MC-218194Mushrooms use less bone meal to grow than saplings
The Bug
I have noticed fungi and mushrooms tend to use less bone meal than saplings. This is probably because they have no second stage of growth that saplings do have. This doesn't seem intentional as one of the 1.5 updates nerfed bone meal significantly, but inconsistently.
After some testing, it took an average of roughly 1 1/2 bone meal per mushroom, and over 3 bone meal per sapling I am not asking that a second stage of growth is added, I am just noting there is an inconsistency, and that it could be dealt with by balancing probabilities of growth for either or both saplings or mushrooms
Reproduce
- Place a sapling
- Bone meal the sapling
- Take note of how many times it took for the tree to grow
- Do the same thing with a mushroom
Observed Result
The mushroom seem to take less bone meal to grow
Expected Result
It would take the same amount of bone meal to grow
Created Issue:
Mushrooms use less bone meal to grow than saplings
I have noticed fungi and mushrooms tend to use less bone meal than saplings. This is probably because they have no second stage of growth that saplings do have. This doesn't seem intentional as one of the 1.5 updates nerfed bone meal significantly, but inconsistently.
I have noticed fungi and mushrooms tend to use less bone meal than saplings. This is probably because they have no second stage of growth that saplings do have. This doesn't seem intentional as one of the 1.5 updates nerfed bone meal significantly, but inconsistently.
I am not asking that a second stage of growth is added, I am just noting there is an inconsistency, and that it could be dealt with by balancing probabilities of growth for either or both saplings or mushrooms
I have noticed fungi and mushrooms tend to use less bone meal than saplings. This is probably because they have no second stage of growth that saplings do have. This doesn't seem intentional as one of the 1.5 updates nerfed bone meal significantly, but inconsistently.
I am not asking that a second stage ofgrowth is added, I am just noting there is an inconsistency, and that it could be dealt with by balancing probabilities of growth for either or both saplings or mushroomsI have noticed fungi and mushrooms tend to use less bone meal than saplings. This is probably because they have no second stage of growth that saplings do have. This doesn't seem intentional as one of the 1.5 updates nerfed bone meal significantly, but inconsistently.
After some testing, it took an average of roughly 1 1/2 bone meal per mushroom, and over 3 bone meal per sapling
I am not asking that a second stage of growth is added, I am just noting there is an inconsistency, and that it could be dealt with by balancing probabilities of growth for either or both saplings or mushrooms
![[Mod] markderickson](../../../data/avatars/users/18946.svg){kind=small}
![[Mod] Anthony Cicinelli](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
I have noticed fungi and mushrooms tend to use less bone meal than saplings. This is probably because they have no second stage of growth that saplings do have. This doesn't seem intentional as one of the 1.5 updates nerfed bone meal significantly, but inconsistently.
After some testing, it took an average of roughly 1 1/2 bone meal per mushroom, and over 3 bone meal per sapling
I am not asking that a second stage of growth is added, I am just noting there is an inconsistency, and that it could be dealt with by balancing probabilities of growth for either or both saplings or mushrooms
The Bug
I have noticed fungi and mushrooms tend to use less bone meal than saplings. This is probably because they have no second stage of growth that saplings do have. This doesn't seem intentional as one of the 1.5 updates nerfed bone meal significantly, but inconsistently.
After some testing, it took an average of roughly 1 1/2 bone meal per mushroom, and over 3 bone meal per sapling I am not asking that a second stage of growth is added, I am just noting there is an inconsistency, and that it could be dealt with by balancing probabilities of growth for either or both saplings or mushroomsReproduce
- Place a sapling
- Bone meal the sapling
- Take note of how many times it took for the tree to grow
- Do the same thing with a mushroom
Observed Result
The mushroom seem to take less bone meal to grow
Expected Result
It would take the same amount of bone meal to grow
![[Mod] Jarl-Penguin](../../../data/avatars/users/92849.png){kind=small}
This could be intentional
Could be but seems more like an oversight to me
Probably because mushrooms and fungus don't grow naturally while saplings do?
It's because bone meal has an equal chance to advance growth by one stage; however, saplings have two stages and mushrooms and fungus only have one.
I mean I think fungus and mushrooms only have one stage because they do not grow naturally.