MC-115025Clicking on recipe or on book to close crafting help additionally clicks in inventory
The bug
When you click on a recipe or on the crafting book to close the help again you additionally click at your inventory and might pick up or throw items this way.
How to reproduce (crafting help on the left side)
Reproduction steps for 17w18b+
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown on the left next to your inventory.
Picking up items from crafting grid
- Right click a crafting table
- Put an item in the slot in the middle of the right column of the crafting grid
- Click on left border of the book to close it
→ You picked up the item from the crafting grid
Dropping item
- Open your inventory
- Open the recipe book
- Pick up an item with your cursor
- Click on the book to close it again
→ The item you were holding is dropped on the right side of your inventory
Linked Issues
is duplicated by2
Attachments1
Created Issue:
crafting recipe loses ingredient beneath mouse
When using a recipe on the crafting table (e.g. an item frame or a clock) the ingredients are taken from the inventory, but one item beneath the mouse pointer gets removed after a fraction of a second. If the player had exactly the ingredients to create one item, the item becomes uncraftable for lack of ingredients.
Steps to reproduce:
1. Create new world in creative mode
2. Use give command to obtain ingredients
/give @p minecraft:crafting_table
/give @p minecraft:stick 8
/give @p minecraft:leather
3. Switch to survival mode
4. place crafting table on the ground, open crafting menu, select recipe book, select tab for item frame recipe, select craftable only
5, Click on item frame reciperesult:
recipe closes, mouse hovers over middle left stick in the crafting grid, the stick vanishes within a fraction of a second. The recipe is incomplete and the item frame can not be crafted.expected result:
recipe closes and player can move mouse to crafted item and obtain an item frameEnvironment
Windows 10, Java 1.8.0_25, Intel i5-3450, internal graphics
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
duplicates
duplicates
![[Mod] Ezekiel (ezfe)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/ezekielelin.jpeg){kind=small}
blocks
relates to
blocks
crafting recipeloses ingredient beneath mouseClicking on recipe or on book to close crafting help additionally clicks in inventory
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/assets/gravatar/mustek2.png){kind=small}
Windows 10, Java 1.8.0_25, Intel i5-3450, internal graphics
When
usinga recipe on the craftingtable (e.g. an item frame or aclock)theingredients are taken from the inventory, but one item beneath the mouse pointer gets removed after a fraction of a second. If the player had exactly the ingredients to create oneitem,the item becomes uncraftable for lack of ingredients.Steps to reproduce:
1. Create new world in creative mode
2. Use give command to obtain ingredients
/give @p minecraft:crafting_table
/give @p minecraft:stick 8
/give @p minecraft:leather
3. Switch to survival mode
4. place crafting table on the ground, open crafting menu, select recipe book, select tab for item frame recipe, select craftable only
5, Click on item frame reciperesult:
recipe closes, mouse hovers over middle left stick in the crafting grid, the stick vanishes within a fraction of a second. The recipe is incomplete and the item frame can not be crafted.expected result:
recipe closes and player can move mouse to crafted item and obtain an item frameThe bug
When you click on a recipe or on the crafting book to close the help again you additionally click at your inventory and might pick up or throw items this way.
How to reproduce (overlapping crafting help)
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown in the middle covering your inventory.
- Use /give command to obtain ingredients
/give @p minecraft:crafting_table/give @p minecraft:stick 8/give @p minecraft:leather- Make sure you have the item frame recipe
/recipe give @p minecraft:item_frame- Place a crafting table on the ground, open crafting menu, select recipe book
- Search for "item frame" and make sure it is in the first row and the first or second column of the results
- Click on item frame recipe
→ You will notice that you threw an item from the crafting grid out of your inventoryHow to reproduce (crafting help on the left side)
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown on the left next to your inventory.
- Place any item in the right middle slot
- Open the crafting help
- Click on the book to close it again
→ You will notice that you picked up the item
relates to
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
Maria Lemónis duplicated by
relates to
The bug
When you click on a recipe or on the crafting book to close the help again you additionally click at your inventory and might pick up or throw items this way.
How to reproduce (
overlappingcrafting help)Use these steps if the crafting help is shown in the middle covering your inventory.
- Use /give command to obtain ingredients
/give @p minecraft:crafting_table/give @p minecraft:stick 8/give @p minecraft:leather- Make sure you have the item frame recipe
/recipe give @p minecraft:item_frame- Place a crafting table on the ground, open crafting menu, select recipe book
- Search for "item frame" and make sure it is in the first row and the first or second column of the results
- Click on item frame recipe
→ You will notice that you threw an item from the crafting grid out of your inventoryHow to reproduce (crafting help on the left side)
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown on the left next to your inventory.
Place any item in the right middle slotOpen the crafting help- Click on the book to close it again
→ You will notice that you picked up the itemThe bug
When you click on a recipe or on the crafting book to close the help again you additionally click at your inventory and might pick up or throw items this way.
How to reproduce (crafting help on the left side)
These steps are for 17w18b+
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown on the left next to your inventory.
- Open the recipe book
- Pick up an item with your cursor
- Click on the book to close it again
→ You will notice that you picked up the item
The bug
When you click on a recipe or on the crafting book to close the help again you additionally click at your inventory and might pick up or throw items this way.
