Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs
The Bug:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
Ever since its introduction, nether fortresses have been able to generate "bridge" sections through solid terrain regions. This results in a weird "roof" of normal terrain blocks generating here instead, which doesn't make sense. Several other corridor paths have roofs made of nether bricks, which is what would have been expected to generate in such cases.
While this form of generation has been standard throughout the generation of fortresses it does not feel intentional and ends up breaking immersion somewhat. Several other structures would replace terrain blocks with their own blocks in cases like these, such as strongholds (pre-21w07a) which would replace non-air blocks with stone bricks and their variants, and mineshafts which replace air with planks. Therefore replacement of the blocks in question with nether bricks would be the expected result in these cases.
Here is an example:
Seed: -5497747566889979774 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_nether run tp @s -710.07 67.00 -404.87 274.42 -0.80
Steps to Reproduce:
- Generate a world with the seed provided above and teleport to the given coordinates.
- Look closely at the nether fortress bridge.
- Take note as to whether or not nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain have proper roofs.
Observed Behavior:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
Expected Behavior:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain would have proper roofs.
Linked Issues
relates to3
MC-193936The tops of stairs above nether fortress wart rooms can generate obstructedCommunity ConsensusMC-120968Nether fortress broken bridge structure does not generate anything inside netherrackConfirmedMC-216226Some nether fortress platforms that generate through terrain don't have proper roofsConfirmed
Created Issue:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain do not have a proper roof
Relates to MC-120968, MC-193936
Ever since their introduction nether fortress have been able to generate "bridge" sections through solid terrain regions. This results in a weird "roof" of normal terrain blocks generating here instead, which doesn't make sense. Several other corridor paths have roofs made of nether bricks, which is what would have been expected to generate in such cases.
While this form of generation has been standard throughout the generation of fortresses it does not feel intentional. Several other structures would replace terrain blocks with their own block sin cases like these, such as strongholds (pre-21w07a) which would replace non-air blocks with stone bricks and its variants, and mineshafts which replace air with planks.
Attachments5
Relates to MC-120968, MC-193936
Ever since their introduction nether fortress have been able to generate "bridge" sections through solid terrain regions. This results in a weird "roof" of normal terrain blocks generating here instead, which doesn't make sense. Several other corridor paths have roofs made of nether bricks, which is what would have been expected to generate in such cases.
While this form of generation has been standard throughout the generation of fortresses it does not feel intentional. Several other structures would replace terrain blocks with their own block
sin cases like these, such as strongholds (pre-21w07a) which would replace non-air blocks with stone bricks and its variants, and mineshafts which replace air with planks.Relates to MC-120968, MC-193936
Ever since their introduction nether fortress have been able to generate "bridge" sections through solid terrain regions. This results in a weird "roof" of normal terrain blocks generating here instead, which doesn't make sense. Several other corridor paths have roofs made of nether bricks, which is what would have been expected to generate in such cases.
While this form of generation has been standard throughout the generation of fortresses it does not feel intentional and ends up breaking immersion somewhat. Several other structures would replace terrain blocks with their own blocks in cases like these, such as strongholds (pre-21w07a) which would replace non-air blocks with stone bricks and its variants, and mineshafts which replace air with planks. Therefore replacement of the blocks in question with nether bricks would be the expected result in these cases.
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Chandler](../../../data/assets/gravatar/triwonder81.png){kind=small}
Relates to MC-120968, MC-193936
Ever since their introduction nether fortress have been able to generate "bridge" sections through solid terrain regions. This results in a weird "roof" of normal terrain blocks generating here instead, which doesn't make sense. Several other corridor paths have roofs made of nether bricks, which is what would have been expected to generate in such cases.
While this form of generation has been standard throughout the generation of fortresses it does not feel intentional and ends up breaking immersion somewhat. Several other structures would replace terrain blocks with their own blocks in cases like these, such as strongholds (pre-21w07a) which would replace non-air blocks with stone bricks and its variants, and mineshafts which replace air with planks. Therefore replacement of the blocks in question with nether bricks would be the expected result in these cases.
