MCPE-169501Some blocks requiring support can be placed on the top side of the Hopper
Summary:
Blocks requiring support can be placed on the top side of the Hopper (lantern, bell, torch...). Since the top side is incomplete, it should not contain almost any blocks that require support, as is done in Java (except for Signs, Pressure Plate, Sea Pickles...).
Here is a comparison of the main blocks:
| Block | Bedrock | Java |
|---|---|---|
| Sea Pickles |  |
|
| Pressure Plates | |
|
| Redstone | |
|
| Redstone Repeater/ Comparator |
|
|
| Rails | |
|
| Bell | |
 |
| Scaffolding | |
|
| Levers | |
|
| Glow Lichen/ Sculck Vein |
|
|
| Amethyst Cluster | |
|
| Buttons | |
|
| Pointed Dripstone | |
|
| Snow | |
|
| Doors | |
|
| Corals | |
|
| Torchs | |
|
| Lanterns | |
|
| Candles | |
|
Steps to reproduce:
- Place Hopper.
- Place blocks like torch, lantern, redstone, bell... on the top side.
Observed results:
Blocks can be placed on the top side.
Expected results:
The top side is incomplete, so no blocks will be placed on it.
![[Mod] EVGENSYPERPRO](../../../data/avatars/users/92853.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Blocks requiring support can be placed on the top side of the Hopper
Summary:
Blocks requiring support can be placed on the top side of the Hopper (lantern, bell, torch, redstone...). Since the top side is incomplete, it should not contain any blocks that require support, as is done in Java (except for signs).Steps to reproduce:
- Place Hopper.
- Place blocks like torch, lantern, redstone, bell... on the top side.
Observed results:
Blocks can be placed on the top side.Expected results:
The top side is incomplete, so no blocks will be placed on it.
Summary:
Blocks requiring support can be placed on the top side of the Hopper (lantern, bell, torch, redstone...). Since the top side is incomplete, it should not contain any blocks that require support, as is done in Java (except forsigns).Steps to reproduce:
- Place Hopper.
- Place blocks like torch, lantern, redstone, bell... on the top side.
Observed results:
Blocks can be placed on the top side.Expected results:
The top side is incomplete, so no blocks will be placed on it.Summary:
Blocks requiring support can be placed on the top side of the Hopper (lantern, bell, torch...). Since the top side is incomplete, it should not contain almost any blocks that require support, as is done in Java (except for Signs, Pressure Plate, Sea Pickles...).Here is a comparison of the main blocks:
Block Bedrock Java Sea Pickles Pressure Plates Redstone Redstone Repeater/
ComparatorRails Bell Scaffolding Levers Glow Lichen/
Sculck VeinAmethyst Cluster Buttons Pointed Dripstone Snow Doors Corals Torchs Lanterns Candles Steps to reproduce:
- Place Hopper.
- Place blocks like torch, lantern, redstone, bell... on the top side.
Observed results:
Blocks can be placed on the top side.Expected results:
The top side is incomplete, so no blocks will be placed on it.
Blocks requiring support can be placed on the top side of the HopperSome blocks requiring support can be placed on the top side of the Hopper
![[Helper] lillybeacon](../../../data/avatars/users/93893.png){kind=small}
![[MCQA] Justyna Oleś](../../../data/avatars/users/18934.svg){kind=small}
![[MCPE Mod] Celesian](../../../data/avatars/users/81635.png){kind=small}
The lantern & bell placement is inconsistent between the java and bedrock editions of the game
This includes but may not be limited to:
- Flower Pot
- Anvil
- Chorus Flower
- Door
- Shulker Box
- Azalea
- Daylight Sensor (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Stonecutter (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Spawner (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Turtle Egg (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Grindstone (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Chest, Trapped Chest, Ender Chest (fixed)
- End Portal (fixed)
- Enchantment Table (fixed)
- Brewing Stand (fixed)
- Slabs (fixed)
- Trapdoors (fixed)
- Campfire (fixed)
- Lectern (fixed)
In Bedrock, the bell should not be placed on the top side of these blocks:
- Cauldron (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Glass Panes (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Iron Bars (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Walls (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Fences (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Lightning Rod (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- End Rod (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Chain (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Composter (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Hopper (MCPE-169501)
In Bedrock, lantern & bell should be placed only on the bottom side:
- Farmland (fixed 1.20.0.20)
- Dirt Path (fixed 1.20.0.20)
Image attached shows all differences I've found between java(left) and bedrock(right)
Fixed in 1.20.0.20
Hopper will be tracked in MCPE-169501. Block honey - MCPE-172508.
Fixed in 1.20.0.20.
Hopper will be tracked in MCPE-169501.
Honey Block - MCPE-172508.