Steven Robb
- stefrobb
- stefrobb
- Pacific/Auckland
- Yes
- No
MC-30877![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
In 1.6.2 and earlier fully grown wheat would pop-off into item form when the light level in the block was reduced to 0. Since snapshot 13w36a wheat no longer does this, this includes the current 1.7.2 release.
The screenshots show the results of placing a block above the water, reducing the light level of the wheat to 0. In 1.6.2 the wheat pops off, in the snapshot the wheat remains.
Creative or survival.
When a mob is punched and jumps into lava above its head it will die and drop XP, indicating a player kill. It is also possible to get multiple and rare drops if using a Fortune enchanted weapon.
However the statistic for the mob is not updated to show the kill, which would seem to indicate that this is not a player kill.
In the screenshots the zombie is punched into the lava, dies, and drops XP, but the stat (which I can't screenshot unfortunately) doesn't update.
I have also uploaded a YT video demonstrating this: https://youtu.be/
phMLtpTLqwc(Sorry about the quality, you can just about read the text, if you squint. Really hard…)
When a mob is punched and jumps into lava above its head it will die and drop XP, indicating a player kill. It is also possible to get multiple and rare drops if using a Fortune enchanted weapon.
However the statistic for the mob is not updated to show the kill, which would seem to indicate that this is not a player kill.
In the screenshots the zombie is punched into the lava, dies, and drops XP, but the stat (which I can't screenshot unfortunately) doesn't update.
I have also uploaded a YT video demonstrating this: https://youtu.be/C2XSb4P5rA4
(Sorry about the quality, you can just about read the text, if you squint. Really hard…)
When a mob is punched and jumps into lava above its head it will die and drop XP, indicating a player kill. It is also possible to get multiple and rare drops if using a Fortune enchanted weapon.
However the statistic for the mob is not updated to show the kill, which would seem to indicate that this is not a player kill.
In the screenshots the zombie is punched into the lava, dies, and drops XP, but the stat (which I can't screenshot unfortunately) doesn't update.
I have also uploaded a YT video demonstrating this: https://youtu.be/C2XSb4P5rA4
(Sorry about the quality, you can just about read the text, if you squint. Really hard…)
When a mob is punched and jumps into lava above its head it will die and drop XP, indicating a player kill. It is also possible to get multiple and rare drops if using a Fortune enchanted weapon.
However the statistic for the mob is not updated to show the kill, which would seem to indicate that this is not a player kill.
In the screenshots the zombie is punched into the lava, dies, and drops XP, but the stat (which I can't screenshot unfortunately) doesn't update.
I have also uploaded a YT video demonstrating this: https://youtu.be/C2XSb4P5rA4
Despite being marked as duplicate, and the duplicate being marked as resolved, the behaviour described here remains the same, and has not changed since first reported. Wheat does not pop-off in light level 0. This bug remains in all snapshots up to and including 14w08a.
Behaviour still present in 14w08a.
Thank you for re-opening this issue.
I don't know what the original intended behaviour is, but it would be good to get that cleared up. I would note that planted items popping off in low light levels has been in the game for a long time, and used in many builds (semi-automatic farms, etc.), so it has at least been shown to be useful.
I'd also not consider comparing anything in Minecraft to 'real life' as a valid argument for behaviour being one way or another—since when could 1m cubed blocks of stone be made to float with no visible support? =)
Cheers!
Just checked in 16w41a and it's still an outstanding issue. It's never been addressed since reported.