How to reproduce (crafting help
on the left side)These steps are for 17w18b+
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown on the left next to your inventory.
Open the recipe bookPick up an item with your cursor- Click on the book to close it again
→ You will notice that you picked up the itemThe bug
When you click on a recipe or on the crafting book to close the help again you additionally click at your inventory and might pick up or throw items this way.
How to reproduce (overlapping crafting help)
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown in the middle covering your inventory.
- Use /give command to obtain ingredients
/give @p minecraft:crafting_table/give @p minecraft:stick 8/give @p minecraft:leather- Make sure you have the item frame recipe
/recipe give @p minecraft:item_frame- Place a crafting table on the ground, open crafting menu, select recipe book
- Search for "item frame" and make sure it is in the first row and the first or second column of the results
- Click on item frame recipe
→ You will notice that you threw an item from the crafting grid out of your inventoryHow to reproduce (crafting help on the left side)
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown on the left next to your inventory.
- Place any item in the right middle slot
- Open the crafting help
- Click on the book to close it again
→ You will notice that you picked up the item
The bug
When you click on a recipe or on the crafting book to close the help again you additionally click at your inventory and might pick up or throw items this way.
How to reproduce (
overlappingcrafting help)Use these steps if the crafting help is shown
in themiddle coveringyour inventory.
- Use /give command to obtain ingredients
/give @p minecraft:crafting_table/give @p minecraft:stick 8/give @p minecraft:leather- Make sure you have the item frame recipe
/recipe give @p minecraft:item_frame- Place a crafting table on the ground, open crafting menu, select recipe book
- Search for "item frame" and make sure it is in the first row and the first or second column of the results
- Click on item frame recipe
→ Youwill notice that you threw anitem from the crafting gridout of your inventoryHow to reproduce (crafting help on the left side)
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown on the left next to your inventory.
Place any item in the right middle slotOpen the crafting help- Click on the book to close it again
→You will notice that you pickeduptheitemThe bug
When you click on a recipe or on the crafting book to close the help again you additionally click at your inventory and might pick up or throw items this way.
How to reproduce (crafting help on the left side)
Reproduction steps for 17w18b
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown on the left next to your inventory.
Picking up items from crafting grid
- Right click a crafting table
- Put an item in the slot in the middle of the right column of the crafting grid
- Click on left border of the book to close it
→ You picked up the item from the crafting gridDropping item
- Open your inventory
- Open the recipe book
- Pick up an item with your cursor
- Click on the book to close it again
→ The item you were holding is dropped on the right side of your inventory
Reverted the reproduction steps change because it appears the bug is not fixed at all (?).
The bug
When you click on a recipe or on the crafting book to close the help again you additionally click at your inventory and might pick up or throw items this way.
How to reproduce (crafting help on the left side)
Reproduction steps for 17w18b+
Use these steps if the crafting help is shown on the left next to your inventory.
Picking up items from crafting grid
- Right click a crafting table
- Put an item in the slot in the middle of the right column of the crafting grid
- Click on left border of the book to close it
→ You picked up the item from the crafting gridDropping item
- Open your inventory
- Open the recipe book
- Pick up an item with your cursor
- Click on the book to close it again
→ The item you were holding is dropped on the right side of your inventory
I'm not sure, MC-115025 is really a duplicate.
In MC-114943 you put items into the grid, then select a recipe. The target item gets created and the items put into the grid are deleted.
In MC-115025 the recipe pulls the ingredients out of the inventory, then deletes the ingredient which happens to be beneath the mouse pointer and fails to craft the target item. (I have now attached a video to MC-115025)
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been closed as a Duplicate of MC-115025.
It has been linked to this report. If you have additional information, please add it to that report.
Please search before reporting, as it's likely that one exists already.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – 📖 Game Wiki
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
Whoa, this report isn't about clicking on buttons also dropping things, this report is about the fact that items can be dropped anywhere in the recipe interface – even with right-click when you aren't interacting with any buttons.
EDIT: If you think they're similar enough to be merged, would you mind adding this information to the description of MC-115025?
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been closed as a Duplicate of MC-115025.
It has been linked to this report. If you have additional information, please add it to that report.
Please search before reporting, as it's likely that one exists already.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – 📖 Game Wiki
Left or right-clicking while holding an item stack has different results in different parts of different inventories.
✔ = makes sense
✘ = needs change
Most Inventories and Containers:
✔ Right and left-click both drop items only when outside the GUI area.
Creative Menu:
✘ Right-click drops an item anywhere unless you're hovering over a slot.
✔ Left-click drops the items anywhere except for when hovering over a slot or tab.
Recipe Interface:
✘ Right and left-click both fail to drop items in the area where tabs can appear, even when not hovering over a tab.
Related to MC-115025.
Please do not mark unreleased versions as affected.
You don't have access to them yet.
Still happens in 17w17a when clicking tabs. The tab will be switched and any item in your hand will be dropped.
Still happens in 1.12 pre-2 when clicking to open the recipe book while holding an item. The inventory shift can put the item outside the inventory and it will be dropped.
Note that pressing the mouse button down on the recipe book without releasing will shift the inventory, but will not drop the item. The item is dropped on mouse release.