MCPE-180472The momentum and motion of a entity will not be reset when a player mounts it
Summary:
Through Minecraft challenge videos, I had noticed a certain difference in resources between the Java and Bedrock editions. In Java Edition, players can slowly fall with the boat, just by getting out and back from it, which is not possible in Bedrock Edition.
Despite being a small resource, some people may miss it, especially the challenge community, which tends to use the item a lot, either to fall with the boat over greater distances, or to fall slowly and trick other players.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Build a tall pillar going upwards (~20 or so blocks, not exact)
- Place a boat down on top of the pillar, and mount it
- Mount the boat and ride it off the pillar
- Quickly dismount the boat, and then immediately mount it again.
Observed Results:
The boat will maintain the same speed during the fall, therefore, the player will not have as much control as in Java Edition, having a greater chance of falling and being defeated.
Expected Results:
Just like in Java Edition, the boat should have its fall slowed for a brief moment.
Linked Issues
MC-174877
Created Issue:
It is not possible to slowly fall with a boat in Minecraft Bedrock
Summary:
Through minecraft challenge videos, I had noticed a certain difference in resources between the Java and Bedrock editions. In the Java edition, players can slowly fall with the boat, just by getting out and back from it, which is not possible in the Bedrock edition of the gameDespite being a small resource, some people may miss it, especially the challenge community, which tends to use the item a lot, either to fall with the boat over greater distances, or to fall slowly and trick other players.
Steps to Reproduce:
1. In minecraft Java Edition, place a boat in a high floor and fall with it
2. While in the fallen, start to leave and sit in the boat
Observed Results:In the Bedrock edition of the game, when trying to replicate, the boat will maintain the same speed during the fall, therefore, the player will not have as much control as in the Java edition, having a greater chance of falling and being defeated.
Expected Results:
Just like in the Java edition, the boat should have its fall slowed for a brief moment, so that the bedrock player would be able to replicate the action
Videos/Screenshots Attached: Yes
Summary:
Through minecraft challenge videos, I had noticed a certain difference in resources between the Java and Bedrock editions. In the Java edition, players can slowly fall with the boat, just by getting out and back from it, which is not possible in the Bedrock edition of the gameDespite being a small resource, some people may miss it, especially the challenge community, which tends to use the item a lot, either to fall with the boat over greater distances, or to fall slowly and trick other players.
Steps to Reproduce:
1. In minecraft Java Edition, place a boat in a high floor and fall with it
2. While in the fallen, start to leave and
sitin the boat
Observed Results:In the Bedrock edition of the game, when trying to replicate, the boat will maintain the same speed during the fall, therefore, the player will not have as much control as in the Java edition, having a greater chance of falling and being defeated.
Expected Results:
Just like in the Java edition, the boat should have its fall slowed for a brief moment, so that the bedrock player would be able to replicate the action
Videos/Screenshots Attached: YesSummary:
Through minecraft challenge videos, I had noticed a certain difference in resources between the Java and Bedrock editions. In the Java edition, players can slowly fall with the boat, just by getting out and back from it, which is not possible in the Bedrock edition of the gameDespite being a small resource, some people may miss it, especially the challenge community, which tends to use the item a lot, either to fall with the boat over greater distances, or to fall slowly and trick other players.
Steps to Reproduce:
1. In minecraft Java Edition, place a boat in a high floor and fall with it
2. While in the fallen, start to leave and ride in the boat
Observed Results:In the Bedrock edition of the game, when trying to replicate, the boat will maintain the same speed during the fall, therefore, the player will not have as much control as in the Java edition, having a greater chance of falling and being defeated.
Expected Results:
Just like in the Java edition, the boat should have its fall slowed for a brief moment, so that the bedrock player would be able to replicate the action
Videos/Screenshots Attached: Yes
Summary:
Through minecraft challenge videos, I had noticed a certain difference in resources between the Java and Bedrock editions. In the Java edition, players can slowly fall with the boat, just by getting out and back from it, which is not possible in the Bedrock edition of the gameDespite being a small resource, some people may miss it, especially the challenge community, which tends to use the item a lot, either to fall with the boat over greater distances, or to fall slowly and trick other players.
Steps to Reproduce:
1. In minecraft Java Edition, place a boat in a high floor and fall with it
2. While in the fallen, start to leave and ride
in the boat
Observed Results:In the Bedrock edition of the game, when trying to replicate, the boat will maintain the same speed during the fall, therefore, the player will not have as much control as in the Java edition, having a greater chance of falling and being defeated.
