MCPE-32740Button block press "animation" is wrong
Attached are four screenshots – so named according to their edition. Look at the top face.
Correct behavior (Java)
Pushing a stone or wooden button hides the inner half (closest to the block) by pushing the outer half (furthest from the block) inward.
Incorrect behavior (Bedrock)
Pushing a stone or wooden button removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
My attempt at a terrible visual model
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).
The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Linked Issues
MC-8522
- Unresolved
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png)
[Mod] tryashtar- 13
- 8
- Confirmed
- 114664
- Multiple
1.19.80.21 Preview - 1.21.51 Hotfix
1.19.80.21 Preview 1.18.10.26 Beta 1.17.40.23 Beta 1.17.40.21 Beta 1.17.20.20 Beta 1.16.0.51 Beta 1.14.0.2 Beta 1.12.0.2 Beta 1.11.0.10 Beta 1.9.0.0 Beta 1.2.20.1 1.2.13.60 1.2.16.3 1.4.3.0 1.4.2.0 1.6.0.5 1.5.0.14 1.7.1 1.7.0 1.9.0 1.10.0 1.13.0.2 Beta 1.14.0 1.16.40 Hotfix 1.16.201 Hotfix 1.17.2 Hotfix 1.17.30 1.17.32 1.18.2 Hotfix 1.19.70 1.21.51 Hotfix
Created Issue:
Button block press "animation" is wrong
Attached are four screenshots – the screenshots from Java are so named, and the other two are from Bedrock.
In Java, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the inner half, and pushes the outer half inward, which makes sense.
In Bedrock, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
Attachments4
image-2018-04-20-10-00-23-676.png
Attached are four screenshots – the screenshots from Java are so named, and the other two are from Bedrock.
In Java, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the inner half, and pushes the outer half inward, which makes sense.
In Bedrock, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Attached are four screenshots – the screenshots from Java are so named, and the other two are from Bedrock.
In Java, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the inner half, and pushes the outer half inward, which makes sense.
In Bedrock, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Attached are four screenshots – the screenshots from Java are so named, and the other two are from Bedrock.
In Java, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the inner half, and pushes the outer half inward, which makes sense.
In Bedrock, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Attached are four screenshots – the screenshots from Java are so named, and the other two are from Bedrock.
In Java, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the inner half, and pushes the outer half inward, which makes sense.
In Bedrock, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Attached are four screenshots – the screenshots from Java are so named, and the other two are from Bedrock.
In Java, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the inner half, and pushes the outer half inward, which makes sense.
In Bedrock, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Attached are four screenshots – the screenshots from Java are so named, and the other two are from Bedrock.
In Java, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the inner half, and pushes the outer half inward, which makes sense.
In Bedrock, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Attached are four screenshots –
the screenshots from Java are so named,and the other two are from Bedrock.
In Java, pushing a stone or wooden buttoninto a block removes the inner half, andpushesthe outer halfinward, which makes sense.In Bedrock, pushing a stone or wooden button into a block removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Attached are four screenshots – so named according to their edition. and the other two are from Bedrock.
Correct behavior (Java)
Pushing a stone or wooden button hides the inner half (closest to the block) by pushing the outer half (furthest from the block) inward.
Incorrect behavior (Bedrock)
Pushing a stone or wooden button removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
My attempt at a terrible visual model
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Attached are four screenshots – so named according to their edition. and the other two are from Bedrock.
Correct behavior (Java)
Pushing a stone or wooden button hides the inner half (closest to the block) by pushing the outer half (furthest from the block) inward.
Incorrect behavior (Bedrock)
Pushing a stone or wooden button removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
My attempt at a terrible visual model
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
Attached are four screenshots – so named according to their edition. and the other two are from Bedrock. Look at the top face.
Correct behavior (Java)
Pushing a stone or wooden button hides the inner half (closest to the block) by pushing the outer half (furthest from the block) inward.
Incorrect behavior (Bedrock)
Pushing a stone or wooden button removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
My attempt at a terrible visual model
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
![[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells)](../../../data/avatars/users/92696.png){kind=small}
Attached are four screenshots – so named according to their edition.
and the other two are from Bedrock.Look at the top face.Correct behavior (Java)
Pushing a stone or wooden button hides the inner half (closest to the block) by pushing the outer half (furthest from the block) inward.
Incorrect behavior (Bedrock)
Pushing a stone or wooden button removes the outer half, shaving it off of the button where it seemingly vanishes before reappearing.
My attempt at a terrible visual model
If you can't see what's happening in the screenshots, picture this:
The half of the button closest to the wall is painted blue, and the half furthest from the wall is painted red.
In Java, pushing the button exposes only the red half (makes sense). In Bedrock, pushing the button exposes only the blue half (logically impossible).The texture is also slightly different, but that is a separate issue.
![[MCPE Mod] Celesian](../../../data/avatars/users/81635.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] OcelotOnesie](../../../data/avatars/users/43220.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] GoldenHelmet](../../../data/avatars/users/18951.svg){kind=small}
is duplicated by
relates to
How the heck did you notice that?
Does it affect the signal output or function of the button or just a cosmetic issue?
Seems like it doesn’t work always. Depending on which orientation you place it or on which side you are looking, it sometimes just cuts off the outer half and sometimes it moves the outer half inward.
This was previously reported at
MCPE-11476. It also existed in Java Edition and was fixed:MC-8522.I can confirm what bugsbugsbugs says, that it's actually directional. You can see that in the screenshots attached, as the side appears to work correctly but the top does not.