MCPE-140610[Experimental] Minecraft Bedrock Caves Biomes have Uneven Distribution or Concentration of Cave Biomes Compared to Java Cave Biomes
Summary: If you compare Cave Biome Generation between Bedrock and Java you will find that Lush Caves Generate more frequently on Bedrock than Java and Bedrock Dripstone Caves Generate to infrequently compared to Java.
Method 1: Exploring The World
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Load Experimental Snapshot 6 and fly around in Spectator Mode (Bedrock sorta has this) at Caves Y Level.
Step 2: Compare and Analyze Dripstone and Lush Cave Biome Generation and distance between another Biome of the same kind.
Step 3: Repeat.
Step 4: Load 1.17.30.23 or .24 with Caves n Cliffs toggle enabled and fly around and explore world.
Step 5: Compare and Analyze Dripstone and Lush Cave Biome Distribution and distance between another biome of the same kind.
Step 6: Repeat all the steps.
Method 2: Use Locate Biome Command
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Use Locate Biome Command on Java (Bedrock lacks this making it harder to prove this as a true bug report but from my testing this is a valid bug report).
Step 2: Measure distances between Caves Biomes and Compare to Bedrock.
Step 3: Repeat.
Method 3: Go on the Web and Find Seeds
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Find a Dripstone Cave Biome and Lush Cave Biome seed on the Latest Versions of both Games containing the newest Cave Gen(Generation) on the respective game.
Step 2: Measure the Amount of Seeds Found.
Step 3: If you want to Fact Check or not do Step 2 then do this to Compare the Average distance between Cave Biomes on Average or Concentration of Cave Biomes on Average.
Step 4: Compare the Data between Versions.
Step 5: Repeat.
Observed Result: Bedrock and Java have disparities in the overall distribution of Cave Biomes and frequency or concentration of Cave Biomes.
Expected Result: Cave Biomes Concentration and Distribution should be more similar or inline between versions having Dripstone Caves generate more frequently on Bedrock to Align with Java and Lush Caves slightly Less on Bedrock.
Related To: MCPE-135061
Created Issue:
[Experimental] Minecraft Bedrock Caves Biomes have Uneven Distribution or Concentration of Cave Biomes Compared to Java Cave Biomes
Summary: If you compare Cave Biome Generation between Bedrock and Java you will find that Lush Caves Generate more frequently on Bedrock than Java and Bedrock Dripstone Caves Generate to infrequently compared to Java.
Method 1: Exploring The World
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Load Experimental Snapshot 6 and fly around in Spectator Mode (Bedrock sorta has this) at Caves Y Level.
Step 2: Compare and Analyze Dripstone and Lush Cave Biome Generation and distance between another Biome of the same kind.
Step 3: Repeat.
Step 4: Load 1.17.30.23 or .24 with Caves n Cliffs toggle enabled and fly around and explore world.
Step 5: Compare and Analyze Dripstone and Lush Cave Biome Distribution and distance between another biome of the same kind.
Step 6: Repeat all the steps.Method 2: Use Locate Biome Command.
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Use Locate Biome Command on Java (Bedrock lacks this making it harder to prove this as a true bug report but from my testing this is a valid bug report).
Step 2: Measure distances between Caves Biomes and Compare to Bedrock.
Step 3: Repeat.Method 3: Go on the Web and Find Seeds.
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Find a Dripstone Cave Biome and Lush Cave Biome seed on the Latest Versions of both Games containing the newest Cave Gen(Generation) on the respective game.
Step 2: Measure the Amount of Seeds Found.
Step 3: If you want to Fact Check or not do Step 2 then do this to Compare the Average distance between Cave Biomes on Average or Concentration of Cave Biomes on Average.
Step 4: Compare the Data between Versions.
Step 5: Repeat.Observed Result: Bedrock and Java have disparities in the overall distribution of Cave Biomes and frequency or concentration of Cave Biomes.
Expected Result: Cave Biomes Concentration and Distribution should be more similar or inline between versions having Dripstone Caves generate more frequently on Bedrock to Align with Java and Lush Caves slightly Less on Bedrock.
Summary: If you compare Cave Biome Generation between Bedrock and Java you will find that Lush Caves Generate more frequently on Bedrock than Java and Bedrock Dripstone Caves Generate to infrequently compared to Java.
Method 1: Exploring The World
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Load Experimental Snapshot 6 and fly around in Spectator Mode (Bedrock sorta has this) at Caves Y Level.
Step 2: Compare and Analyze Dripstone and Lush Cave Biome Generation and distance between another Biome of the same kind.
Step 3: Repeat.
Step 4: Load 1.17.30.23 or .24 with Caves n Cliffs toggle enabled and fly around and explore world.
Step 5: Compare and Analyze Dripstone and Lush Cave Biome Distribution and distance between another biome of the same kind.
Step 6: Repeat all the steps.Method 2: Use Locate Biome Command
.Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Use Locate Biome Command on Java (Bedrock lacks this making it harder to prove this as a true bug report but from my testing this is a valid bug report).
Step 2: Measure distances between Caves Biomes and Compare to Bedrock.
