MC-143716/replaceitem allows incongruous slot types
The bug
The /replaceitem command allows in general incongruous slot types, e.g. you can use inventory.X for a container (where you should use container.X), see MC-143663.
This can result in targeting the wrong slot and the mistake is often not obvious.
The expected behavior would be that the slot is validated based on the targeted entity or block and the command would fail executing if the wrong slot type is used.
How to reproduce
- Place a chest
- Use inventory.X as slot
/replaceitem block ~1 ~ ~ inventory.0 stone
→
The command is executed and the stone is placed in the second row
Created Issue:
/replaceitem allows incongruous slots types
The bug
The /replaceitem allows in general incongruous slot types, e.g. you can use inventory.X for a container (where you should use container.X), see
MC-143663.
This can result in targeting the wrong slot and the mistake is often not obvious.The expected behavior would be that the slot is validated based on the targeted entity or block and the command would fail executing if the wrong slot type is used.
How to reproduce
- Place a chest
- Use inventory.X as slot
/replaceitem block ~1 ~ ~ inventory.0 stone→
/replaceitem allows incongruous slotstypes
relates to
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
The bug
The /replaceitem command allows in general incongruous slot types, e.g. you can use inventory.X for a container (where you should use container.X), see
MC-143663.
This can result in targeting the wrong slot and the mistake is often not obvious.The expected behavior would be that the slot is validated based on the targeted entity or block and the command would fail executing if the wrong slot type is used.
How to reproduce
- Place a chest
- Use inventory.X as slot
/replaceitem block ~1 ~ ~ inventory.0 stone→
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Adrian Östergård](../../../data/assets/gravatar/nighter.jpeg){kind=small}
I created MC-143716 for that now, please comment on it if you want to become the reporter.