MC-154745Pillager Outpost and Mineshaft should use Biome materials
Pillager Outposts in all biomes contain a large amount of wood. In Desert Biomes, wood is scarcer than gold. Consider making Pillager Outposts more Biome specific and using building materials and resources that are typical for the Desert Biome. (You have to ask where the Pillagers got all those birch logs from!) Similar issue with Mineshafts though that is less significant as Mineshafts are harder to find/exploit and probably more dangerous.
This has a really big balance impact on Desert Survival that was probably not anticipated?
Environment
MacOS X but probably all environments
Java 1.8.0_74 but probably all
Created Issue:
Pillager Outpost and Mineshaft should use Biome materials
Pillager Outposts in all biomes contain a large amount of wood. In Desert Biomes, wood is scarcer than gold. Consider making Pillager Outposts more Biome specific and using building materials and resources that are typical for the Desert Biome. (You have to ask where the Pillagers got all those birch logs from!) Similar issue with Mineshafts though that is less significant as Mineshafts are harder to find/exploit and probably more dangerous.
This has a really big balance impact on Desert Survival that was probably not anticipated?
Environment
MacOS X but probably all environments
Java 1.8.0_74 but probably all
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue is Invalid.
You have posted a feature request or a suggestion. This site is for bug reports only.
For suggestions, please visit Minecraft Suggestions on Reddit.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – 📖 Game Wiki
Well I thought it might have been an oversight on the part of the development team since they are quite consistent about using Biome-appropriate materials for most construction. But if you are sure it's working as designed?
So please reclassify this as Working As Designed if that's the case. Because if it's not Working As Designed, then this is a valid bug.
Pillager outposts are working as designed based on the resolution of
MC-140105, and normal mineshafts have always generated with oak since they were added before release. You have even worded your title like feature request and requested that mineshafts should use different types of wood, even though mineshafts haven't been updated in any significant way for about a decade.Thanks for the explanation and the reference to the resolved issue.
Saying "should" doesn't imply a feature request however. It hinges on whether this is working as designed. So can you mark this as Working As Designed then please?
Or alternatively, mark as a duplicate of
MC-140105which is itself marked as Working As Designed.No. Your ticket does not describe a bug in the first place and therefore is invalid.
You're welcome to suggest these changes to the developers, but the bug tracker is not the place to do so. As said above, either use /r/minecraftsuggestions or https://feedback.minecraft.net/.
That's a circular argument. If what I described was not what was designed, then it would be a bug. If it's working as designed, that's fine, but mark this as Working As Designed. Like the more or less identical
MC-140105which is marked Working As Designed. Or as a duplicate ofMC-140105. Either makes sense. Invalid does not make sense because this issue is not a feature request. If I wanted to make a feature request I would make a feature request.Your ticket is "Hey, please change pillager outposts and mineshafts, so that they have different wood types!". That's not a bug.
MC-140105is "Pillager outposts always spawn the same, while villages don't". That can be considered a bug, but the devs have clarified that it is not.In the end of the day it does not matter how a report is resolved. This ticket won't be reopened. End of discussion.