MC-156161Some chest loot is randomized across the same seed, unlike before 1.14
Certain chest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location, when it didn't before 1.14. This behavior is different than all other chest loot, and applies to villages, pillager outposts, ruined portals, and bastion remnants. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly teleport to a village chest (the first one is a plains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table).
/tp @p 1.5 64 43.5
/tp @p 653.5 71 -810
Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5
Linked Issues
MCPE-72432Attachments5
![[Helper] gaspoweredpick](../../../data/avatars/users/80904.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Village loot is inconsistent across the same seed
Village loot never generates consistently in different worlds with the same seed and different location. -336141819713325 is the seed used in this example world. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly go to a village chest.
/tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5
Attachments6
Screen Shot 2019-07-06 at 11.59.15 AM.png
Village loot never generates consistently in different worlds with the same seed and
differentlocation. -336141819713325 is the seed used in this example world. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly go to a village chest./tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5Village loot never generates consistently in different worlds with the same seed and location. -336141819713325 is the seed used in this example world. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly go to a village chest.
/tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5
Village
loot nevergeneratesconsistently in different worlds with the same seed and location. -336141819713325 is the seed used in this example world. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly go to a village chest./tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5Village chest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location, unlike all other chest loot. -336141819713325 is the seed used in this example world. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly go to a village chest (the first one is the plains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table).
/tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5
Village chest loot is inconsistent across the same seed
Village chest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location, unlike all other chest loot. -336141819713325 is the seed used in this example world. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly
goto a village chest (the first one istheplains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table)./tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5Village chest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location, unlike all other chest loot. -336141819713325 is the seed used in this example world. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly teleport to a village chest (the first one is a plains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table).
/tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5
![[Mod] NeunEinser](../../../data/avatars/users/39263.png){kind=small}
Village chest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location, unlike all other chest loot. -336141819713325
is the seed used in this example world. To reproduce, createtwodifferent worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. Thesecommands are for the seed-336141819713325 to quickly teleport to a village chest (the first one is a plains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table)./tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5Village chest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location, unlike all other chest loot. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly teleport to a village chest (the first one is a plains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table).
/tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5
Village chest loot isinconsistentacross the same seedVillage chest loot is randomized across the same seed, unlike before 1.14
Village chest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location,
unlikeall other chest loot. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly teleport to a village chest (the first one is a plains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table)./tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5Village chest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location, when it didn't before 1.14. This behavior is different than all other chest loot. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly teleport to a village chest (the first one is a plains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table).
/tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
Very Important
Villagechest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location, when it didn't before 1.14. This behavior is different than all other chest loot. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly teleport to a village chest (the first one is a plains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table)./tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5Certain chest loot generates randomly in different worlds with the same seed and location, when it didn't before 1.14. This behavior is different than all other chest loot, and applies to villages, pillager outposts, ruined portals, and bastion remnants. To reproduce, create two different worlds with the same seed and notice that the same village has different loot for the same chests. These commands are for the seed -336141819713325 to quickly teleport to a village chest (the first one is a plains house loot table, the second is a plains weaponsmith loot table).
/tp @p 1.5 64 43.5/tp @p 653.5 71 -810Other loot generates correctly when doing the same thing.
/tp @p 327.5 60 46.5
Village chest loot is randomized across the same seed, unlike before 1.14Some chest loot is randomized across the same seed, unlike before 1.14
![[Mojang] Matthew Gatland](../../../data/avatars/users/43046.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Matthew Gatland![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Bot] Piston](../../../data/avatars/users/31202.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
relates to
Your "point" doesn't make any sense at all. Villages used to generate consistent loot before 1.14 so this is certainly a bug.
I believe this is intentional, village chests generate loot inside them at the moment you open them, not through world generation.
Relates to
MC-127839(fixed at undetermined version)Affects 1.15-pre6 as well. The problem is that the game is not seeding the village chests. They should have their `LootTableSeed` set based on the world seed and coordinates, or some other hashing method based on the world seed. You can verify the absence of this tag by using `data get block` on a village chest that has not been opened.
Confirmed for pillager outposts, ruined portals, and bastion remnants.
Probably because of this fix, some structures no longer contain any loot at all:
MC-186067Can a mod please reprove gaspoweredpick? I've seen him being toxic on numerous occasions and he is proving disruptive to this board's efforts with his constant hostile attitude towards reporters. Sorry for having to post it here.