MCPE-40927Marsh areas do not generate in swamp biomes
Still affects 1.13.0.2 beta
Of course I checked first if it is intended, but I wasn’t able to find any sources of they where removed, I checked almost all changelogs. So It is most likely a bug. Because they always say If they remove something in the changelog.
Steps to Reproduce
1 enter the seed 1411648432
2 teleport to
x: 183
y: 63
z: 0
Observed result:
No flat terrain with puddles within swamp
Expected result:
In the swamp, there are some areas with flat terrain.
As I am an IOS player, I can not check older versions of the game, but I know that in 1.0 the puddles already were absent. So at least the bug affects 1.0 onward
As well I can’t not take any photos of the earlier swamp terrain, so I have to copy photos from the internet.
![[MCPE Mod] Auldrick](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Marsh areas do not generate in swamp biomes
Still affects 1.9.0.5 beta
What should generate:
Some parts of the swamp biome generates typical one-block deep lakes in swamp, often covered with lily padsWhat happens instead:
Only the bigger lakes and flat terrain without those lakes generate.How to reproduce:
Enter the seed 1411648432 and tp to 183-63-0.
In older versions it shows the one-block deep lakes, but in 1.2 +, it generate flatland with no small lakes instead.
Thus on 1.2 + onward it do not generate.Extra info to reproduce:
In 1.7.2 on Java they were removed, and added back in a snapshot of 1.8, but on bedrock edition it is not stated in a change log of a beta that it was removed, thus I think it must be a bug.
Attachments4
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/assets/gravatar/mustek2.png){kind=small}
Still affects 1.9.0.5 beta
What should generate:
Some parts of the swamp biome generates typical one-block deep lakes in swamp, often covered with lily padsWhat happens instead:
Only the bigger lakes and flat terrain without those lakes generate.How to reproduce:
Enter the seed 1411648432 and tp to 183-63-0.
In older versions it shows the one-block deep lakes, but in 1.2 +, it generate flatland with no small lakes instead.
Thus on 1.2 + onward it do not generate.Extra info to reproduce:
In 1.7.2 on Java they were removed, and added back in a snapshot of 1.8, but on bedrock edition it is not stated in a change log of a beta that it was removed, thus I think it must be a bug.Edit:
Checked 1.0 +, was also affected.
![[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells)](../../../data/avatars/users/92696.png){kind=small}
Still affects 1.
9.0.5betaWhat should generate:
Some parts of the swamp biome generates typical one-block deep lakes in swamp, often covered with lily padsWhat happens instead:
Only the bigger lakes and flat terrain without those lakes generate.How to reproduce:
Enter the seed 1411648432 and tp to 183-63-0.
In older versions it shows the one-block deep lakes, but in 1.2 +, it generate flatland with no small lakes instead.
Thus on 1.2 + onward it do not generate.Extra info to reproduce:
In 1.7.2 on Java they were removed, and added back in a snapshot of 1.8, but on bedrock edition it is not stated in a change log of a beta that it was removed, thus I think it must be a bug.Edit:
Checked 1.0 +, was also affected.Still affects 1.11.0.9 beta
What should generate:
Some parts of the swamp biome generates typical one-block deep lakes in swamp, often covered with lily padsWhat happens instead:
Only the bigger lakes and flat terrain without those lakes generate.How to reproduce:
Enter the seed 1411648432 and tp to 183-63-0.
In older versions it shows the one-block deep lakes, but in 1.2 +, it generate flatland with no small lakes instead.
Thus on 1.2 + onward it do not generate.Extra info to reproduce:
In 1.7.2 on Java they were removed, and added back in a snapshot of 1.8, but on bedrock edition it is not stated in a change log of a beta that it was removed, thus I think it must be a bug.Edit:
Checked 1.0 +, was also affected.
Still affects 1.1
1.0.9betaWhat should generate:
Some parts of the swamp biome generates typical one-block deep lakes in swamp, often covered with lily padsWhat happens instead:
Only the bigger lakes and flat terrain without those lakes generate.How to reproduce:
Enter the seed 1411648432 and tp to 183-63-0.