![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
Ever since
theirintroduction nether fortress have been able to generate "bridge" sections through solid terrain regions. This results in a weird "roof" of normal terrain blocks generating here instead, which doesn't make sense. Several other corridor paths have roofs made of nether bricks, which is what would have been expected to generate in such cases.While this form of generation has been standard throughout the generation of fortresses it does not feel intentional and ends up breaking immersion somewhat. Several other structures would replace terrain blocks with their own blocks in cases like these, such as strongholds (pre-21w07a) which would replace non-air blocks with stone bricks and
itsvariants, and mineshafts which replace air with planks. Therefore replacement of the blocks in question with nether bricks would be the expected result in these cases.The Bug:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
Ever since its introduction, nether fortresses have been able to generate "bridge" sections through solid terrain regions. This results in a weird "roof" of normal terrain blocks generating here instead, which doesn't make sense. Several other corridor paths have roofs made of nether bricks, which is what would have been expected to generate in such cases.
While this form of generation has been standard throughout the generation of fortresses it does not feel intentional and ends up breaking immersion somewhat. Several other structures would replace terrain blocks with their own blocks in cases like these, such as strongholds (pre-21w07a) which would replace non-air blocks with stone bricks and their variants, and mineshafts which replace air with planks. Therefore replacement of the blocks in question with nether bricks would be the expected result in these cases.
Here is an example:
Version: 1.19.4Seed: -5497747566889979774 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_nether run tp @s -710.07 67.00 -404.87 274.42 -0.80Steps to Reproduce:
- Generate a world with the seed provided above and teleport to the given coordinates.
- Look closely at nether fortress bridges.
- Take note as to whether or not nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain have proper roofs.
Observed Behavior:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
Expected Behavior:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain would have proper roofs.
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain donot haveaproper roofNether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs
The Bug:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
Ever since its introduction, nether fortresses have been able to generate "bridge" sections through solid terrain regions. This results in a weird "roof" of normal terrain blocks generating here instead, which doesn't make sense. Several other corridor paths have roofs made of nether bricks, which is what would have been expected to generate in such cases.
While this form of generation has been standard throughout the generation of fortresses it does not feel intentional and ends up breaking immersion somewhat. Several other structures would replace terrain blocks with their own blocks in cases like these, such as strongholds (pre-21w07a) which would replace non-air blocks with stone bricks and their variants, and mineshafts which replace air with planks. Therefore replacement of the blocks in question with nether bricks would be the expected result in these cases.
Here is an example:
Version: 1.19.4Seed: -5497747566889979774 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_nether run tp @s -710.07 67.00 -404.87 274.42 -0.80Steps to Reproduce:
- Generate a world with the seed provided above and teleport to the given coordinates.
- Look closely at nether fortress bridge
s.- Take note as to whether or not nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain have proper roofs.
Observed Behavior:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
Expected Behavior:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain would have proper roofs.
The Bug:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
Ever since its introduction, nether fortresses have been able to generate "bridge" sections through solid terrain regions. This results in a weird "roof" of normal terrain blocks generating here instead, which doesn't make sense. Several other corridor paths have roofs made of nether bricks, which is what would have been expected to generate in such cases.
While this form of generation has been standard throughout the generation of fortresses it does not feel intentional and ends up breaking immersion somewhat. Several other structures would replace terrain blocks with their own blocks in cases like these, such as strongholds (pre-21w07a) which would replace non-air blocks with stone bricks and their variants, and mineshafts which replace air with planks. Therefore replacement of the blocks in question with nether bricks would be the expected result in these cases.
Here is an example:
Version: 1.19.4Seed: -5497747566889979774 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_nether run tp @s -710.07 67.00 -404.87 274.42 -0.80Steps to Reproduce:
- Generate a world with the seed provided above and teleport to the given coordinates.
- Look closely at the nether fortress bridge.
- Take note as to whether or not nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain have proper roofs.
Observed Behavior:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
Expected Behavior:
Nether fortress bridges that generate through terrain would have proper roofs.
The Bug:
Some nether fortress platforms that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
See reasoning in MC-216221.
Here is an example:
Seed: -5497747566889979774 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_nether run tp @s 106445.12 73.00 -1529.48 69.09 5.58
Steps to Reproduce:
- Generate a world with the seed provided above and teleport to the given coordinates.
- Look closely at the nether fortress platform.
- Take note as to whether or not some nether fortress platforms that generate through terrain have proper roofs.
Observed Behavior:
Some nether fortress platforms that generate through terrain don't have proper roofs.
Expected Behavior:
Some nether fortress platforms that generate through terrain would have proper roofs.
Can confirm.
Can confirm in 21w08b.
Can confirm in 1.17-pre5.