MCPE-178205The output of Stonecutting Copper Grates is inconsistent with Java Edition
Summary
Same issue just like MC-266078
This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when "stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.
Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments: Yes
Steps to Reproduce
- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
You get 4 Grates from Stonecutting (1 Copper blocks -> 4 Copper grates)
Expected Behavior
You should get only 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a 1 Copper Block
Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in 24w03a, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)
Linked Issues
MC-266078Attachments1
Created Issue:
The output of Crafting and Stonecutting Copper Grates is inconsistent with each other
Summary
Same issue just like
MC-266078This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when crafting/"stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.
Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments: Pending
Steps to Reproduce
- Craft Copper Grate
- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
You get 4 Grates from Crafting (4 Blocks -> 4 Grates)
You get 4 Grates (more value) from the Stonecutter (1 Block -> 4 Grates)Expected Behavior
You should get 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a Copper Block
OR
You should get 16 Copper Grate from Crafting them instead of 4.Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in Future snapshot, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)
Summary
Same issue just like
MC-266078This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when crafting/"stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.
Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments:
PendingSteps to Reproduce
- Craft Copper Grate
- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
You get 4 Grates from Crafting (4 Blocks -> 4 Grates)
You get 4 Grates (more value) from the Stonecutter (1 Block -> 4 Grates)Expected Behavior
You should get 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a Copper Block
OR
You should get 16 Copper Grate from Crafting them instead of 4.Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in Future snapshot, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)
Summary
Same issue just like
MC-266078This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when crafting/"stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.
Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments: Yes
Steps to Reproduce
- Craft Copper Grate
- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
You get 4 Grates from Crafting (4 Blocks -> 4 Grates)
You get 4 Grates (more value) from the Stonecutter (1 Block -> 4 Grates)Expected Behavior
You should get 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a Copper Block
OR
You should get 16 Copper Grate from Crafting them instead of 4.Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in Future snapshot, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)
Screenshot_2024-01-15-22-03-28-21.jpg
![[MCQA] Zgajak](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
duplicates
![[Mod] OcelotOnesie](../../../data/avatars/users/43220.png){kind=small}
duplicates
![[MCQA] Bartłomiej Słodkowski](../../../data/avatars/users/18941.svg){kind=small}
relates to
Summary
Same issue just like
MC-266078This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when
crafting/"stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments: Yes
Steps to Reproduce
CraftCopper Grate- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
You get 4 Grates from Crafting (4 Blocks -> 4 Grates)
You get 4 Grates (more value) from the Stonecutter (1 Block -> 4 Grates)Expected Behavior
You should get 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a Copper Block
OR
You should get 16 Copper Grate from Crafting them instead of 4.Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in Future snapshot, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)
Summary
Same issue just like
MC-266078This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when "stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.
Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments: Yes
Steps to Reproduce
- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
You get 4 Grates from Crafting (4 Blocks -> 4 Grates)
Expected Behavior
You should get 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a Copper Block
Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in Future snapshot, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)
The output ofCrafting andStonecutting Copper Grates is inconsistent with each other
Summary
Same issue just like
MC-266078This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when "stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.
Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments: Yes
Steps to Reproduce
- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
You get 4 Grates from Crafting (
4Blocks -> 4 Grates)Expected Behavior
You should get 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a Copper Block
Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in
Future snapshot, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)Summary
Same issue just like
MC-266078This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when "stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.
Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments: Yes
Steps to Reproduce
- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
You get 4 Grates from Crafting (1 Blocks -> 4 Grates)
Expected Behavior
You should get 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a Copper Block
Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in 24w03a, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)
Summary
Same issue just like
MC-266078This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when "stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.
Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments: Yes
Steps to Reproduce
- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
You get 4 Grates from Crafting (1 Blocks -> 4 Grates)
Expected Behavior
You should get 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a Copper Block
Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in 24w03a, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)
Summary
Same issue just like
MC-266078This could be intentional because this inconsistency can also be seen when "stonecutting" Cut Copper. This may also be because the stonecutter's purpose is to dim down on how many resources are used when making something for a smaller output, i.e. slabs and stairs.
Addons/Resource Packs: No
Attachments: Yes
Steps to Reproduce
- Obtain Copper Grate using the Stonecutter
Observed Results
Expected Behavior
You should get only 1 Copper Grate from Stonecutting a 1 Copper Block
Note
This is a Bedrock bug ticket, for Java ticket (which is already planned to be fixed in 24w03a, but no fix version on Bedrock for this)
The output of Stonecutting Copper Grates is inconsistent witheach otherThe output of Stonecutting Copper Grates is inconsistent with Java Edition
is duplicated by
For cut copper and copper grate, this is working as intended. See MCPE-167828 and MCPE-178205.
![[Mod] Jarl-Penguin](../../../data/avatars/users/92849.png){kind=small}
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MCPE-178205, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
That ticket has already been resolved as working as intended, which means this is not considered a bug and won't be fixed. Please do not leave a comment on the linked ticket.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support (Technical Issues) – 📧 Microsoft Support (Account Issues)
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in
MCPE-155643, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support (Technical Issues) – 📧 Microsoft Support (Account Issues)
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! The ticket was resolved by one of our moderators, and I left this message to give more information to you.
This is not a duplicate of
MCPE-155643. That report is talking about copper blocks, not copper grates.Update for this ticket, The "Crafting" is removed because of 4 Grates from the Crafting table/crafter (4 copper blocks = 4 Grates) is Intended, But the 1 piece of copper block to 1 copper grates in stonecutter must be match java Edition.
Per 24w04a (java snapshot) this is now the intended design. The fix on the java report got reverted, and the behavior of outputting 4 crates is now intentional (mentioned in the changelog).
This should get WAId now.
MC-266078was closed with "Works As Intended". Closing this to maintain parity.