MC-129543Lava and water with fish react abnormally
The first screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava shown in the second screenshot.
Let's just assume the water source block is called Block 1, and the flowing water block is called Block 2.
What I expected:
Block 1 turning into obsidian, and lava in Block 2 disappearing (the fish being in Block 2 and generally suffocating to death).
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
Linked Issues
Created Issue:
Lava and water with fish react abnormally
Environment
The second screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava.
Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
**Block 1 turning into obsidian, and the fish dying (appearing in the lava in Block 2 and then being burned to death), while the lava in Block 2 staying still.
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
Attachments2
2018-05-13_14.16.59.png
The second screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava.
Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
**Block 1 turning into obsidian, and the fish dying (appearing in the lava in Block 2 and then being burned to death), while the lava in Block 2 staying still.
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
The second screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava.
Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
**Block 1 turning into obsidian, and the fish dying (appearing in the lava in Block 2 and then being burned to death), while the lava in Block 2 staying still.
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
The
secondscreenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava.Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
**Block 1 turning into obsidian, and the fish dying (appearing in the lava in Block 2 and then being burned to death), while the lava in Block 2 staying still.
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
The first screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava.
Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
**Block 1 turning into obsidian, and the fish dying (appearing in the lava in Block 2 and then being burned to death), while the lava in Block 2 staying still.
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
The first screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava shown in the second screenshot.
Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
**Block 1 turning into obsidian, and the fish dying (appearing in the lava in Block 2 and then being burned to death), while the lava in Block 2 staying still.
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
The first screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava shown in the second screenshot.
Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
**Block 1 turning into obsidian, and the fish dying (appearing in
thelava in Block 2 and then being burned to death), while the lava in Block 2 staying still.What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
The first screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava shown in the second screenshot.
Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
**Block 1 turning into obsidian, and the fish dying (appearing in lava in Block 2 and then being burned to death), while the lava in Block 2 staying still.What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
duplicates
The first screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava shown in the second screenshot.
Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
Block 1 turning into obsidian, and
the fish dying (appearing in lava in Block 2 and then being burned to death), while the lava in Block 2 staying still.What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
The first screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava shown in the second screenshot.
Let's just assume the block where water with fish was poured into is called Block 1, and the block beside is called Block 2.
What I expected:
Block 1 turning into obsidian, and lava in Block 2 disappearing (the fish being in Block 2 and generally suffocating to death).
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
The first screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava shown in the second screenshot.
Let's just assume the
block where water with fish was poured intois called Block 1, and theblock besideis called Block 2.What I expected:
Block 1 turning into obsidian, and lava in Block 2 disappearing (the fish being in Block 2 and generally suffocating to death).
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
The first screenshot shows what happened when a fish bucket is poured into lava shown in the second screenshot.
Let's just assume the water source block is called Block 1, and the flowing water block is called Block 2.
What I expected:
Block 1 turning into obsidian, and lava in Block 2 disappearing (the fish being in Block 2 and generally suffocating to death).
What actually happened:
Block 1 turning into water (the fish living and swimming as normal), and Block 2 turning into cobblestone.
How to reproduce:
It's obvious upon seeing the screenshots.
I don't know if it's intended. But the reaction is indeed abnormal.
But the flowing water didn't react with lava. The water source block did. And because of lacking source block, the flowing water disappeared.
I also reported this issue in MC-129434 and MC-129543. They were resolved as duplicates of MC-8930, that didn't annoy me. What actually annoyed me was that MC-8930 had been resolved as working as intended. I really can't understand why the thing works so. From any sense this doesn't follow the basic rule of reaction of contacted water and lava. I have been exclaiming my discontent and asking about the reason of the resolution all the time, but not a single person has replied me. I don't how why's that so. This is obviously a bug and once again, I really don't understand why MC-8930 was resolved as intended.
Look at MC-8930. Lava/water placed onto a single water/lava source block substitutes the water/lava source block instead of changing it into obsidian. Is this reasonable? It violates the basic rule of how water and lava should react when in contact. Should MC-8930 be resolved as WAI?
I've been questioning this all the time under MC-8930 and both my duplicates (MC-129434 and MC-129543), but none of you has responded. Usually when I have an unreasonable explanation you would rush to correct me, but no one has pointed out where I'm wrong about this particular issue, and you don't reopen MC-8930 either. I don't know why's that so.
Hope that you can carefully consider this again. Thank you!
Again, same as
MC-8930. The same reaction occurs with a normal water bucket. The lava is replaced with water (with fish) and the flowing lava turns into cobblestone.But if lava is poured down to water, then the water source is turned into obsidian and the flowing water beside disappears. May I ask why do the things change when the order is reversed, thus, water is poured down to lava?
Once the water is replaced with lava, the flowing water reacts with the lava and creates obsidian.
The flowing water was still present when the lava turned into obsidian.
Whatever. But why are
MC-8930and my duplicates intended? The issues violate the basic rule of how lava and water should react when in contact.Somebody help me? I don't understand why is it intended? Shouldn't water/lava become obsidian all the time when lava/water is directly poured onto it? Why is it not happening here? In my opinion there's no reasonable account for it.