MCPE-148384Trapdoor recipes for wood types don't exist in Vanilla Behavior Pack and cannot be overwritten
When trying to overwrite recipes in an addon, the 6 standard wooden trapdoor recipe identifiers are unknown. They are not included in the Vanilla Behavior Pack, Recipe folder.
The crafting recipes for Iron, Crimson, and Warped trapdoors are in the behavior pack and can be overwritten as expected.
What Happens:
Various attempts at determining the recipe IDs fail, using permutations the likes of of: trapdoor, trap_door, [wood type], [woodtype]_trapdoor, [woodtype]trapdoor, trapdoor[woodtype], and many other permutations with various logical placement or omission of underscore(s). Using the naming convention of the included trapdoors and replacing their types with the standard wood types does not work either. I've also tried it case-sensitive, and included a "_recipeId" found on the end of some old/original recipes, all with no luck.
When establishing any of these wood-type trapdoor recipes, the "two rows of 3 planks" recipe still produces a trapdoor.
What I Expect to Happen:
1) the Vanilla Behavior Pack Recipe folder should include all trapdoor recipes, considering it does contain a portion of them, or...
2) using the same naming conventions as the included trapdoor recipes, creating a new recipe for one of the 6 pre-1.16 wood-type trapdoors should overwrite the existing trapdoor recipe, and "two rows of 3 planks" no longer crafts its associated trapdoor.
Additional Information:
Other recipes seem to be missing from the official pack, as well, including Stone Brick crafting table and stonecutter recipes, Cracked Stone Brick furnace recipe,
Created Issue:
Trapdoor recipes for wood types don't exist in Vanilla Behavior Pack and cannot be overwritten
When trying to overwrite recipes in an addon, the 6 standard wooden trapdoor recipe identifiers are unknown. They are not included in the Vanilla Behavior Pack, Recipe folder.
The crafting recipes for Iron, Crimson, and Warped trapdoors are in the behavior pack and can be overwritten as expected.
What Happens:
Various attempts at determining the recipe IDs fail, using permutations the likes of of: trapdoor, trap_door, [wood type], [woodtype]_trapdoor, [woodtype]trapdoor, trapdoor[woodtype], and many other permutations with various logical placement or omission of underscore(s). Using the naming convention of the included trapdoors and replacing their types with the standard wood types does not work either.
When establishing any of these wood-type trapdoor recipes, the "two rows of 3 planks" recipe still produces a trapdoor.
What I Expect to Happen:
1) the Vanilla Behavior Pack Recipe folder should include all trapdoor recipes, considering it does contain a portion of them, or...
2) using the same naming conventions as the included trapdoor recipes, creating a new recipe for one of the 6 wood-type trapdoors should overwrite the existing trapdoor recipe, and "two rows of 3 planks" no longer crafts its associated trapdoor.
![[MCQA] Bartłomiej Słodkowski](../../../data/avatars/users/18941.svg){kind=small}
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
![[MCQA] Justyna Oleś](../../../data/avatars/users/18934.svg){kind=small}
![[Mod] CubeTheThird](../../../data/assets/gravatar/cubethethird.jpeg){kind=small}
![[MCQA] v-magwar](../../../data/avatars/users/18935.svg){kind=small}
When trying to overwrite recipes in an addon, the 6 standard wooden trapdoor recipe identifiers are unknown. They are not included in the Vanilla Behavior Pack, Recipe folder.
The crafting recipes for Iron, Crimson, and Warped trapdoors are in the behavior pack and can be overwritten as expected.
What Happens:
Various attempts at determining the recipe IDs fail, using permutations the likes of of: trapdoor, trap_door, [wood type], [woodtype]_trapdoor, [woodtype]trapdoor, trapdoor[woodtype], and many other permutations with various logical placement or omission of underscore(s). Using the naming convention of the included trapdoors and replacing their types with the standard wood types does not work either. I've also tried it case-sensitive, and included a "_recipeId" found on the end of some old/original recipes, all with no luck.
When establishing any of these wood-type trapdoor recipes, the "two rows of 3 planks" recipe still produces a trapdoor.