In older versions it shows the one-block deep lakes, but in 1.2 +, it generate flatland with no small lakes instead.
Thus on 1.2 + onward it do not generate.Extra info to reproduce:
In 1.7.2 on Java they were removed, and added back in a snapshot of 1.8, but on bedrock edition it is not stated in a change log of a beta that it was removed, thus I think it must be a bug.Edit:
Checked 1.0 +, was also affected.Still affects 1.13.0.2 beta
Of course I checked first if it is intended, but I wasn’t able to find any sources of they where removed, I checked almost all changelogs. So It is most likely a bug. Because they always say If they remove something in the changelog.
How to reproduce:
- 1 enter the seed 1411648432
- 2 teleport to
x: 183
y :63
Z: 0- 3 search for the marsh terrain, but you can not find them there.
What I expected:
In swamps, the flat terrain with the small puddles with Lily pads everywhere
What happened instead:
I searched everywhere, also other seeds, but no flat terrain with puddlesAs I am an IOS player, I can not check older versions of the game, but I know that in 1.0 the puddles already were absent. So at least the bug affects 1.0 onward
As well I can’t not take any photos of the earlier swamp terrain, so I have to copy photos from the internet.
Still affects 1.13.0.2 beta
Of course I checked first if it is intended, but I wasn’t able to find any sources of they where removed, I checked almost all changelogs. So It is most likely a bug. Because they always say If they remove something in the changelog.
How to reproduce:
- 1 enter the seed 1411648432
- 2 teleport to
x: 183
y :63
Z: 0- 3 search for the marsh terrain, but you can not find them there.
What I expected:
In swamps, the flat terrain with the small puddles with Lily pads everywhere
What happened instead:
I searched everywhere, also other seeds, but no flat terrain with puddlesAs I am an IOS player, I can not check older versions of the game, but I know that in 1.0 the puddles already were absent. So at least the bug affects 1.0 onward
As well I can’t not take any photos of the earlier swamp terrain, so I have to copy photos from the internet.Still affects 1.13.0.2 beta
Of course I checked first if it is intended, but I wasn’t able to find any sources of they where removed, I checked almost all changelogs. So It is most likely a bug. Because they always say If they remove something in the changelog.
Steps to Reproduce
1 enter the seed 1411648432
2 teleport to
x: 183
y: 63
z: 0Observed result:
No flat terrain with puddles within swampExpected result:
In the swamp, there are some areas with flat terrain.
As I am an IOS player, I can not check older versions of the game, but I know that in 1.0 the puddles already were absent. So at least the bug affects 1.0 onward
As well I can’t not take any photos of the earlier swamp terrain, so I have to copy photos from the internet.
![[Mod] OcelotOnesie](../../../data/avatars/users/43220.png){kind=small}
Please do not mark unreleased versions as affected.
You don't have access to them yet.
OK
Thanx for answer
That was not a response from a dev. That was from an A.I. correcting your mistake.
As for the bug, I think I know what you are talking about, and can confirm that the marsh areas do not generate, assuming we are on the same page
1. I would not expect to see anything in a changelog related to this issue. Yes, "they always say If they remove something in the changelog", but this isn't a case of something being removed because what you're calling a marsh isn't a separate thing in the game, it's just an aspect of how world generation creates a swamp biome. Also, the devs make minor changes to world generation fairly often, trying to reduce odd terrain forms and make the world more natural seeming. These changes usually only affect new chunk generation, so they don't alter gameplay and therefore aren't mentioned in the changelog.
2. I don't understand how the screenshots you provide are meant to illustrate the problem. Two of them show ample examples of puddles on flat swampland, and the other two only show part of a swamp where a village extends into it. It's perfectly normal for a swamp to include puddle-free land above the water level, depending on how the terrain happens to generate. So I can't see the issue you're describing in these pictures.
3. I followed your reproduction steps in a new world in 1.12.1. After teleporting to the coordinates you gave, I was on flat terrain with swamp-color grass, with a puddle directly in front of me:
I believe you should get the same result in either 1.12 or the 1.13 Beta. If you don't, please add a screenshot showing what you see there.
Resolving as Incomplete due to no response.