MC-109584Observer Detecting Signal from an above Observer Outputs a Longer Pulse
EDIT: This behavior is due to Quasi-Connectivity. It likely "works as intended".
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain, without other blocks.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
The left-side pulse was longer than the right-side.
Linked Issues
Created Issue:
Observer Detecting Signal from an above Observer Outputs a Longer Pulse
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain.
In the screenshots below both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
The left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse, and it took longer to retract than the left piston.
Attachments3
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain.
In the screenshots below both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
The left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse,andit took longer toretract than theleft piston.In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston. The pulse on the left piston was longer than the right.
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.The pulse on the left piston was longer than the right.In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
The left-side pulse was longer than the right-side.
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain, without other blocks.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
The left-side pulse was longer than the right-side.
EDIT: This behavior is due to Quasi-Connectivity. This likely "works as intended".
-
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain, without other blocks.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
The left-side pulse was longer than the right-side.
EDIT: This behavior is due to Quasi-Connectivity. This likely "works as intended".
-
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain, without other blocks.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
The left-side pulse was longer than the right-side.EDIT: This behavior is due to Quasi-Connectivity. This is likely "works as intended".
-
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain, without other blocks.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
The left-side pulse was longer than the right-side.
EDIT: This behavior is due to Quasi-Connectivity.
This islikely "works as intended".-
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain, without other blocks.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
The left-side pulse was longer than the right-side.EDIT: This behavior is due to Quasi-Connectivity. It likely "works as intended".
-
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain, without other blocks.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
The left-side pulse was longer than the right-side.
EDIT: This behavior is due to Quasi-Connectivity. It likely "works as intended".
-
In 16w44a, Observers are meant to output a 1-Redstone tick signal (2 game ticks). However, this is not the case in a downward-flowing Observer Chain, without other blocks.
In the screenshots below, both foreground Sticky Pistons should only push or pull the Emerald Blocks with each pulse.
But the left-side piston pushes and pulls with the same pulse and retracts later than the right piston.
The left-side pulse was longer than the right-side.
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/grum.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)
There is quasi-connectivity involved for the left column.
Ok. Didn't see that at first. Thanks.
Perhaps this doesn't need to be fixed then. You could just replace the second to last Observer with an Activator Rail or a Fence Gate, like I did on the right side.
Works as intended?
Updated OP.