MC-44579Cannot summon green robed villager, even though its Zombie counterpart works
While the Green Robed Villager isn't able to spawn, textures for the Green Robed Zombie Villager were added. This indicates to me that the Green Robed Villager should exist. Logically, Green Villagers should use Profession:5
Green Villager (not working)
summon Villager ~ ~1.5 ~ {NoAI:true,Profession:5}
Green Zombie Villager
summon Zombie ~ ~1.5 ~ {IsVillager:true,IsBaby:false,NoAI:true,VillagerProfession:5}
Original report:
in 14w02b I was able to spawn in the green robed villager but now in 14w02c I cant spawn them in anymore! and when I change from 14w02b to 14w02c the green robed villager turns into a librarian Villager!
Linked Issues
is duplicated by4
Created Issue:
Cant Spawn the green robed villager with the /summon Villager ~ ~ ~ {Profession:6}
in 14w02b I was able to spawn in the green robed villager but now in 14w02c I cant spawn them in anymore! and when I change from 14w02b to 14w02c the green robed villager turns into a librarian Villager!
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Torabi](../../../data/assets/gravatar/torabi.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
in 14w02b I was able to spawn in the green robed villager but now in 14w02c I cant spawn them in anymore! and when I change from 14w02b to 14w02c the green robed villager turns into a librarian Villager!
While the Green Robed Villager isn't able to spawn, textures for the Green Robed Zombie Villager were added. This indicates to me that the Green Robed Villager should exist. Logically, Green Villagers should use Profession:5
Green Villager (not working)summon Villager ~ ~1.5 ~ {NoAI:true,Profession:5}
Green Zombie Villagersummon Zombie ~ ~1.5 ~ {IsVillager:true,IsBaby:false,NoAI:true,VillagerProfession:5}
Original report:
in 14w02b I was able to spawn in the green robed villager but now in 14w02c I cant spawn them in anymore! and when I change from 14w02b to 14w02c the green robed villager turns into a librarian Villager!
Cant Spawn thegreen robed villagerwith the /summon Villager ~ ~ ~ {Profession:6}Cannot summon green robed villager, even though its Zombie counterpart works
![[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/grum.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/searge.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke)A comment with security level 'global-moderators' was removed.
is duplicated by
relates to
Duplicate of MC-44579. Generic, green-robed villagers were deliberately removed from the game.
I know why you can't spawn it with,
{Profession:6}thats because Green villagers are
{Profession:5}, but profession:5 does not work either, so this is still a issue.
The green villagers were never fully implemented anyway, so maybe they've finally just removed them without mentioning it yet?
"FINALLY"???!?! GREEN VILLAGERS WAS ONE OF THE BEST MOBS IN THE GAME! Cause they don't come naturrally and then you can give them custom trades, its like adding your own villager, without doing it!
and yes they were! they were fully implemented, but for no USE theres difference! but people like to have them there because, like the giant, its like a..... whats the word... CUSTOM mob! and that makes it feel cool to have them!
Green robed villagers were removed in 14w02c. See
MC-44331for more details.Okay, I'm going to trust that info and probably break some systems here...Derp.
According to 14w05b, you still can spawn green robed villagers. Albeit, they crash the game whenever I try to trade with them, but they still do exist. Here.
You just have to be a little more crafty in your experiments. Those Minecraft programmers are out to fool you.
Why were they removed that's the dumbest thing ever in fact I forget if it was dinnerbone or jeb that said it but one of the mojang devs said that they wanted to add more villager types and removing a villager even if that villager is not in use just makes their statement less valid.
I recently realized Dinnerbone added textures for the green robed Zombie Villager. This indicates to me that the Green Robed Villager should exist. Could we reopen this report and have Dinnerbone weigh in on this? Logically, Green Villagers should use Profession:5
Green Villager
summon Villager ~ ~1.5 ~ {NoAI:true,Profession:5}Green Zombie Villager
summon Zombie ~ ~1.5 ~ {IsVillager:true,IsBaby:false,NoAI:true,VillagerProfession:5}I agree with qmagnet, I was also surprised when I found out the green robed zombie villager exists, so it should be logical a green robed villager exists too, I mean, the texture of it is still in between the other villager textures.
Also see
MC-87742. This is a feature request, not reopening.No dev ever said the green wasn't supported AFAIK. Those reports were closed based on community consensus.
MC-44331claims that "crashing" issue was fixed as well.IIRC the green villager was just the fallback texture for unknown professions, it's impossible now to create villagers with invalid professions (because those were crashy) thus the fallback never appears. But you're right, I haven't seen any official word either. Reopening and giving the ticket to qmagnet, but don't expect any miracles.
confirmed for 15w45a
Counterpart no longer works due to IsVillager and VillagerProfession being replaced with ZombieType (0=normal, 1-5=villager, 6=husk) Using the old way still works, but it's no longer saved in the entity.
Because of that, the above command results in a Husk.
Resolving as Fixed, as the green robe villager is not spawn-able, nor is the zombie variant.