Step 3: Repeat.Method 3: Go on the Web and Find Seeds
.Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Find a Dripstone Cave Biome and Lush Cave Biome seed on the Latest Versions of both Games containing the newest Cave Gen(Generation) on the respective game.
Step 2: Measure the Amount of Seeds Found.
Step 3: If you want to Fact Check or not do Step 2 then do this to Compare the Average distance between Cave Biomes on Average or Concentration of Cave Biomes on Average.
Step 4: Compare the Data between Versions.
Step 5: Repeat.Observed Result: Bedrock and Java have disparities in the overall distribution of Cave Biomes and frequency or concentration of Cave Biomes.
Expected Result: Cave Biomes Concentration and Distribution should be more similar or inline between versions having Dripstone Caves generate more frequently on Bedrock to Align with Java and Lush Caves slightly Less on Bedrock.
Summary: If you compare Cave Biome Generation between Bedrock and Java you will find that Lush Caves Generate more frequently on Bedrock than Java and Bedrock Dripstone Caves Generate to infrequently compared to Java.
Method 1: Exploring The World
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Load Experimental Snapshot 6 and fly around in Spectator Mode (Bedrock sorta has this) at Caves Y Level.
Step 2: Compare and Analyze Dripstone and Lush Cave Biome Generation and distance between another Biome of the same kind.
Step 3: Repeat.
Step 4: Load 1.17.30.23 or .24 with Caves n Cliffs toggle enabled and fly around and explore world.
Step 5: Compare and Analyze Dripstone and Lush Cave Biome Distribution and distance between another biome of the same kind.
Step 6: Repeat all the steps.Method 2: Use Locate Biome Command
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Use Locate Biome Command on Java (Bedrock lacks this making it harder to prove this as a true bug report but from my testing this is a valid bug report).
Step 2: Measure distances between Caves Biomes and Compare to Bedrock.
Step 3: Repeat.Method 3: Go on the Web and Find Seeds
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Find a Dripstone Cave Biome and Lush Cave Biome seed on the Latest Versions of both Games containing the newest Cave Gen(Generation) on the respective game.
Step 2: Measure the Amount of Seeds Found.
Step 3: If you want to Fact Check or not do Step 2 then do this to Compare the Average distance between Cave Biomes on Average or Concentration of Cave Biomes on Average.
Step 4: Compare the Data between Versions.
Step 5: Repeat.Observed Result: Bedrock and Java have disparities in the overall distribution of Cave Biomes and frequency or concentration of Cave Biomes.
Expected Result: Cave Biomes Concentration and Distribution should be more similar or inline between versions having Dripstone Caves generate more frequently on Bedrock to Align with Java and Lush Caves slightly Less on Bedrock.
Related To:
MCPE-135061
![[MCQA] Bartłomiej Słodkowski](../../../data/avatars/users/18941.svg){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells)](../../../data/avatars/users/92696.png){kind=small}
Summary:
Dripstone Pillars from the dripstone cave biome in Java spawn in Bedrock and they spawn without pointed dripstone.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Load a Minecraft World with Caves n Cliffs.
- Dig for a while through caves until you find a dripstone pillar
- Repeat
Observed Results:
Dripstone Pillars from the dripstone cave biome spawn like the Java Dripstone Cave generation which was never mentioned in the changelog therefore its observed that they spawn without pointed dripstone unlike its Java Counterpart.
Expected Results:
Dripstone Pillars should spawn with pointed dripstone on top of them if they are supposed to spawn in the world.
Note: If you can't reproduce this its because of this bug >>> MCPE-140610 Please Upvote and Confirm This Bug!
Update: This Bug Has Gotten Worse In The New Beta 1.17.20.23 I Don't See Dripstone Pillars as Frequently in The New Beta(1.17.30.23 and Above)! This Has Gotten Sadly Even Worse Please Upvote MCPE-140613
Summary: I loaded 20-25 seeds and couldn't find a Lush/Dripstone Cave Below Y-10.
Steps to Reproduce:
Step 1: Load a World.
Step 2: Enable Caves n Cliffs Toggle.
Step 3: Go 2000-3500 blocks in One Direction.
Step 4: If you have no luck finding a Lush Cave Repeat Step 1.
Step 5: Dig Down when you see Vines.
Step 6: Repeat.
Observed Result: Lush and Dripstone Caves Dont Generate Below Y-10.
Expected Result: Lush and Dripstone Caves Dont Generate Below Y-10.
Note: If you can't reproduce this its because of this bug MCPE-140610
Affects 1.17.40.21
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response.
Is this still an issue in the latest version? If yes, can you please add it to the affected versions (or mention it if you are not the reporter)?
This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Mojang Support – 📧 Suggestions – 📖 Minecraft Wiki
Cleaning up old tickets: This ticket had been set to 'Awaiting Response', but has not received a response from the reporter (~3 months+) so is being closed as Incomplete. If you feel this is still a valid issue then please comment, or create a new ticket following the Issue Guidelines which includes steps to reproduce the problem.
For any account or purchasing related issues, please contact Minecraft Customer Support directly, as we cannot assist with those here at the bug tracker.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Mojang Support – 📧 Suggestions – 📖 Minecraft Wiki