MC-256475Placing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves displays the "Block placed" subtitle
The Bug:
Placing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves displays the "Block placed" subtitle.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Ensure that you have subtitles enabled in your accessibility settings.
- Place down a chiseled bookshelf and obtain some books.
- Place and take books from the chiseled bookshelf and look at the subtitles that are produced upon you doing so.
- Take note as to whether or not placing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves displays the "Block placed" subtitle.
Observed Behavior:
Placing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves displays the "Block placed" subtitle.
Expected Behavior:
Placing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves would not display the "Block placed" subtitle. Instead, these interactions should have their own unique subtitles to correctly reflect what action is occurring.
Linked Issues
LowAttachments2
![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
ImportantCreated Issue:
"Block placed" subtitle when placing books into chiseled bookshelves.
"Block placed" subtitle when placing books into chiseled bookshelves. This makes no sense as no blocks are placed.
Attachments1
2022-10-19_14.33.05.png
"Block placed" subtitle when placing booksintochiseled bookshelves."Block placed" subtitle when placing and taking books from chiseled bookshelves.
![[Mod] ampolive](../../../data/avatars/users/18949.svg){kind=small}
"Block placed" subtitle when placing and taking books from chiseled bookshelves.
relates to
"Block placed" subtitle when placing booksintochiseled bookshelves. This makes no sense as no blocks are placed.The Bug:
Placing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves displays the "Block placed" subtitle.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Ensure that you have subtitles enabled in your accessibility settings.
- Place down a chiseled bookshelf and obtain some books.
- Place and take books from the chiseled bookshelf and look at the subtitles that are produced upon you doing so.
- Take note as to whether or not placing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves displays the "Block placed" subtitle.
Observed Behavior:
Placing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves displays the "Block placed" subtitle.
Expected Behavior:
Placing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves would not display the "Block placed" subtitle. Instead, these interactions should have their own unique subtitles to correctly reflect what action is occurring.
"Block placed" subtitle when placingandtaking books from chiseled bookshelvesPlacing or taking books from chiseled bookshelves displays the "Block placed" subtitle
![[Mojang] Moesh](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
I'd like to request a review of this report for the following reasons:
- In the past, several examples of sounds producing misleading/incorrect subtitles were triaged and later fixed, for example,
MC-256475,MC-261646,MC-166292,MC-163947,MC-177523, andMC-178130. - Following from above,
MC-204050, which is a ticket that concerns the "Block breaking" subtitle being displayed when shooting amethysts, is considered to be a valid issue by Mojang themselves, therefore one would expect this report (MC-260213) to follow the same or a similar resolution. - Having the "Block Breaking" subtitle display for sniffers' digging sounds is misleading. It indicates that a block is currently breaking, and this isn't true; the said block is actually being dug by the sniffer.
This issue has been fixed in 22w45a.
Can confirm fixed in 22w45a.