MC-272053The "armor_effectiveness" effect does not work with projectiles or indirect damage
The "minecraft:armor_effectiveness" effect in enchantments does not work with projectiles or indirect damage.
Using a datapack it is possible do a custom enchantment. If this enchantment has the "minecraft:armor_effectiveness" effect and its value is -1,
//unarmored.json //... "effects": { "minecraft:armor_effectiveness": [ { "effect": { "type": "minecraft:add", "value": -1 } } ] } //...
this will remove the entity's entire armor.
How to reproduce:
- Download a pack or create one with a custom enchantment that remove the armor and enable it.
- Summon some entities with armor (or full armor) to test.
- Give you a trident (/give @s minecraft:trident)
- Enchant an item with the custom enchantment (in this case: /enchant @s test:unarmored).
- Deal damage to the entities.
You will notice that the direct damage (melee) is ignoring the armor, but the indirect damage (projectiles) is not ignoring the armor. You can use /data get entity @e[sort=nearest,type=!minecraft:player,limit=1] Health to see their health.
Attachments2
NormalCreated Issue:
The "armor_effectiveness" effect does not work with projectiles or indirect damage
The "minecraft:armor_effectiveness" effect in enchantments does not work with projectiles or indirect damage.
Using a datapack it is possible do a custom enchantment. If this enchantment has the "minecraft:armor_effectiveness" effect and its value is -1,
//unarmored.json //... "effects": { "minecraft:armor_effectiveness": [ { "effect": { "type": "minecraft:add", "value": -1 } } ] } //...this will remove the entity's entire armor.
How to reproduce:
- Download a pack or create one with a custom enchantment that remove the armor and enable it.
- Summon some entities with armor (or full armor) to test.
- Give you a trident (/give @s minecraft:trident)
- Enchant an item with the custom enchantment (in this case: /enchant @s test:unarmored).
- Deal damage to the entities.
You will notice that the direct damage (melee) is ignoring the armor, but the indirect damage (projectiles) is not ignoring the armor. You can use /data get entity @e[sort=nearest,limit=1] Health to see their health.
Attachments3
2024-05-15_13.20.15.png
The "minecraft:armor_effectiveness" effect in enchantments does not work with projectiles or indirect damage.
Using a datapack it is possible do a custom enchantment. If this enchantment has the "minecraft:armor_effectiveness" effect and its value is -1,
//unarmored.json //... "effects": { "minecraft:armor_effectiveness": [ { "effect": { "type": "minecraft:add", "value": -1 } } ] } //...this will remove the entity's entire armor.
How to reproduce:
- Download a pack or create one with a custom enchantment that remove the armor and enable it.
- Summon some entities with armor (or full armor) to test.
- Give you a trident (/give @s minecraft:trident)
- Enchant an item with the custom enchantment (in this case: /enchant @s test:unarmored).
- Deal damage to the entities.
You will notice that the direct damage (melee) is ignoring the armor, but the indirect damage (projectiles) is not ignoring the armor. You can use /data get entity @e[sort=nearest,type=!minecraft:player,limit=1] Health to see their health.
![[Mod] Jarl-Penguin](../../../data/avatars/users/92849.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Triage Team](../../../data/avatars/users/89842.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Gegy](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
[Mojang] Gegy![[Bot] Piston](../../../data/avatars/users/31202.png){kind=small}
The skeleton wither D should have 12.0 health points, not 17.7.
Can confirm, relates to MC-272006