MC-200813Mobs are not longer spawning on the trapdoors (closed, top position)
Previously mobs were spawning on the trapdoors while these were closed and in top position. In 1.16.3 that got broken
Spawn still works as expected for slabs in top position. Reproduced on servers and in singleplayer (tested in flat world )
Environment
1.16.3, both server and singleplayer
Created Issue:
Mobs are not longer spawning on the trapdoors (closed, top position)
Previously mobs were spawning on the trapdoors while these were closed and in top position. In 1.16.3 that got broken
Spawn still works as expected for slabs in top position. Reproduced on servers and in singleplayer (tested in flat world )
Environment
1.16.3, both server and singleplayer
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
This bug report was incorrectly 'fixed' it should of fixed the broken wood trapdoors to spawn mobs on top of them like they always use to spawn there. Also new bug report to address this problem. MC-200813
I don't believe closed trapdoors were ever valid spawning spaces in the unmodified game?
Maybe I used wrong words in description, I hope attached screenshot gonna help
Trapdoors and slabs are on the same level here, but spawning works only on slabs. Previously it worked on trapdoors too
Please define what you mean by "previously".
In 1.16.1 it worked for sure (at least on iron trapdoors, I've created passive spawn farm using them). And don't remember any troubles in 1.16.2
No, it did not, see screenshot.
You have posted a feature request or a suggestion. This site is for bug reports only.
For suggestions, visit the Feedback website, or visit Minecraft Suggestions on Reddit.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 🛠 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
💬 Mojira Subreddit – 💬 Mojira Discord
Please reopen this bug report as the spawning is still broken since the incorrect 'fixing' of this bug report
MC-181233Hostile mobs no longer spawn on top of top trapdoors. Mobs would always spawn on top before this was broken by mistake. Here you can see them spawning on top of a similar property block, piston heads.
Should I make new bug report? or can this be reopened?
If you have a good and sensible indication or reason that the resolution of
MC-181233was "incorrect", feel free to do so, and include that in your bug report. However, to me it seems very much intentional that mobs no longer spawn on closed trap doors, so I'd expect that bug report to be resolved as either WAI or Invalid (due to being a feature request).