MC-49Sounds: Fire extinguish sound does not work in survival
Fire extinguish sound doesn't work in survival, but it works in creative mode.
1. Light some netherrack (or anything else) on fire and then punch it to extinguish it. In survival you hear the punching a block sound for the block type behind the fire (netherrack in this example)
2. do /gamemode creative
3. Punch some more fire, the correct extinguish sound plays.
4. do /gamemode survival
5. Try again. Fire extinguish sound will not play.
Edit: When another player punches fire to extinguish it, the sound plays. It just doesn't work when the player himself does it.
And it appears that the extinguish sound might play twice while in creative mode
Environment
Linux, sun-jdk-1.6.0.35; Windows 7, Java 1.6u35
Linked Issues
Created Issue:
Sounds: Fire extinguish sound does not work in survival
Fire extinguish sound doesn't work in survival, but it works in creative mode.
1. Light some netherrack on fire and then punch it to extinguish it. In survival you hear the punching a block sound for the block type behind the fire (netherrack in this example)
2. do /gamemode creative
3. Punch some more fire, the correct extinguish sound plays.
4. do /gamemode survival
5. Try again. Fire extinguish sound will not play.Environment
Linux, sun-jdk-1.6.0.35; Windows 7, Java 1.6u35
is duplicated by
Fire extinguish sound doesn't work in survival, but it works in creative mode.
1. Light some netherrack on fire and then punch it to extinguish it. In survival you hear the punching a block sound for the block type behind the fire (netherrack in this example)
2. do /gamemode creative
3. Punch some more fire, the correct extinguish sound plays.
4. do /gamemode survival
5. Try again. Fire extinguish sound will not play.Edit: When another player punches fire to extinguish it, the sound plays. It just doesn't work when the player himself does it.
is duplicated by
Fire extinguish sound doesn't work in survival, but it works in creative mode.
1. Light some netherrack on fire and then punch it to extinguish it. In survival you hear the punching a block sound for the block type behind the fire (netherrack in this example)
2. do /gamemode creative
3. Punch some more fire, the correct extinguish sound plays.
4. do /gamemode survival
5. Try again. Fire extinguish sound will not play.Edit: When another player punches fire to extinguish it, the sound plays. It just doesn't work when the player himself does it.
Fire extinguish sound doesn't work in survival, but it works in creative mode.
1. Light some netherrack (or anything else) on fire and then punch it to extinguish it. In survival you hear the punching a block sound for the block type behind the fire (netherrack in this example)
2. do /gamemode creative
3. Punch some more fire, the correct extinguish sound plays.
4. do /gamemode survival
5. Try again. Fire extinguish sound will not play.Edit: When another player punches fire to extinguish it, the sound plays. It just doesn't work when the player himself does it.
And it appears that the extinguish sound might play twice while in creative mode
![[Mojang] Jeb (Jens Bergensten)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/jeb.jpeg){kind=small}
[Mojang] Jeb (Jens Bergensten)
test.txt.txtDuplicate of: MC-49 - Please use the search function to see if your bug has already been submitted.
Currently 27% of tickets are being closed as duplicate.
Duplicate of MC-49 , please use the search function to see if your bug has already been submitted. Currently over 35% of tickets are being closed as duplicate.
Still occurs in 1.4.2.
Confirmed. I also notice that in creative mode the sound seems to be played twice (with a random delay just enough to hear sometimes).
Is this still a concern on Minecraft 1.4.4 Pre-Release? If so, please update the version affected.
I confirm in 1.4.4 prerelease. (Not the original reporter so I can't set the version.)
Thank you Kevin, the issue has been updated.