MC-49728You can swim up in water that is enclosed in cactus if you go to the edge of one of the sides of it - collision glitch
You can swim up in water that is enclosed in cactus, therefore it has to do with collision.
Reproduction
1. Make cactus hole by enclosing cactus.
2. Pour water inside cactus
3. Go to the edge of one of the cactus and you will be affected by water.
Environment
Java 7, AMD HD5450, Win7 Pro and i7 3770k CPU
Created Issue:
You can swim up in water that is enclosed in cactus - collision glitch
You can swim up in water that is enclosed in cactus, therefore it has to do with collision.
Reproduction
1. Make cactus hole by enclosing cactus.
2. Pour water inside cactus
3. Go to the edge of one of the cactus and you will be affected by water.Environment
Java 7, AMD HD5450, Win7 Pro and i7 3770k CPU
Attachments1
Changed Summary:
You can swim up in water that is enclosed in cactus if you go to the edge of one of the sides of it - collision glitch
Added Attachments:
Added Attachments:
Added Affects Versions: 14w18b
Added Assignee: ![[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/searge.png)
[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke)
[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke)
I don't get the bug here ?
Of course you can swim up in water enclosed by cacti like you can swim up in water enclosed by any other block.
If I get in "the edge" like you said, the cactus will hurt me
Confirmed for 14w10b
Confirmed what ? I fail to see a bug here.
When you walk towards enclosed water, you're affected by it although there are cacti.
This happens also with chests and should happen with any block that is slightly smaller than one block length.
This is not a bug, cactus is not a full block, like chests and anvils.
Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version 14w18b / Launcher version 1.3.11 or later? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.
Confirmed for both 1.7.9 and 14w19a.
Again, this is not a bug, cactus, chest and fence are blocks that aren't a full block. It is only logical that you can interact with what's behind it. This is probably most understandable for fences, you can see that you'r actually in the water when walking up against them. Same goes for chest and cactus, but now you are only touching the water a little bit.
But it is right that you are able to swim up in water of which only approximately 2.5 inches affect you? Pretty sure: no.
In minecraft: yes. If you stand in lava for 2.5 inches it also burns you. And if you were to change it, then what would be the limit?
Half of your body? The very middle of your player should be affected by the water. But that is not the point of this ticket, since it would be a feature request.
The only way of proving its intention is by awaiting Mojang's official handling concerning this ticket. You and me are both unable to say what is true. Just wanted to share my thoughts in this topic.