MC-3660Bone meal is used on any attempt for a tree to grow
Any time you try to grow a tree with bone meal, even if the tree is not grown, a bone meal is used.
To reproduce:
1. Plant sapling.
2. Restrict tree's ability to grow
3. Use bone meal on sapling
4. Keep trying until you have no more bone meal
5. Be sad
Created Issue:
Bone meal is used on any attempt for a tree to grow
Any time you try to grow a tree with bone meal, even if the tree is not grown, a bone meal is used.
To reproduce:
1. Plant sapling.
2. Restrict tree's ability to grow
3. Use bone meal on sapling
4. Keep trying until you have no more bone meal
5. Be sad
![[Mod] CubeTheThird](../../../data/assets/gravatar/cubethethird.jpeg){kind=small}
relates to
It's actually a different issue, the bonemeal gets used up as expected and the hand animation in this case is correct, the issue would be that the bonemeal is used up even though there is no result - this is intentional as per Mojang, see MC-3660 for example.
Can confirm.
I think this may be intended. The sapling needs bone meal to grow, but then it can't grow. So, it's like a failed attempt at growing, which should cost the same.
Confirmed. However, if you put 4 Jungle saplings together under some sort of roof or something, because big trees vary in height it may take a few tries to get it to work.
While consuming 1 bone meal each time it doesn't work.
I'd say this is intended.
This functionality (including the most recent comment on taking a couple tries to grow) is intended.