MC-57884Coarse dirt & Podzol turns to regular dirt after tree grows on it
1. Plant a sapling on coarse dirt, either bonemeal it or wait until it grows.
2. Chop down tree.
3. The coarse dirt has been replaced by regular dirt.
Linked Issues
![[Mojang] Jeb (Jens Bergensten)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/jeb.jpeg){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Coarse dirt turns to regular dirt after tree grows on it
1. Plant a sapling on coarse dirt, either bonemeal it or wait until it grows.
2. Chop down tree.
3. The coarse dirt has been replaced by regular dirt.
Attachments2
2014-06-19_15.26.04.png
Coarse dirt & Podzol turns to regular dirt after tree grows on it
is duplicated by
![[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/searge.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke)A comment with security level 'global-moderators' was removed.
Broken resource pack. Please switch to the default resource pack, and see if it occurs there.
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Torabi](../../../data/assets/gravatar/torabi.png){kind=small}
relates to
@Blah Resource packs aren't automatically broken just because it's used.
Unfixed in 14w34a.
Turns always into normal dirt with podzol and coarse dirt with all saplings in desert biome.
Dupe of MC-57884
And yet, it got "fixed" again :/
You're meaning MC-57884 I think... In my case, I think it was better that it didn't turn into dirt again, as it's a limited resource, unlike grass or mycelium (Same with coarse dirt)
EDIT: Now that I look here, it doesn't even have an assigned person on this "fixed" bug, that's even weirder...
When a tree grows on coarse dirt, it reverts to regular dirt.
To reproduce this bug:
1, Place coarse dirt.
2. Plant sapling on it.
3. Use bone meal to grow tree or wait until it grows naturally.
4. Cut down the tree to discover that there is now regular dirt left behind.
This bug also existed in the Java Edition previously and was fixed. See MC-57884.
For player-grown trees, this was intentionally fixed so that the podzol stays: MC-57884
Also, podzol in general behaves differently than grass does not decaying when something is on top of it.
![[Mod] OcelotOnesie](../../../data/avatars/users/43220.png){kind=small}
Summary:
Podzol turns into dirt when a tree grows on it. This bug also existed in the Java Edition previously and was fixed. See MC-57884
Steps to Reproduce:
- Place podzol
- Place a sapling on it
- Bone meal the sapling
- Break the tree logs
Observed Results:
The podzol turns into dirt.
Expected Results:
The podzol should not turn into dirt.
The same happens with the default ressource pack.
Confirmed for 14w25b
Confirmed
The dirt block below the tree is created when the tree grows / spawns.
Because of this functionality, podzol gets replaced as well when a tree grows on it.
Confirmed for 14w26a and b
Confirmed for 14w26c
Confirmed for 14w27a
It's still an issue in 14w29a.
Confirmed for 14w30b
Thanks Jeb <3
Confirmed for
@Marcono1234: Please create a new ticket for this and leave a note here for linking the tickets.
Still occuring in 34a for podzol due to the unintentional fix of
MC-67947Can't reproduce, update the bug report with an example of a failure.
Cannot reproduce in the latest snapshot (14w34b). I conclude that the bug has been fixed.
Confirmed fixed.