Illager captain spawned from raids will still give the bad omen effect to its killer, causing raids to never end
The bug
When a illager captain (an illager with a banner) that spawned during a raid, is killed, it will still give its killer the bad omen effect, causing raids to never end.
Original description
Description:
When starting a raid and sending the banner carrier (spawned from the raid) to the nether you can get the bad omen effect from him. This allows the player to start a raid over and over again by sending at least 1 banner carrier to the nether.
What I expected to happen:
The banner carriers spawned from raids don't give the bad omen effect.
What actually happened
The banner carriers spawned from raids give the bad omen effect when killed in the nether (where there is no raid active).
Steps to reproduce:
1) Start a raid in the overworld
2) Lure the banner carriers to the nether
3) Kill the banner carriers in the nether (make sure there is no raid active in the nether). Each banner carrier equals 1 level of bad omen which can be brought back to the overworld to start another raid.
Linked Issues
is duplicated by14
MC-149222Bad Omen Obtained During Raids From Pillager Tower NearbyDuplicateMC-150317Unlimited raid wavesDuplicateMC-151247Raid pillager leader gives bad omen status effectDuplicateMC-151551Raid Never EndsDuplicateMC-151829Built my own village, but when I cured a villager I got infinite raids.DuplicateMC-152386Infinite Raids/ Village Location WrongDuplicateMC-152395Endless Village RaidDuplicateMC-152676banner pillagers in raids giving bad omen DuplicateMC-153333Constant bad omen, and more raids (village raid range check should change?)DuplicateMC-153681Illager captains in raids can start another raid DuplicateMC-153836Pillagers infinitely raid.DuplicateMC-153909Infinite/Repeating RaidsDuplicateMC-153973Рейды DuplicateMC-154584infinite raidsDuplicate
Created Issue:
Banner carriers spawned from raids will give the bad omen effect when killed in the nether
Description:
When starting a raid and sending the banner carrier (spawned from the raid) to the nether you can get the bad omen effect from him. This allows the player to start a raid over and over again by sending at least 1 banner carrier to the nether.
What I expected to happen:
The banner carriers spawned from raids don't give the bad omen effect.
What actually happened
The banner carriers spawned from raids give the bad omen effect when killed in the nether (where there is no raid active).
Steps to reproduce:
1) Start a raid in the overworld
2) Lure the banner carriers to the nether
3) Kill the banner carriers in the nether (make sure there is no raid active in the nether). Each banner carrier equals 1 level of bad omen which can be brought back to the overworld to start another raid.
Environment
Windows 10 64 bit
Nvidia geforce GTX 1060
Intel core i7-7700HQ
16GB of RAM
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
Description:
When starting a raid and sending the banner carrier (spawned from the raid) to the nether you can get the bad omen effect from him. This allows the player to start a raid over and over again by sending at least 1 banner carrier to the nether.
What I expected to happen:
The banner carriers spawned from raids don't give the bad omen effect.
What actually happened
The banner carriers spawned from raids give the bad omen effect when killed in the nether (where there is no raid active).
Steps to reproduce:
1) Start a raid in the overworld
2) Lure the banner carriers to the nether
3) Kill the banner carriers in the nether (make sure there is no raid active in the nether). Each banner carrier equals 1 level of bad omen which can be brought back to the overworld to start another raid.
The bug
When a illager captain (an illager with a banner) that spawned during a raid, is killed, it will still give its killer the bad omen effect, causing raids to never end.
Original description
Description:
When starting a raid and sending the banner carrier (spawned from the raid) to the nether you can get the bad omen effect from him. This allows the player to start a raid over and over again by sending at least 1 banner carrier to the nether.
What I expected to happen:
The banner carriers spawned from raids don't give the bad omen effect.
What actually happened
The banner carriers spawned from raids give the bad omen effect when killed in the nether (where there is no raid active).
Steps to reproduce:
1) Start a raid in the overworld
2) Lure the banner carriers to the nether
3) Kill the banner carriers in the nether (make sure there is no raid active in the nether). Each banner carrier equals 1 level of bad omen which can be brought back to the overworld to start another raid.
Windows 10 64 bit
Nvidia geforce GTX 1060
Intel core i7-7700HQ
16GB of RAM
Banner carriersspawned from raids will give the bad omen effectwhen killed in the netherIllager captain spawned from raids will still give the bad omen effect to its killer, causing raids to never end
relates to
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Asteraoth](../../../data/avatars/users/92886.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Cory Scheviak](../../../data/avatars/users/92893.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Cory Scheviak![[Bot] Piston](../../../data/avatars/users/31202.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
Duplicate of MC-146835
I'm sorry - but I don't see how our bug is a duplicate of the one with the nether. We don't even have a nether portal yet. Could you please explain why you think our situation is the same as MC-146835 ?
Also, I tried attaching my saved world here (after 9+ Raids), but it's a 50MB Zip file which is beyond the accepted filesize. So now, instead I uploaded it as separate files - one main ZIP archive missing the bigger region files, those I've attached separately (they all go into the region folder)
MC-146835 is about the illager captain giving you the bad omen effect even during a raid. You can see that by moving him into the nether, and you need that to prevent that the bad omen level is immediately counted towards the raid. That doesn't mean it doesn't happen if you don't move the illager captain to the nether.
Duplicate of MC-146835
Duplicate of MC-146835
Only one issue per ticket please.
Getting bad omen from illagers spawned in a raid is MC-146835.
Duplicate of MC-146835
Even if this is intentional, its a pretty bad game design that allows for these never ending raids. A lot of things about raids are being re-worked at the moment (like raiders with banners no longer giving bad oman, another issue that caused infinite raids MC-146835) and this issue should be one of those things reworked. Pretty simple fix, saves a ton of hassle for players.
Duplicate of MC-146835
Still affects 1.16.4
Kingsley Zhang, in that case, please file a new bug report.