4 blocks wide paintings need 5 blocks space / Paintings popping off wall when blocks around it are broken
4x4 paintings need 4x5 space to be there i cant show a good picture but im sure you get it
Linked Issues
is duplicated by22
MC-521613x4 Painting needs a 4x5 space and 4x4 painting needs a 5x5 spaceDuplicateMC-53942Paintings bigger than 2x2 popping off wall when blocks around it are broken.DuplicateMC-55232"Fighters" Painting detecting wrong blocks (pops off)DuplicateMC-61685Large Painting bugDuplicateMC-660543x4 Paintings work incorrectlyDuplicateMC-663604x3 painting falls off the wallDuplicateMC-67213Some paintings disappear from a wall if adjacent to the wall's edgeDuplicateMC-69774Can't place a BIG painting on a 4x3 wall with some glass next to it.DuplicateMC-72603Large (4x4) paintings pop off wallsDuplicateMC-73011Painting holds more space than it is supposed to doDuplicateMC-73163I am trying to place one of the 4x4 paintings in a certain spotDuplicateMC-75142Specific Paintings Requiring Odd Wall Space For PlacementDuplicateMC-75304Large Picture frame bugDuplicateMC-75608Paintings don't stay in spotDuplicateMC-75909Paintings hanging over edgesDuplicateMC-77292Picture of 4x4, 4x3 and 4x2 sized properly and require an additional block to the rightDuplicateMC-77398paintings disappear although the right sizeDuplicateMC-794724x2 Painting (Fighter) improper placementDuplicateMC-80317Painting placement bugDuplicateMC-88075Large paintings problemDuplicateMC-94623Paintings not fitting walls of their sizeDuplicateMC-97888Big paintings wall requirement is offsetDuplicate
Created Issue:
painting
4x4 paintings need 4x5 space to be there i cant show a good picture but im sure you get it
duplicates
4x4 paintings need 4x5 space
Are you sure that you're on 14w05b ? Can no longer confirm the 0.5 blocks offset, see screenshot.
relates to
duplicates
is duplicated by
4x4 paintings need 4x5 space / Paintings popping off wall when blocks around it are broken
is duplicated by
4x4paintings need4x5space / Paintings popping off wall when blocks around it are broken4 blocks wide paintings need 5 blocks space / Paintings popping off wall when blocks around it are broken
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Torabi](../../../data/assets/gravatar/torabi.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
For what it may be worth, the blocks to the right of the painting do not have to be solid blocks. I've attached a screenshot (taken with my resource pack enabled) showing two 4x4 paintings side by side with a door to the right of the second one. This is a stable configuration.
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mod] CubeTheThird](../../../data/assets/gravatar/cubethethird.jpeg){kind=small}
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
ProfMobius (Thomas Guimbretiere)is duplicated by
is duplicated by
Confirmed.
Steps to reproduce:
According to
MC-55232the painting center is offset one block to the leftStill in 14w32d
Confirmed for 14w33a
Still present in 14w34a
Still present in 1.8 prerelease 1. Come on, this is a serious bug that didn't exist in 1.7 and needs fixing before 1.8 comes out.
Still present in 1.8-pre2 ...
Confirmed for 1.8-pre3
For placing a 4x3 painting i need a 4x4 wall!!
Still unfixed in 1.8 release
For what it may be worth, the blocks to the right of the painting do not have to be solid blocks. I've attached a screenshot (taken with my resource pack enabled) showing two 4x4 paintings side by side to make an 8x4 mural, with a door to the right of the right-hand one. This is a stable configuration.
Still present in 1.8.1-pre2
Still in 1.8.1-pre5
Still present in 1.8.1
Still in 1.8.2-pre1
My mc world is filled with my own customized kx.png paintings. When I upgraded from 1.7.9 to 1.8.1 those 4x4 paintings dropped off in all areas where there was only a 4x4 space. Disappointing that 1.8.1 is not "better" than an earlier version or that a model wall filled with the kz.png paintings was not tested before a new release.
Note: I use optifine.
I want to comment that 1) even if the walls are large, a 4x4 painting does did not work if there are paintings surrounding the 4x4 empty space. 2) the 4x4 paintings do NOT work on a large wall filled with paintings even if there is an open 4 high x 5 wide open space. 3) if there is a stand alone 4x4 block wall a 4x4 painting will stick, but only if the painting hangs off the left side over empty space.
This forum is just over one year old with no solution found yet. I'm glad the topic is still open. I will either have to go back to 1.7.9 or go back and rework all of my structures to make this work.
Question: Is there a mod that will fix this problem?
Unrelated question: Are there mods, like "More Paintings mod" that work with 1.8.1 and optifine?
@James Taylor Flores:
This should fix the problem (if someone want to make a mod with it, feel free) (patch for mcp 1.8.0 code)
The fix is in a build for mc1.9. Is there any chance that it will be backported to a patch for 1.8, or is 1.8 permanently bugged?
@Jeffry, not unless Mojang releases a 1.8.9 which is unlikely.