Haste does not work correctly due to rounding
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (done in 1.13.1-pre2 by mining a 10*9 area, see picture for more details) :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 (time to mine the 90 blocks in ticks)
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 716
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
I did try this on Oak Planks as well and I got the same results.
I wanted to compare with something, here are the results :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Pickaxe with Efficiency V on Stone : 711
Diam Pick Effi V with Haste II on Stone : 150
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So yeah, there is definitively somthingwrong with Axes...
Addendum :
During my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment... (Note : That isn't the case with Wooden Axe that takes about 820 ticks)...
Linked Issues
is duplicated by4
MC-135237Efficiency and Haste might have no effectDuplicateMC-239137Mining Deepslate takes longer than expected when under Haste EffectDuplicateMC-239967Haste effect is not as fast as advertisedDuplicateMC-265419Haste I or II from a Beacon never makes breaking wood with an Efficiency V Netherrite Axe faster than 0.1 secondsDuplicaterelates to1
Attachments1
Created Issue:
Haste does not work on axes
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster.
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
![[Mod] Sonicwave](../../../data/avatars/users/94627.png){kind=small}
Unable to reproduce in 1.13.1-pre2 using unenchanted diamond and stone axes to break logs; the difference in breaking speed is slight, but it seems to be consistent with breaking other blocks (e.g. sand with fist).
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (mining 10*9 area, times in ticks, see picture for more details) :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 - 715 - 713
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714 - 719 - 718
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
But during my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment...
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (mining 10*9 area, times in ticks, see picture for more details) :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 - 715 - 713
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714 - 719 - 718
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
But during my testing I found something else, I let you see :-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment...
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (mining 10*9 area, times in ticks, see picture for more details) :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 - 715 - 713
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714 - 719 - 718
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
I did try this on Oak Planks as well and I got the same results.
I wanted to compare with something, here are the results :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Pickaxe with Efficiency V on Stone : 711
Diam Pick Effi V with Haste II on Stone : 150
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So yeah, there is definitively somthingwrong with Axes...
Addendum :
During my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment... (Note : That isn't the case with Wooden Axe that takes about 820 ticks)...
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (mining 10*9 area
, times in ticks, see picture for more details) :-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 - 715 - 713
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714 - 719 - 718
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
I did try this on Oak Planks as well and I got the same results.
I wanted to compare with something, here are the results :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Pickaxe with Efficiency V on Stone : 711
Diam Pick Effi V with Haste II on Stone : 150
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So yeah, there is definitively somthingwrong with Axes...
Addendum :
During my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment... (Note : That isn't the case with Wooden Axe that takes about 820 ticks)...
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (done in 1.13pre-2mining 10*9 area, see picture for more details) :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 - 715 - 713 (in ticks)
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714 - 719 - 718
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
I did try this on Oak Planks as well and I got the same results.
I wanted to compare with something, here are the results :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Pickaxe with Efficiency V on Stone : 711
Diam Pick Effi V with Haste II on Stone : 150
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So yeah, there is definitively somthingwrong with Axes...
Addendum :
During my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment... (Note : That isn't the case with Wooden Axe that takes about 820 ticks)...
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (done in 1.13
pre-2mining 10*9 area, see picture for more details) :-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 - 715 - 713 (in ticks)
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714 - 719 - 718
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
I did try this on Oak Planks as well and I got the same results.
I wanted to compare with something, here are the results :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Pickaxe with Efficiency V on Stone : 711
Diam Pick Effi V with Haste II on Stone : 150
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So yeah, there is definitively somthingwrong with Axes...
Addendum :
During my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment... (Note : That isn't the case with Wooden Axe that takes about 820 ticks)...
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (done in 1.13.1-pre2 by mining a 10*9 area, see picture for more details) :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 - 715 - 713 (in ticks)
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714 - 719 - 718
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
I did try this on Oak Planks as well and I got the same results.
I wanted to compare with something, here are the results :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Pickaxe with Efficiency V on Stone : 711
Diam Pick Effi V with Haste II on Stone : 150
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So yeah, there is definitively somthingwrong with Axes...
Addendum :
During my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment... (Note : That isn't the case with Wooden Axe that takes about 820 ticks)...
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (done in 1.13.1-pre2 by mining a 10*9 area, see picture for more details) :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 - 715 - 713 (time to mine the 90 blocks in ticks)
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714 - 719 - 718
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
I did try this on Oak Planks as well and I got the same results.
