MCPE-72432Some loot chests have different loot in the same seed
The bug
Some, but not all, chests in structures have different loot even when using the same world seed. The following is a complete description of which structures are affected.
About half of the chests give the same loot, but in a random order. This is indicated with a 
, but the order should be fixed as well. Additionally, enchantments are always different, even in the consistent chests.
Seed for all of these examples: -626760004
Desert Temple
/tp 1641 53 -406
Same loot, different order
Shipwreck
/tp 39369 36 2438
Same loot, different order
Buried Treasure
/tp 39320 36 2185
Same loot, different order
Pillager Outpost
/tp 2746 83 5609
Same loot, different order
Ocean Ruins
/tp 2332 34 14452
Same loot, different order
Igloo Basement
/tp 23628 49 37922
Same loot, different order
Woodland Mansion
/tp 14572 91 14420
Same loot, different order
Nether Fortress
/tp 5242 53 -66
Same loot, different order
End City
/tp -648 120 977
Same loot, different order
Village
/tp 1456 89 127
Abandoned Mineshaft
/tp 1284 26 45
Chest didn't even generate in one world
Dungeon
/tp 1241 33 702
Stronghold
/tp 947 36 1041
Ruined Portal
/tp 964 66 2548
Jungle Temple
/tp 9846 75 2403
Piglin Bastion
/tp 5016 73 446
Linked Issues
BDS-9354
MC-156161Attachments35
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Some loot chests have different loot in the same seed
The bug
Some, but not all, chests in structures have different loot even when using the same world seed. The following is a mostly complete description of which structures are affected:
Seed for all of these examples: -626760004
/tp 1641 53 -406
Same loot, different order
/tp 39369 36 2438
Same loot, different order
/tp 39320 36 2185
Same loot, different order
/tp 2746 83 5609
Same loot, different order
/tp 2332 34 14452
Same loot, different order
/tp 23628 49 37922
Same loot, different order
/tp 14572 91 14420
Same loot, different order
/tp 5242 53 -66
Same loot, different order
/tp -648 120 977
Same loot, different order
/tp 1456 89 127
/tp 1284 26 45
Chest didn't even generate in one world
/tp 1241 33 702
/tp 947 36 1041
/tp 964 66 2548
/tp 9846 75 2403
/tp 5016 73 446
Attachments33
The bug
Some, but not all, chests in structures have different loot even when using the same world seed. The following is a
mostlycomplete description of which structures are affected:Seed for all of these examples: -626760004
/tp 1641 53 -406
Same loot, different order
/tp 39369 36 2438
Same loot, different order
/tp 39320 36 2185
Same loot, different order
/tp 2746 83 5609
Same loot, different order
/tp 2332 34 14452
Same loot, different order
/tp 23628 49 37922
Same loot, different order
/tp 14572 91 14420
Same loot, different order
/tp 5242 53 -66
Same loot, different order
/tp -648 120 977
Same loot, different order
/tp 1456 89 127
/tp 1284 26 45
Chest didn't even generate in one world
/tp 1241 33 702
/tp 947 36 1041
/tp 964 66 2548
/tp 9846 75 2403
/tp 5016 73 446
The bug
Some, but not all, chests in structures have different loot even when using the same world seed. The following is a complete description of which structures are affected.
About half of the chests give the same loot, but in a random order. This is indicated with a
Seed for all of these examples: -626760004
/tp 1641 53 -406
Same loot, different order
/tp 39369 36 2438
Same loot, different order
/tp 39320 36 2185
Same loot, different order
/tp 2746 83 5609
Same loot, different order
/tp 2332 34 14452
Same loot, different order
/tp 23628 49 37922
Same loot, different order
/tp 14572 91 14420
Same loot, different order
/tp 5242 53 -66
Same loot, different order
/tp -648 120 977
Same loot, different order
/tp 1456 89 127
/tp 1284 26 45
Chest didn't even generate in one world
/tp 1241 33 702
/tp 947 36 1041
/tp 964 66 2548
/tp 9846 75 2403
/tp 5016 73 446
relates to
![[Mod] OcelotOnesie](../../../data/avatars/users/43220.png){kind=small}
![[MCQA] Kinga Izdebska](../../../data/avatars/users/18949.svg){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mod] LateLag](../../../data/avatars/users/92884.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Mod] Jarl-Penguin](../../../data/avatars/users/92849.png){kind=small}
relates to
Summary
Soul speed enchanted books can be found in stronghold library room chests.
Steps to reproduce
- Use the /locate command to find a stronghold
- Find a library inside the stronghold
- Open the chests.
- Repeat steps 1-3 in another world for several more times if you can't find a soul speed book (can't provide a consistent seed due to
MCPE-72432) - The enchanted book will contain the soul speed enchantment.
Expected Results
Soul speed should not be obtainable through stronghold library chests
Observed Results
Soul speed can obtained through stronghold chests.
Screenshots/Videos Attached: Yes
Preliminary note: I have searched for this problem, and found very numerous tickets on the subject.... however, I have found none of them OPEN for JAVA edition... all of them are "resolved" which means this is still a bug and not resolved (maybe even resurfaced?).
Since I can't reopen existing tickets, I am forced to open a new one.
I apologise if I should not have created a new ticked... but... I tried this...
Search terms "ruined portal loot"... all status except for "resolved" ... nothing came up except for MCPE-69003 and MCPE-72432 which is not java of course 
The problem - NEW Map using seed: 414284818784059697
Picture attached.... ruined portal @ 80 ~ 48 – No loot 
I tried searching for other portals... even some 15000 blocks away - both positive and negative X and Z coords, just for kicks... and none of them had loot ? This is also a first, as I distinctly recall other 20w... snapshots that did have loot (to my knowledge, I didn't test all ruined portals, just occasionally with no missing loot issues).
Again, I apologise if I wasn't supposed to create this, but I could not find an open ticket for this problem on Java Edition.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MCPE-72432, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 BDS Wiki – 📖 FAQs
The bug
MCPE-72432 was fixed except for this. The enchantments applied to items ignore the seed, resulting in different enchantments every time.
How to reproduce
1. Create a world with seed -626760004
2. Go to the end
3. /tp -648 120 977
4. Look in the right chest and take note of the enchantments on the helmet
5. Repeat steps 1-4 again
→ The enchantments were different
![[Mod] GoldenHelmet](../../../data/avatars/users/18951.svg){kind=small}
The behavior described here may be intended as a direct consequence of fixing MCPE-72432 in 1.16.210.
That said, could you please clarify the report with succinct statements of Expected Behavior and Observed Behavior?
Finally, the attached .zip file has an incorrect manifest and many pointless duplicates of vanilla files. Here is a clean, working pack with your custom bonus chest loot table: Loot copy.mcpack
I think the wiki is outdated based on MCPE-72432. The wiki is not an official source for intended game mechanics.
This may relates to MCPE-72432.
Relates to
MC-156161This could potentially be exploited. On a given seed, you can copy the world several times, go to the same structure, and use the one with the best loot.
I have encountered the more severe version of this bug for Woodland Mansions when playing on BDS. World seed is 853837038, and chest coordinates are 433 79 -11176. The chest contained an enchanted apple when generated in a local world, but did not contain one when generated on the server. Screenshots attached.
Tested some bastion chests in 1.20.32 and it's still random in the same seed/same chest