batmanstanley
- batmanstanley
- JIRAUSER774633
- Europe/Stockholm
- Yes
- No
3 issues
Key
Summary
Status
Reporter
Assignee
Created
REALMS-11723
MCPE-180698
Deleted Comment:
I believe the title can be changed from Add-ons to resource packs.
Deleted Comment:
Another way of reproducing this is using a high amount of large resource packs and/or add-ons.
Added Attachments:
This happens in your regular world along with realms if you use an excessive amount of addons.
It affects Blocks, UI, Skybox, and Entitys/Players.
Any update yet? Even after the 1.20.80 update this bug still persists.
@KR_ I believe the limit is in the 14-18 range as when you go over the amount with resource packs. You cannot copy/download a realm at that threshold. My personal realms limit was 14 packs but it may depend on other factors as well. It also may not just be addons that cause this.
do you have experiments enabled?
My limit is 18 resource packs active at once. I believe it may have to do with bedrocks rendering software "renderdragon" not having enough space/memory available to meet with the usage of add-ons and texture packs. This limit is the same no matter what. The only fix is the not using the add-ons/texture packs. I'm not saying it only happens when you use both as it does happen when you only use add-ons but I'm combining them due to both being considered "resource packs". maybe if they were able to lift the cap depending on certain specs or a setting to give it more could be a solution.
@exhila the experimental toggle just allows until the threshold is reached due to system limitations. the error would still happen just now it would be at a lesser rate. maybe there is some enhancements renderdragon could get to help alleviate it more?
This error seems to be remerging on my realm, it only has marketplace add-ons as well as the most recent version. could it have just been harder to encounter or less common? Its happening with 2 different players with different ones not appearing for each person.
An Offender i have is the XP Games furniture add-on. Though tinkers construct, more blocks, waystones, and roads + Add-on are doing it as well. The fact that Add-ons are breaking so much in realms is depressing.
After looking into new comments on
REALMS-11696. The Only platform this is happening on anymore is Xbox. It might just be the Series X, or more of the consoles. I hope the technical things get overhauled.This issue has spiraled even more with Add-ons that were perfectly working now not appearing anymore. This is after updating to 1.21.2 that had released on 7/9/2024. This has also completely removed my Add-ons in resource packs and behavior packs from my realm. Though they are still "Active" just not toggleable.
My question is why isn't this a hotfix issue? Its a system in the game not properly working making it highly disruptive.
@GreasyBat735419 The reason mobile/pocket edition cant have this bug is just due to it not being able to handle the addons in mass.
I have heard that it has to do with the texture atlas the game uses maybe some changes to this could fix the issue?
P.S Realms isnt fixed
As i have reported many times before i believe this issue is with how Minecraft's rendering system/Renderdragon handles textures and texture memory/storage. As what this glitch essentially is blocks not having a texture rendered. The reason its a big issue is that its effecting vanilla blocks ,ui and the death screen. It happens when your system/Renderdragon has used the maximum memory it can and assigns any new loaded block/menu that is encountered after the limit is reached to the pink texture. Removing the memory limit makes it less common but it can still happen. But as add-ons add more things that use memory the issue can become common with them. The issue is entirely Minecraft's issue as it is a error with textures and how they are assigned. Another reason why our first guesses at it being add-ons were wrong were that Add-ons sizes vary. If you combine more large load add-ons you can expect to see it more. But its not the true cause.
The easiest fix is increasing the texture limit, or making the textures be processed in a way that would make a texture limit obsolete.
They are encrypted to prevent private server use and piracy. If they are able to integrate them with Server hosts other than realms it might help alleviate the problem as i believe it is a resource allocation problem with realms.
Even with the texture limit removed this persists. Is the game throttling its own memory cause its ridiculous next gen consoles are facing these issues.
Could be reproduced with using mb excessive addons. (Decocraft,Spongebob,Furniture By XP Games) Time played isn't the main dependent but memory space is. If a Xbox series x is having issues with this its clear that something is wrong under the hood that they avoid addressing.
Here is what happens sometimes joining a realm with the amount that produces this texture error not even loading into the world. All marketplace add-ons, With the official 10 player realm options. Having texture limit off on the Xbox series X. Its insulting that they do weekly Add-on drops yet do nothing to fix an issue since before the release of them that has been more common due to the release of Add-ons.
The limit is not far fetched as other games do have a similar limit.
While it is not exactly a texture error games like fallout and skyrim that allow mods on console as similar as add-ons also have a download and usage limit. i wasn't saying the error is common practice but the limit itself is in the few allowances of mods/add-ons. Fallout as well has payed content similar to add-ons that costs their currency that is pooled into the 3rd party mods limit. While i do find it ridiculous a block game has the most issues with texture in the modern day. It is one of the few games that allow mods/3rd party additions. B4 this gets deleted cause its off topic. The only other games that does this is fallout and skyrim, and even then texture errors happen sometimes.