager", same as the one in the description.
Actually my comment was meant more to point out that now spawned Villager GUI is broken and some random villagers are spawning with the wrong Tier 1 trades as well. I didn't spend a whole lot of time looking for the Butcher once I accidentally opened the Armorer and found the trade for wheat. This may be related to
MC-106126. I'll check my snapshot test worlds and see if the issue is present there as well.There appears to be a mismatch now in generated Villagers' entitydata. I found more with wrong Tier 1 trades as well as a few with one Profession and the Career/entitydata of nitwit (unable to trade). It may happen with spawn eggs, but I didn't try it. Nor did I find a nitwit who can trade, but I wouldn't rule it out. Maybe the description should be updated to reflect more the overall problem rather than just an error in the title of one Villager.
Villagers with no trades is
MC-106064.I think you should create a new ticket about wrong Tier 1 trades.
I only reported what I found incorrect. I looked around the village after recreating the seed several times and found a cleric with two trades, one for wool and the other for shears. I also found the villager with the GUI title "Villager" again.
MC-106064by user-f2760 is about no trades,MC-106324by Muriel Tuttle is about impossible tier levels, and MC-?????? by possibly Socks will be about tier 1.I am not sure I am following everything correctly, but
@Suncat do you want me or the original reporter to open a new ticket for the wrong Tier 1 trades?
@FVbico huh???
I must have missed the ticket about no trades; I am going to assume that since FVbico reported it, I don't need to comment there
Socks, you have the issue - you make the ticket.Don't need to do it. I'm going to change this ticket after a few testsLol too late - I just did it -
MC-106362next time I'll keep my curiousity in check lol