Ending a raid with only tamed wolf kills will not grant the "hero of the village" effect
If the only kills in a raid are made by a trained wolf and non-player kills (lava damage, fall damage, etc.) the player is not granted the hero of the village effect.
Steps to Reproduce:
(Start test in creative mode)
- Load into the attached world:
WolfRaidTest.zip
- Spawn a wolf, tame it
- Give the wolf and player resistance (for ease)
/effect give @e[type=wolf] minecraft:resistance infinite 255 true /effect give @p minecraft:resistance infinite 255 true
- Start the test with the command block labeled 'Start Test' (this starts a raid)
- Allow the first and second rounds to execute naturally (mobs will suffocate with provided setup), or speed the process up using a '/tick' command
- On the third wave, enable the repeating command block labeled 'Enable on third wave'
- Enter survival mode, allowing the pillager to attack yourself (this alerts the wolf)
- Allow the wolf to kill the pillager, ending the raid
Expected & Observed Results:
- The raid will end, and the player will not be granted hero of the village.
- The player would be granted hero of the village, as their wolf pet had killed a pillager and participated in the raid.
Screenshots/Videos:
Ending the raid with a wolf kill
RaidHeroVillageWolf.mp4
Linked Issues
relates to3
MC-165262Tamed wolves don't trigger the player_hurt_entity or player_killed_entity advancement conditions, but loot tables are written as though tamed wolf kills are player kills.ConfirmedMC-220360Gifts given by baby villagers, nitwits and unemployed villagers when under the Hero of the Village effect are hardcodedFixedMC-186647Villager price changes are extremely inconsistent, and completely break in combination with hero of the villageConfirmed
![[Mod] Jiingy](../../../data/avatars/users/91802.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Trained wolf kills don't grant hero of the village effect
If the only kills in a raid are made by a trained wolf and non-player kills (lava damage, fall damage, etc.) the player is not granted the hero of the village effect. I would think that a kill by a trained wolf would count as a player kill for the purpose of granting the hero of the village, as it does for other purposes.Back
To recreate:
1. Train some wolves and start a raid
2. Let an ill after damage you in the raid so that your wolves attack the illager and get a raid kill
3. Complete the raid using non-player kill methods, so that the only raid kills are by trained wolves. I mostly placed lava underneath the raiders to do this.
4. Once the raid is finished, you will not have been granted hero of the village.Environment
Mac OS, Java 1.16.4
![[Mod] LateLag](../../../data/avatars/users/92884.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] markderickson](../../../data/avatars/users/18946.svg){kind=small}
Mac OS, Java 1.16.4
Trained wolf kills don't grant hero of the village effectTamed wolf kills don't grant hero of the village effect
![[Mod] turbo](../../../data/avatars/users/92867.png){kind=small}
If the only kills in a raid are made by a trained wolf and non-player kills (lava damage, fall damage, etc.) the player is not granted the hero of the village effect.
I would think that a kill by a trained wolf would count as a player kill for the purpose of granting the hero of the village, as it does for other purposes.BackTo recreate:
1. Train some wolves and start a raid
2. Let an ill after damage you in the raid so that your wolves attack the illager and get a raid kill
3. Complete the raid using non-player kill methods, so that the only raid kills are by trained wolves. I mostly placed lava underneath the raiders to do this.4. Once the raid is finished, you will not have been granted hero of the village.If the only kills in a raid are made by a trained wolf and non-player kills (lava damage, fall damage, etc.) the player is not granted the hero of the village effect.
Steps to Reproduce:
(Start test in creative mode)
- Load into the attached world:
WolfRaidTest.zip- Spawn a wolf, tame it
- Give the wolf and player resistance (for ease)
/effect give @e[type=wolf] minecraft:resistance infinite 255 true /effect give @p minecraft:resistance infinite 255 true- Start the test with the command block labeled 'Start Test' (this starts a raid)
- Allow the first and second rounds to execute naturally (mobs will suffocate with provided setup), or speed the process up using a '/tick' command
- On the third wave, enable the repeating command block labeled 'Enable on third wave'
- Enter survival mode, allowing the pillager to attack yourself (this alerts the wolf)
- Allow the wolf to kill the pillager, ending the raid
Expected & Observed Results:
Screenshots/Videos:
Ending the raid with a wolf kill
RaidHeroVillageWolf.mp4Notes:
Related to the following issues
MC-220360MC-186647 MC-165262
Tamed wolf killsdon't grant hero of the village effectEnding a raid with only tamed wolf kills will not grant the `hero of the village` effect
Ending a raid with only tamed wolf kills will not grant the`hero of the village`effectEnding a raid with only tamed wolf kills will not grant the "hero of the village" effect
relates to
If the only kills in a raid are made by a trained wolf and non-player kills (lava damage, fall damage, etc.) the player is not granted the hero of the village effect.
Steps to Reproduce:
(Start test in creative mode)
- Load into the attached world:
WolfRaidTest.zip- Spawn a wolf, tame it
- Give the wolf and player resistance (for ease)
/effect give @e[type=wolf] minecraft:resistance infinite 255 true /effect give @p minecraft:resistance infinite 255 true- Start the test with the command block labeled 'Start Test' (this starts a raid)
- Allow the first and second rounds to execute naturally (mobs will suffocate with provided setup), or speed the process up using a '/tick' command
- On the third wave, enable the repeating command block labeled 'Enable on third wave'
- Enter survival mode, allowing the pillager to attack yourself (this alerts the wolf)
- Allow the wolf to kill the pillager, ending the raid
Expected & Observed Results:
Screenshots/Videos:
Ending the raid with a wolf kill
RaidHeroVillageWolf.mp4Notes:
Related to the following issues
MC-220360MC-186647 MC-165262
Related to MC-208946
Please could you provide some screenshots or videos of this issue occurring whilst the F3 Debug screen is enabled? This would help myself, along with others, determine what the problem is. Thanks!
Can confirm in 24w10a. I would like to request ownership of this issue to add easier to follow steps to reproduce.