Upside down stairs have hitbox of regular stairs / regular stairs have wrong hitbox
Hitboxes for stairs are transposed.
Environment
Windows 8.1 64-bit
Linked Issues
is duplicated by40
MC-61432Stairs have smaller HitboxDuplicateMC-61575Upside Down stair hitbox is rotatedDuplicateMC-61665Stairs hitboxDuplicateMC-62025Stair placing problemDuplicateMC-62270Block "behind" closest staircase being minedDuplicateMC-62346Blocks can be placed through stairs DuplicateMC-62466Odd Block on Stair placementDuplicateMC-63193Pre-placed 14w30b stairs are treated as solid blocksDuplicateMC-63248placing blocks on stairs glitchDuplicateMC-63409Stairs bugDuplicateMC-63452Cant open chest under stairsDuplicateMC-63560Oak Stairs Glitched HitboxDuplicateMC-63641Hit detection box of stairs is backwards.DuplicateMC-63672breaking blocks behind stairs works not right DuplicateMC-63694Stair hit boxes are durpyDuplicateMC-63912Unusual Block Placement on Backs of StairsDuplicateMC-63935Can't Place Cobble Stairs Against Mossy CobbleDuplicateMC-63941Stair placement on back of other stairs buggedDuplicateMC-63958Hitboxes of blocks are incorrectDuplicateMC-64202Can not reach blocks behind stairsDuplicateMC-64216Stairs have wrong hitbox for arrows.DuplicateMC-64338StairsDuplicateMC-64527Upside Down Stairs Hitbox Not Registering on Certain AnglesDuplicateMC-64628Stair's hitbox does not match directional facingDuplicateMC-64668Stairs & wallsDuplicateMC-64693Walking up the stairs bugDuplicateMC-64738Can't place blocks ontop of stairsDuplicateMC-65052Stair hitbox glitchedDuplicateMC-65135Stairs not working when leaning on a wallDuplicateMC-65178Stairs are just buggy in generalDuplicateMC-65242Stairs (and upside down) have a buggy hit box.DuplicateMC-65268When walking against a wall, you can't climb stairs.DuplicateMC-65438Hitbox on stair blocks is different depending on orientationDuplicateMC-65923build through stairsDuplicateMC-66053placing in the wrong spotDuplicateMC-66779Placement of slabs next to stairs seems buggedDuplicateMC-66804upside down stairs not placing correctlyDuplicateMC-66859stairs working like halfblock when i touch upsideDuplicateMC-66871faulty stairs hitboxDuplicateMC-66962When to do a roof for a house that a block is put higher than stepsDuplicate
Created Issue:
Wrong stairs hitboxes
Hitboxes for stairs are transposed.
Environment
Windows 8.1 64-bit
Attachments2
Wrong stairs hitboxesStairs have a wrong Hitbox (too big or too small)
Stairs haveawrong Hitbox (too big or too small)
is duplicated by
Stairs have wrong Hitbox (too big or too small)Upside down stairs have hitbox of regular stairs
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Ezekiel (ezfe)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/ezekielelin.jpeg){kind=small}
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
Upside down stairs have hitbox of regular stairs / regular stairs have wrong hitbox
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/grum.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)is duplicated by
relates to
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
relates to
Duplicate of MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
Easy ?
Probably duplicate of MC-61245 "Upside down stairs have hitbox of regular stairs"
duplicate of MC-61245
Duplicate of MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
duplicate of MC-61245
duplicate of MC-61245
duplicate of MC-61245
duplicate of MC-61245
Duplicate of MC-61245 – If you have not, please use the search function in the future, to see if your bug has already been submitted.
Dupe of MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
Blame MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
sounds like a duplicate of MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
Facing into the wall at a diagonal I'm unable to move up the stairs
if I jump I will go up one stair block then get stuck on the next one up
When I read MC-61245 it doesn't sound like this
image of what I'm doing (I'm pushing forward but am unable to move)
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/19910871/2014-07-31_17.50.57.png
Oh yeah some people have reported this bug already. Best to add your info to that report instead of making a new copy of the same bug.
Duplicate of MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
Re-open this issue!
This is not a dupe of MC-61245 which pertains to the hitbox of placing stair blocks but that is not the collision issue which is happening here, which is caused by "catching" on what should be completely flat walls - another way you can test this is by using half-slab stairs which have the same issue, if you walk into them at a 45deg angle you will "catch" on the wall and it will block your movement - this is not the same behaviour as in previous versions of the game and is not the same issue as MC-61245.
Re-open this issue!
As explained on MC-65360; this is not a dupe of MC-61245 which pertains to the hitbox of placing stair blocks but that is not the collision issue which is happening here, which is caused by "catching" on what should be completely flat walls - another way you can test this is by using half-slab stairs which have the same issue, if you walk into them at a 45deg angle you will "catch" on the wall and it will block your movement - this is not the same behaviour as in previous versions of the game and is not the same issue as MC-61245.
Alternative video link if you can't watch the one above: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vDrRzoOSdY
Confirmations (incorrectly closed): MC-65360 , MC-65285
Not related to: MC-61245 !!
Please notice how this post also refers to snow and slabs. Are you saying snow/slabs are stairs? If this somehow is because of the same problem, the hitbox problem needs to be expanded beyond "stairs", because as Zuriki reports, this does not only happen with stairs.
This is NOT a dupe of MC-61245.
If anything, MC-61245 could be related to this post, but only partially.
OK. The stairs issue is still a dupe of MC-61245, but these 2 things are fairly new. Deleting old comment.
The issues are not related. MC-61245 is about the hitbox of stairs specifically in relation to them being placed or destroyed. This does not affect the example above because the stairs in the example I gave are acting in accordance to how they should act in versions unaffected by MC-61245 and the hitbox of stairs is entirely irrelevant to this issue.
This issue is about player movement across any non-full block and more specifically relates to the special-case snapping the player to elevated surfaces when the destination surface is elevated by 0.5m or less.
Dupe of MC-61245
Duplicate of MC-61245
Dupe of MC-61245
Duplicate of MC-61245
Duplicate of MC-61245
can confirm, the hitboxes are completly screwed up
still screwy in 14w29b, especially the upside down ones.
confirmed for 14w30b
MC-63452you should retitle the report, now it looks like it's only with upside down stairs
stairs and there hitboxes effects both normal and upside down:
stair = hitbox
west = west
south = east
east = north
north = south
confirmed for 14w30c
I've made a short video, demonstrating some of the behaviors.
http://youtu.be/6vfikA1U6fI
Confirmed for 14w30c
"placing block on the top is buggy"
there is one thing I have to say: you aimed at the inside side of the stains, not top/inside top
Oh, I see what you're saying, FVbico. Didn't realize that it had always been that way.
Thanks for clarifying that. -
Confirmed for 14w32a. I can only have kitchen cabinets to the west
Confirmed for 14w32b
Confirmed for 14w32d. Upside down stars are particularly problematic, as they've made chests placed behind them inaccessible.
confirmed for 32d - seems to have something to do with the block models
This bug is back in 15w38a
Regression in
MC-88847