MC-3610Pistons cannot be de/activated individually when stacked on top of each other
Good evening,
Excuse me for my poor english.
I experienced an issue with the activation of vertical pistons.
The first screen shows us the configuration: 2 piston taking alimentation from stone block near them, and redstone torch to tell us if the stone is alimented.
The second screen shows us what happens if we alimente the bottom piston only.
The third screen shows us what happens if we alimente the top piston only.
At the fourth screen we alimente both pistons, every thing works well.
At the fifth screen, we cancel the bottom piston's alimentation: here's the problem.
The bottom piston is still activated while the bottom redstone torch shows that the stone is not powered: the piston should be deactivated.
The screen six just shows us that the redstone torchs don't change anything.
The screen seven shows that system come back to normal if we take away the power.
And the last screen shows the system from his back.
I had this bug on online server and offline on private world on the last version, and both creative and survival.
This is really sad, because we can't deal with the powering of vertical stack of pistons.
exemple of application: double vertical piston system
Thanks for reading me, the redstone mechanics is one part of minecraft that I really love.
I wish you a good week.
Linked Issues
Attachments11
![[Mod] CubeTheThird](../../../data/assets/gravatar/cubethethird.jpeg){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Piston activation bug
Good evening,
Excuse me for my poor english.
I experienced an issue with the activation of vertical pistons.
The first screen shows us the configuration: 2 piston taking alimentation from stone block near them, and redstone torch to tell us if the stone is alimented.
The second screen shows us what happens if we alimente the bottom piston only.
The third screen shows us what happens if we alimente the top piston only.At the fourth screen we alimente both pistons, every thing works well.
At the fifth screen, we cancel the bottom piston's alimentation: here's the problem.
The bottom piston is still activated while the bottom redstone torch shows that the stone is not powered: the piston should be deactivated.The screen six just shows us that the redstone torchs don't change anything.
The screen seven shows that system come back to normal if we take away the power.And the last screen shows the system from his back.
I experienced this bug on online server and offline on private world on the last version, and both creative and survival.
This is really sad, because we can't deal with the powering of vertical stack of pistons.exemple of application: double vertical piston system
Thanks for reading me, the redstone mechanics is one part of minecraft that I really love.
I wish you a good week.
Environment
Private and Multi in every Mode
Linked Issues
is blocked by1
TRASH-991
Attachments8
Good evening,
Excuse me for my poor english.
I experienced an issue with the activation of vertical pistons.
The first screen shows us the configuration: 2 piston taking alimentation from stone block near them, and redstone torch to tell us if the stone is alimented.
The second screen shows us what happens if we alimente the bottom piston only.
Thethird screen shows us what happens if we alimente the top piston only.At the fourth screen we alimente both pistons, every thing works well.
At the fifth screen, we cancel the bottom piston's alimentation: here's the problem.
The bottom piston is still activated while the bottom redstone torch shows that the stone is not powered: the piston should be deactivated.
The screensix just shows us that the redstone torchs don't change anything.
Thescreen seven shows that system come back to normal if we take away the power.And the last screen shows the system from his back.
I
experienced this bug on online server and offline on private world on the last version, and both creative and survival.
This is really sad, because we can't deal with the powering of vertical stack of pistons.exemple of application: double vertical piston system
Thanks for reading me, the redstone mechanics is one part of minecraft that I really love.
I wish you a good week.
Good evening,
Excuse me for my poor english.
I experienced an issue with the activation of vertical pistons.
The first screen shows us the configuration: 2 piston taking alimentation from stone block near them, and redstone torch to tell us if the stone is alimented.
The second screen shows us what happens if we alimente the bottom piston only.
The third screen shows us what happens if we alimente the top piston only.
At the fourth screen we alimente both pistons, every thing works well.
At the fifth screen, we cancel the bottom piston's alimentation: here's the problem.
The bottom piston is still activated while the bottom redstone torch shows that the stone is not powered: the piston should be deactivated.The screen six just shows us that the redstone torchs don't change anything.
The screen seven shows that system come back to normal if we take away the power.
And the last screen shows the system from his back.
I had this bug on online server and offline on private world on the last version, and both creative and survival.
This is really sad, because we can't deal with the powering of vertical stack of pistons.exemple of application: double vertical piston system
Thanks for reading me, the redstone mechanics is one part of minecraft that I really love.
I wish you a good week.
Piston activation bugPistons cannot be de/activated individually when stacked on top of each other
is blocked by
relates to
TNT (Australian Version) - 01 - It's A Long Way To The Top (If You Wanna Rock 'n' Roll).mp3
is blocked by
is blocked by
![[Mod] Torabi](../../../data/assets/gravatar/torabi.png){kind=small}
Since MC-108 has been marked as Works as intended, this ticket should be marked accordingly, too, shouldn't it?
here´s an idea that I love but isn´t mine:
have 2 new pistons that dont have QC, maybe right click the piston to toggle between the 2, that way noobs can hav simple and understandable redstone and old players can have a new toy to play with that doesnt break already existing devices.
It was mention in the chat of a livestream that Meri Diana, cubehamster, and Panda4994 were in.
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Adrian Östergård](../../../data/assets/gravatar/nighter.jpeg){kind=small}
duplicates
is blocked by
I believe this is intended behaviour, and I am posting a screenshot for a possible solution/alternative. Does this solve your problem?
This is kind of related to the piston quasi connectivity. To be able to control 2 pistons above each other without interference use the setup I provided in the screenshot.
Edit: Using the "feature" explained here:
MC-3592Thanks for your answers.
CubeTheThird: it's the most naïve way to power pistons, the problem is that it powers both top and bottom pistons, i use a "proxy" stone block to power only one piston.
Tails: It works only if we works we 2 pistons, in my case it's not possible because i have a big vertical stack of pistons and i need to control each separatly.
I believe it's a bug because it works separatly, but when the top one is activated, if you activate the bottom one he's stuck in this position, you can barrely remove everything else except the bottom piston, he will keep being stuck.
What is "is blocked by" mean?
Isnt this basicly a duplicate?
It basically means that so long as
MC-108is intended and will not change in behaviour, this report remains valid and unfixable.I tested in 1.8.
There's no such ghost behavior now. But it's still impossible to activate separately pistons stacked vertically.
And honestly it is a reason I stopped minecraft: you create an object called piston, opening a new world of possibilities. In fact no the possibilities are really limited and the fixes on this was more like "featuring the bug more than fixing it", this is dirty work.
You truly can't do everything you want, there isn't even a simple featured way to extend the size of the pistons, there isn't even the feature of catapulting sand and player when turned to the top. Pistons are a shame, if I wonder what was in the head of the devs when they implemented the piston mod i think about this "meh you want it, get it, happy now?".
This is sad.
http://mojang.com/2016/08/whats-happening-with-redstone-on-pocket-win-10/
Welp, I suppose that's the final nail in the coffin for people wanting to get it fixed. This report can finally be "resolved as Won't Fix".
"Aren't planning" isn't the same thing as "never", nor does it mean that they can't devise a solution to this issue.
Actually, you could use tripwire hooks (with different lengths) and more a entity in it, not compact, but it is possible.