MC-85627Empty lines on signs rendered as "null" when upgrading 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 -> 15w32c
tl;dr: When upgrading 1.7.10 --> 1.8.8 -->15w32c empty lines on 1.7.10 signs will be rendered as null in 15w32c.
- World was right now created in 1.7.10
- in 1.8.8 single and double quotes were removed, empty lines of 1.7.10 remain empty but represented internally as null
- in 15w32c empty lines of the 1.7.10 signs render as null whereas the empty lines of the 1.8.8 signs remain empty
- Upgrade over 1.8.8 is necessary, when directly upgrading 1.7.10 -> 15w32c empty lines remain empty
| Version | NBT of empty line |
|---|---|
| 1.7.10 | |
| 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 | null |
| 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 -> 15w32c | {"text":"null"} |
| 1.8.8 | "" |
| 1.8.8 -> 15w32c | {"text":""} |
| 1.7.10 -> 15w32c | {"text":""} |
Linked Issues
is duplicated by2
Created Issue:
Sign text of empty lines rendered as "null" when upgrading 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 -> 15w32c
When upgrading 1.7.10 --> 1.8.8 -->15w32c empty lines on 1.7.10 signe will be rendered as "null" in 15w32c.
- World was right now created in 1.7.10
- in 1.8.8 single and double quotes were removed, empty lines of 1.7.10 remain empty
- in 15w32c empty lines of the 1.7.10 signs render as "null" whereas the empty lines of the 1.8.8 signs remain empty
Attachments3
2015-08-09_19.18.11.png
![[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/grum.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)Sign text of empty lines rendered as "null" when upgrading 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 -> 15w32cEmpty lines on signs rendered as "null" when upgrading 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 -> 15w32c
When upgrading 1.7.10 --> 1.8.8 -->15w32c empty lines on 1.7.10 sign
ewill be rendered as "null" in 15w32c.
- World was right now created in 1.7.10
- in 1.8.8 single and double quotes were removed, empty lines of 1.7.10 remain empty
- in 15w32c empty lines of the 1.7.10 signs render as "null" whereas the empty lines of the 1.8.8 signs remain empty
When upgrading 1.7.10 --> 1.8.8 -->15w32c empty lines on 1.7.10 signs will be rendered as "null" in 15w32c.
- World was right now created in 1.7.10
- in 1.8.8 single and double quotes were removed, empty lines of 1.7.10 remain empty
- in 15w32c empty lines of the 1.7.10 signs render as "null" whereas the empty lines of the 1.8.8 signs remain empty
When upgrading 1.7.10 --> 1.8.8 -->15w32c empty lines on 1.7.10 signs will be rendered as "null" in 15w32c.
- World was right now created in 1.7.10
- in 1.8.8 single and double quotes were removed, empty lines of 1.7.10 remain empty
- in 15w32c empty lines of the 1.7.10 signs render as "null" whereas the empty lines of the 1.8.8 signs remain empty
- Upgrade over 1.8.8 is necessary, when directly upgrading 1.7.10 -> 15w32c empty lines remain empty
When upgrading 1.7.10 --> 1.8.8 -->15w32c empty lines on 1.7.10 signs will be rendered as "null" in 15w32c.
- World was right now created in 1.7.10
- in 1.8.8 single and double quotes were removed, empty lines of 1.7.10 remain empty
- in 15w32c empty lines of the 1.7.10 signs render as "null" whereas the empty lines of the 1.8.8 signs remain empty
- Upgrade over 1.8.8 is necessary, when directly upgrading 1.7.10 -> 15w32c empty lines remain empty
Version NBT of empty line 1.7.10 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 null 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 -> 15w32c {"text":"null"} 1.8.8 "" 1.8.8 -> 15w32c {"text":""} 1.7.10 -> 15w32c {"text":""}
When upgrading 1.7.10 --> 1.8.8 -->15w32c empty lines on 1.7.10 signs will be rendered as "null" in 15w32c.
- World was right now created in 1.7.10
- in 1.8.8 single and double quotes were removed, empty lines of 1.7.10 remain empty
- in 15w32c empty lines of the 1.7.10 signs render as "null" whereas the empty lines of the 1.8.8 signs remain empty
- Upgrade over 1.8.8 is necessary, when directly upgrading 1.7.10 -> 15w32c empty lines remain empty
Version NBT of empty line 1.7.10 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 null 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 -> 15w32c {"text":"null"} 1.8.8 "" 1.8.8 -> 15w32c {"text":""} 1.7.10 -> 15w32c {"text":""}
When upgrading 1.7.10 --> 1.8.8 -->15w32c empty lines on 1.7.10 signs will be rendered as "null" in 15w32c.
- World was right now created in 1.7.10
- in 1.8.8 single and double quotes were removed, empty lines of 1.7.10 remain empty
- in 15w32c empty lines of the 1.7.10 signs render as "null" whereas the empty lines of the 1.8.8 signs remain empty
- Upgrade over 1.8.8 is necessary, when directly upgrading 1.7.10 -> 15w32c empty lines remain empty
Version NBT of empty line 1.7.10 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 null 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 -> 15w32c {"text":"null"} 1.8.8 "" 1.8.8 -> 15w32c {"text":""} 1.7.10 -> 15w32c {"text":""} tl;dr: When upgrading 1.7.10 --> 1.8.8 -->15w32c empty lines on 1.7.10 signs will be rendered as null in 15w32c.
- World was right now created in 1.7.10
- in 1.8.8 single and double quotes were removed, empty lines of 1.7.10 remain empty but represented internally as null
- in 15w32c empty lines of the 1.7.10 signs render as null whereas the empty lines of the 1.8.8 signs remain empty
- Upgrade over 1.8.8 is necessary, when directly upgrading 1.7.10 -> 15w32c empty lines remain empty
Version NBT of empty line 1.7.10 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 null 1.7.10 -> 1.8.8 -> 15w32c {"text":"null"} 1.8.8 "" 1.8.8 -> 15w32c {"text":""} 1.7.10 -> 15w32c {"text":""}
This is a duplicate of
MC-85366and may be resolved as that when no longer needed.
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
@Kumasasa
https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-88078
Unfortunately, no.
This ticket has been marked as a duplicate of MC-85627, in favor of the more general or better information provided.
[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes) what you are asking for rather sounds like MC-85627
Like I said in my comment above commands placed by setblock still default empty lines to "null". This was also the case in 1.8.8
Confirmed for
- 15w47c
Can someone please confirm this still happens, this should have been fixed some snapshots ago again.
It is not possible to fix the things that have gone wrong but the upgradepath should be fine now from both 1.7->1.9 and 1.7->1.8->1.9.
This still happens when you use to setblock a sign like this and reload :
/setblock ~ ~1 ~ standing_sign 0 replace {Text1:"{\"text\":\"TEST\"}"}This works but i think the other one should works to :
/setblock ~ ~1 ~ standing_sign 0 replace {Text1:"{\"text\":\"TEST\"}",Text2:"{\"text\":\"\"}",Text3:"{\"text\":\"\"}",Text4:"{\"text\":\"\"}"}@sekamine: This is clearly related, but create another ticket about that issue. (Edit: Someone else did :
MC-87143)Edit: Confirmed your issue.
Fix confirmed in 15w34d