MC-28400Breeding animals gives xp even if doMobLoot gamerule is false
Steps to reproduce
- Spawn in 2 passive mobs (e.g. pig)
- Type /gamerule doMobLoot false
- Breed the 2 mobs
- Observe loot, you will find xp
Created Issue:
Breeding animals gives xp even if doMobLoot gamerule is false
Steps to reproduce
- Spawn in 2 passive mobs (e.g. pig)
- Type /gamerule doMobLoot false
- Breed the 2 mobs
- Observe loot, you will find xp
Added Linked Issues:
relates to
Added Assignee: 
EvilSeph (Warren Loo)
EvilSeph (Warren Loo)Added Fixed Versions: 13w37a
Added Linked Issues:
relates to
![[Mod] EVGENSYPERPRO](../../../data/avatars/users/92853.png){kind=small}
and MC-28400 was confirmed to be true despite it not affecting mobs UPON DEATH as you say
Confirmed in 1.8.3. Definitely a bug, MC-28400 being fixed shows that doMobLoot is supposed to affect all items gotten from mobs, not just ones dropped on death.
The doMobLoot gamerule does not prevent players from milking cows and Mooshrooms
MC-28400 proves that the doMobLoot gamerule is supposed to affect any item obtainable from mobs, not just once dropped on death.
Can we get an explanation for this resolution? Why does XP from breeding animals count as "loot" (MC-28400) but not wool from shearing them?
Confirmed.
It isn't really loot. The gamerule applies to killed mobs.
Yes but it is still a drop, and therefore should count
also this game rule was made either for adventure map as well as to prevent having a bunch of xp/items all over your world
This site is for bug reports only. Feature and improvement suggestions are not currently being tracked here.
I have this on some multiplayer servers with any mob spawned from eggs, even though gamerule doMobLoot is false. Any fixes for this? It ruins my redstone, as XP orbs trigger tripwires
if you vote then it is more likely to be seen, and therefore, more likely to be fixed