What I Expect to Happen:
1) the Vanilla Behavior Pack Recipe folder should include all trapdoor recipes, considering it does contain a portion of them, or...
2) using the same naming conventions as the included trapdoor recipes, creating a new recipe for one of the 6 pre-1.16 wood-type trapdoors should overwrite the existing trapdoor recipe, and "two rows of 3 planks" no longer crafts its associated trapdoor.
When trying to overwrite recipes in an addon, the 6 standard wooden trapdoor recipe identifiers are unknown. They are not included in the Vanilla Behavior Pack, Recipe folder.
The crafting recipes for Iron, Crimson, and Warped trapdoors are in the behavior pack and can be overwritten as expected.
What Happens:
Various attempts at determining the recipe IDs fail, using permutations the likes of of: trapdoor, trap_door, [wood type], [woodtype]_trapdoor, [woodtype]trapdoor, trapdoor[woodtype], and many other permutations with various logical placement or omission of underscore(s). Using the naming convention of the included trapdoors and replacing their types with the standard wood types does not work either. I've also tried it case-sensitive, and included a "_recipeId" found on the end of some old/original recipes, all with no luck.
When establishing any of these wood-type trapdoor recipes, the "two rows of 3 planks" recipe still produces a trapdoor.
What I Expect to Happen:
1) the Vanilla Behavior Pack Recipe folder should include all trapdoor recipes, considering it does contain a portion of them, or...
2) using the same naming conventions as the included trapdoor recipes, creating a new recipe for one of the 6 pre-1.16 wood-type trapdoors should overwrite the existing trapdoor recipe, and "two rows of 3 planks" no longer crafts its associated trapdoor.
Additional Information:
Other recipes seem to be missing from the official pack, as well, including Stone Brick crafting table and stonecutter recipes, Cracked Stone Brick furnace recipe,
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response.
Is this still an issue in the latest version? If yes, can you please add it to the affected versions (or mention it if you are not the reporter)?
This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.
Quick Links:
π Issue Guidelines – π¬ Mojang Support – π§ Suggestions – π Minecraft Wiki
Trapdoor recipe, along with a handful of other "original" recipes (torches, etc) are still not available in the official Vanilla Behavior Pack download.
Cleaning up old tickets: This ticket has not been updated recently (~3 months+) so is being closed as Cannot Reproduce. If you feel this is still a valid issue then please comment, or create a new ticket following the [Issue Guidelines|https://aka.ms/MCBugTrackerHelp].
Just checked the most recent Beta behaviour pack available (1.19.40.22) and the old wood type trapdoor recipes, torch recipes, and a few others are unavailable. This means the recipe ID is unavailable to be overwritten or disabled.
Please reopen this ticket. Issue is still present in most recent 1.19.40 beta.
Have a look at the Resolution and the comments to see why this ticket has been resolved. If you think this ticket has been resolved erroneously you can contact the Mojira staff on Discord or Reddit.
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! If you think it was incorrect, please notify us on Discord or Reddit
Reopened as requested.
Could you please provide an addon showcasing the issue?
To make your bug report as effective as possible, please try and include the following steps to reproduce the problem:
This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.
Quick Links:
π Issue Guidelines – π¬ Mojang Support – π Project Summary – π§ Suggestions – π Minecraft Wiki
There isn't an addon because the content is MISSING from the official documentation. It can easily be verified by simply looking in the official creator content behavior and resource packs that contain the actual Minecraft files, as there are no recipes given to allow one to π°π·π¦π³πΈπ³πͺπ΅π¦ trapdoors other than the new wood types (warped, crimson, mangrove, bamboo, with iron available, too), and a few other "og" staples (like torches) as well.
In one of the more recent official behavior packs (after recipe unlocking was introduced), previously missing torch recipes are now available, albeit with an odd identifier: "minecraft:Torch_recipeId" and "minecraft:Torch_charcoal_recipeId", to a point where removing the crafting table tags does indeed remove it from being craftable (i.e. works as expected).
With that in mind and renewed hope, I revisited the trapdoor recipes with other names, such as trapdoor_recipeId, Trapdoor_recipeId, [woodtype]_Trapdoor_recipeId, etc, but to no avail.
That being said, this still affects 1.20.15