MC-683Witches not spawning in Swamp Huts
I have located in multiple worlds (existing worlds and freshly created worlds) a few of the Swamp Hut structures. However, I have yet to find a witch. I have tried just about everything from waiting days, changing distances from the Hut and more waiting. I have so far been unable to find even one witch that spawned near or in the swamp hut. If this is not a bug and rather it is a issue with spawning conditions, information and specifics on spawning conditions need to be made known.
Environment
OS Windows XP Java version 1.7.0_09
Created Issue:
Witches not spawning in Swamp Huts
I have located in multiple worlds (existing worlds and freshly created worlds) a few of the Swamp Hut structures. However, I have yet to find a witch. I have tried just about everything from waiting days, changing distances from the Hut and more waiting. I have so far been unable to find even one witch that spawned near or in the swamp hut. If this is not a bug and rather it is a issue with spawning conditions, information and specifics on spawning conditions need to be made known.
Environment
OS Windows XP Java version 1.7.0_00
OS Windows XP Java version 1.7.0_0
0OS Windows XP Java version 1.7.0_09
duplicates
MC-72
duplicates
duplicates
Also a duplicate of MC-683.
This is likely to be due to witches despawning before you reach them. Hostile mobs have a chance to despawn 30 blocks + and they instantly despawn 128blocks+.
So then what exactly do I need to do to get a witch to successfully spawn without des pawning? I have tried waiting at many various block distances with no luck. I have yet to even see a clue that a witch spawned even temporarily. If this is not a bug then this is a serious flaw in the spawn conditions. A player should not have to try for hours to find one witch. Quoting the wiki on swamp hits witches commonly spawn in these huts. That is obviously very misleading. Thoughts anyone????
I've actually seen several witches spawn in desert temples that appear in swamps, as mentioned in
MC-659. Not yet seen a witch hut though. Witches are in the same mob category as skeletons and zombies and creepers, so maybe at night if you hang around a witch hut you may get one to spawn?I agree though that this is buggy behavior.
By the way, this is a duplicate issue of MC-72 and
MC-710.This is not a duplicate of MC-72 because I have no proof that it spawned in the first place so it is not a "despawning" issue as far as I know. And
MC-683was reported beforeMC-710.You really thing this is not the same issue as MC-72? You really think there is a totally separate bug regarding witches spawning near witch huts? I mean how can one person claim witches spawn then despawn at witch huts, then another person claim witches "never" spawn at witch huts? Both are playing the same version of the game, but both claims can't possibly be true. Whether or not you had witches despawn, I'm pretty sure they are the same issue.
Just try hanging out by a witch hut at night and see if one spawns for you.
I know
MC-686was reported beforeMC-710, but that is irrelevant since they are still duplicates. Including that detail will hopefully help the mods organize the issues.Marking it as a duplicate of MC-72, please continue discussion there.
Ok I stand corrected. You are right Joseph and thank you for taking the time to point that out to me.
so...
has it been fixed?
No, as of yet it has not been fixed. Please check MC-72 for any further info. From all that I have gathered, the witches are just EXTREMELY rare.
This is NOT a duplicate of MC-72. Many witch huts are duds due to being mostly or entirely on River biome. Witches can only spawn in a Swamp biome.
Here is a YouTube video that explains exactly where witches can spawn:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KllWkdfOS3M
I have also seen a witch hut that NEVER spawns witches due to the entire interior being on River, so that only a small portion of a wall is on Swamp. Thus, modification of that hut would be necessary for witches to spawn there, and even then they'd be abnormally rare.
Witches are NOT normally rare. As long as you are about 24 blocks from a perfectly normal witch hut (one that is entirely on Swamp), witches will spawn more often than Endermen. (Not counting Endermen that spawn underground where you can't see them.)
If it is not a bug that witches can spawn only on Swamp, then it is a bug that a witch hut can be mostly on River.
I think that maybe the requirement to be on Swamp was intentional, but was intended only as a safeguard to prevent them from spawning like crazy everywhere in case something went wrong with the other spawn condition (that they must be in a hut). It was then assumed that the "only on swamp" condition would not matter because Swamp Huts are supposed to generate only in a Swamp. But this assumption is wrong because a hut can actually generate almost entirely on a River. I'd be interested to know whether my guess on this is correct.
Relinked as a duplicate of
MC-7482, in favor of the better description/information provided.