I wanted to compare with something, here are the results :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Pickaxe with Efficiency V on Stone : 711
Diam Pick Effi V with Haste II on Stone : 150
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So yeah, there is definitively somthingwrong with Axes...
Addendum :
During my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment... (Note : That isn't the case with Wooden Axe that takes about 820 ticks)...
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (done in 1.13.1-pre2 by mining a 10*9 area, see picture for more details) :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715
- 715 - 713(time to mine the 90 blocks in ticks)Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 71
4 - 719 - 718Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
I did try this on Oak Planks as well and I got the same results.
I wanted to compare with something, here are the results :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Pickaxe with Efficiency V on Stone : 711
Diam Pick Effi V with Haste II on Stone : 150
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So yeah, there is definitively somthingwrong with Axes...
Addendum :
During my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment... (Note : That isn't the case with Wooden Axe that takes about 820 ticks)...
Having Haste 2 doesn't make you cut logs faster. (Only tried with an Efficiency 5 diamond axe)
(I know this is a duplicate of
MC-25330, but it's still the case in 1.13...)
Here is some testing I have done (done in 1.13.1-pre2 by mining a 10*9 area, see picture for more details) :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 715 (time to mine the 90 blocks in ticks)
Diam Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 716
Diam Axe Effi V with Mining Fatigue II on Oak Logs : 2314
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Axe on Oak Logs : 1246
Diam Axe with Haste II on Oak Logs : 1068
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the Haste effect seems to work on axes with low efficiency value, but doesn't seems to work on axes with high efficiency value...
I did try this on Oak Planks as well and I got the same results.
I wanted to compare with something, here are the results :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diamond Pickaxe with Efficiency V on Stone : 711
Diam Pick Effi V with Haste II on Stone : 150
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So yeah, there is definitively somthingwrong with Axes...
Addendum :
During my testing I found something else, I let you see :
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STONE Axe with Efficiency V on Oak Logs : 711
STONE Axe Effi V with Haste II on Oak Logs : 714
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Stone Axe with Efficiency V is as fast as Diamond Axe with the same enchantment... (Note : That isn't the case with Wooden Axe that takes about 820 ticks)...
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
Haste does not workon axesHaste does not work correctly due to rounding
is duplicated by
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mod] SPGoding](../../../data/avatars/users/44622.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mod] markderickson](../../../data/avatars/users/18946.svg){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mod] ampolive](../../../data/avatars/users/18949.svg){kind=small}
Forward-resolving to MC-136213.
Might be a duplicate of MC-136213.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-136213 and MC-239137, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! The ticket was resolved by one of our moderators, and I left this message to give more information to you.
![[Mod] Anthony Cicinelli](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-136213, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
![[Mod] j_p_smith](../../../data/avatars/users/92851.png){kind=small}
Thank you for your report!
We're actually already tracking this issue in MC-136213, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote or any additional information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
Please be sure to use the search feature before creating a ticket to see if the issue has already been reported.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 🛠 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 💬 Mojira Discord
Actually, its a duplicate of this one: MC-136213 you're already tracking this parity problem.
Cannot reproduce. (Haste will still affect the mining speed of a diamond axe unless it has a high efficiency enchantment)
[Helper] gaspoweredpick, I haven't verified it myself, but apparently, and when looking at
MC-25330, this would apply only to axes and chopping wood.Unable to reproduce in 1.13.1-pre2 using unenchanted diamond and stone axes to break logs; the difference in breaking speed is slight, but it seems to be consistent with breaking other blocks (e.g. sand with fist).
As there is a lot of 'cannot reproduce' in the comments, I've decided to run a proper test.
You can see the results in the main message.
From my calculations, haste does indeed have an effect on breaking time. However, due to Minecraft's level of imprecision with its tickrate, all breaking times are rounded up to the nearest 0.05s, which means it does not have a tangible effect in this instance.
Strange thing is that it's working fine on pickaxes ...
EDIT : Wait... maybe not, the stone might have a lower breaking time than the log, thus the breaking time of the stone with effi V and haste II might be lower than 0.05...
Stone's breaking hardness is 1.5, while logs are 2, so you are exactly right.
Can confirm in 1.17.1.
Per
MC-265419affects 1.20.1.Why would this be exclusive to axes? Shouldn't it affect any block that's hardness is exactly 2, such as cobblestone, bricks, smooth stone, nether bricks, etc?
It's not exclusive to them, the report description was just never changed to state other examples, nor does it need to.
We still have this problem in 1.21.1
MC-276792