MC-268381Player attack sounds play when it isn't supposed to
The sound "minecraft:entity.player.attack.weak" and "minecraft:entity.player.attack.knockback" is played when the player attacks any entity that is currently invulnerable. Currently this sound is supposed to be played when the player attacks any entity with an attack that isn't fully charged to indicate that the attack dealt less damage than it can or when a attack is made that dealt substantial knockback to another entity.
This leads to where it can occur quite often in situations such as:
-> When the player attacks any entity during a invincibility tick. This is most notable when attack speed is set to a high number to remove the cooldown and the player continuously attacks another entity, creating a deafening noise.
-> When the player attacks any entity that is set as invulnerable.
-> The player is on the same team as another person and they cannot receive damage.
-> Servers where large groups of players congregate and do not have pvp enabled.
Linked Issues
Created Issue:
The player attack weak sound is played when it isn't supposed to.
The sound "minecraft:entity.player.attack.weak" is played when the player attacks any entity that is currently invulnerable. Currently this sound is supposed to be played when the player attacks any entity with an attack that isn't fully charged to indicate that the attack dealt less damage than it can.
This leads to where it can occur quite often in situations such as:
-> When the player attacks any entity during a invincibility tick. This is most notable when attack speed is set to a high number to remove the cooldown and the player continuously attacks another entity, creating a deafening noise.
-> When the player attacks any entity that is set as invulnerable.
-> The player is on the same team as another person and they cannot receive damage.
-> Servers where large groups of players congregate and do not have pvp enabled.
The player attackweaksoundis playedwhen it isn't supposed to.Player attack sounds play when it isn't supposed to
The sound "minecraft:entity.player.attack.weak" is played when the player attacks any entity that is currently invulnerable. Currently this sound is supposed to be played when the player attacks any entity with an attack that isn't fully charged to indicate that the attack dealt less damage than it can.
This leads to where it can occur quite often in situations such as:
-> When the player attacks any entity during a invincibility tick. This is most notable when attack speed is set to a high number to remove the cooldown and the player continuously attacks another entity, creating a deafening noise.
-> When the player attacks any entity that is set as invulnerable.
-> The player is on the same team as another person and they cannot receive damage.
-> Servers where large groups of players congregate and do not have pvp enabled.The sound "minecraft:entity.player.attack.weak" and "minecraft:entity.player.attack.knockback" is played when the player attacks any entity that is currently invulnerable. Currently this sound is supposed to be played when the player attacks any entity with an attack that isn't fully charged to indicate that the attack dealt less damage than it can.
This leads to where it can occur quite often in situations such as:
-> When the player attacks any entity during a invincibility tick. This is most notable when attack speed is set to a high number to remove the cooldown and the player continuously attacks another entity, creating a deafening noise.
-> When the player attacks any entity that is set as invulnerable.
-> The player is on the same team as another person and they cannot receive damage.
-> Servers where large groups of players congregate and do not have pvp enabled.
The sound "minecraft:entity.player.attack.weak" and "minecraft:entity.player.attack.knockback" is played when the player attacks any entity that is currently invulnerable. Currently this sound is supposed to be played when the player attacks any entity with an attack that isn't fully charged to indicate that the attack dealt less damage than it can or when a attack is made that dealt substantial knockback to another entity.
This leads to where it can occur quite often in situations such as:
-> When the player attacks any entity during a invincibility tick. This is most notable when attack speed is set to a high number to remove the cooldown and the player continuously attacks another entity, creating a deafening noise.
-> When the player attacks any entity that is set as invulnerable.
-> The player is on the same team as another person and they cannot receive damage.
-> Servers where large groups of players congregate and do not have pvp enabled.
![[Mod] turbo](../../../data/avatars/users/92867.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Maxime Lebrot](../../../data/avatars/users/18941.svg){kind=small}
duplicates
Duplicates
MC-93086, which is WAI.I'm not entirely sure though if the remainder of the bug would fall under WAI though? This happens during invulnerability frames. Whilst the other bug report only mentions explicitly invulnerable players or entities where it is explicitly made so the entity cannot take damage
Iframes are different.
I would then first suggest then that the situations which duplicate
MC-93086be removed from the issue because case #2 and #3 are directly stated in the bullets points, and to just focus on case #1 only.Though, I'm still not entirely sure how iframes are different than other cases of invulnerability since both result in the entity being invincible/invulnerable. Since the issue was confirmed, Mojang can decide that.
There is specifically a "no damage" contact sound, that's the one you're hearing. WAI
I would let Mojang determine if this is WAI as they have already confirmed the bug and not marked it as WAI. Furthermore in my previous comment this affects iframes as well as other cases outside explicitly invulnerable mobs. I don't think a deafening annoying noise would be WAI.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in
MC-93086, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support (Technical Issues) – 📧 Microsoft Support (Account Issues)
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! The ticket was resolved by one of our moderators, and I left this message to give more information to you.