Expected Results:
Just like in the Java edition, the boat should have its fall slowed for a brief moment, so that the bedrock player would be able to replicate the action
Videos/Screenshots Attached: YesSummary:
Through minecraft challenge videos, I had noticed a certain difference in resources between the Java and Bedrock editions. In the Java edition, players can slowly fall with the boat, just by getting out and back from it, which is not possible in the Bedrock edition of the gameDespite being a small resource, some people may miss it, especially the challenge community, which tends to use the item a lot, either to fall with the boat over greater distances, or to fall slowly and trick other players.
Steps to Reproduce:
1. In minecraft Java Edition, place a boat in a high floor and fall with it
2. While in the fallen, start to leave and ride on the boat
Observed Results:In the Bedrock edition of the game, when trying to replicate, the boat will maintain the same speed during the fall, therefore, the player will not have as much control as in the Java edition, having a greater chance of falling and being defeated.
Expected Results:
Just like in the Java edition, the boat should have its fall slowed for a brief moment, so that the bedrock player would be able to replicate the action
Videos/Screenshots Attached: Yes
Invalid. This parity issue predates the Buzzy Bees update.
![[Mod] Jarl-Penguin](../../../data/avatars/users/92849.png){kind=small}
Summary:
Throughminecraft challenge videos, I had noticed a certain difference in resources between the Java and Bedrock editions. IntheJavaedition, players can slowly fall with the boat, just by getting out and back from it, which is not possible intheBedrockeditionof the gameDespite being a small resource, some people may miss it, especially the challenge community, which tends to use the item a lot, either to fall with the boat over greater distances, or to fall slowly and trick other players.
Steps to Reproduce:
1. In minecraft Java Edition, place a boat in a high floor and fall with it
2. While in the fallen, start to leave and ride on the boat
Observed Results:In the Bedrock edition of the game, when trying to replicate, the boat will maintain the same speed during the fall, therefore, the player will not have as much control as in the Java edition, having a greater chance of falling and being defeated.
Expected Results:
Just like in the Java edition, the boat should have its fall slowed for a brief moment, so that the bedrock player would be able to replicate the action
Videos/Screenshots Attached: YesSummary:
Through Minecraft challenge videos, I had noticed a certain difference in resources between the Java and Bedrock editions. In Java Edition, players can slowly fall with the boat, just by getting out and back from it, which is not possible in Bedrock Edition.Despite being a small resource, some people may miss it, especially the challenge community, which tends to use the item a lot, either to fall with the boat over greater distances, or to fall slowly and trick other players.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Build a tall pillar going upwards (~20 or so blocks, not exact)
- Place a boat down on top of the pillar, and mount it
- Mount the boat and ride it off the pillar
- Quickly dismount the boat, and then immediately mount it again. Notice that unlike Java Edition the boat doesn't stop when the player mounts/dismounts it.
Observed Results:
The boat will maintain the same speed during the fall, therefore, the player will not have as much control as in Java Edition, having a greater chance of falling and being defeated.Expected Results:
Just like in Java Edition, the boat should have its fall slowed for a brief moment.
Summary:
Through Minecraft challenge videos, I had noticed a certain difference in resources between the Java and Bedrock editions. In Java Edition, players can slowly fall with the boat, just by getting out and back from it, which is not possible in Bedrock Edition.Despite being a small resource, some people may miss it, especially the challenge community, which tends to use the item a lot, either to fall with the boat over greater distances, or to fall slowly and trick other players.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Build a tall pillar going upwards (~20 or so blocks, not exact)
- Place a boat down on top of the pillar, and mount it
- Mount the boat and ride it off the pillar
- Quickly dismount the boat, and then immediately mount it again.
Notice that unlike Java Edition the boat doesn't stop when the player mounts/dismounts it.Observed Results:
The boat will maintain the same speed during the fall, therefore, the player will not have as much control as in Java Edition, having a greater chance of falling and being defeated.Expected Results:
Just like in Java Edition, the boat should have its fall slowed for a brief moment.
It is not possible to slowly fall with a boat in Minecraft BedrockThe momentum and motion of a entity will not be reset when a player mounts it
relates to
![[Mod] OcelotOnesie](../../../data/avatars/users/43220.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
Duplicates MCPE-180472
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MCPE-180472, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support (Technical Issues) – 📧 Microsoft Support (Account Issues)
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! The ticket was resolved by one of our moderators, and I left this message to give more information to you.
Relates to MC-174877
Can confirm in 1.21.2.
Steps to reproduce (from MC-174877):
Affects 1.21.50.22