Destroying sugar cane from bottom doesn't destroy the sugar canes one at a time
Currently cactus and scaffolding have physics that if you destroy one from the bottom then it will very quickly destroy all of them from the ground up. But with sugar cane, it all destroys instantly. I have a video showing what I mean:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1PN7VGmYuYupnZkMcNuu7SfRoCwF-7Tpc/view
Here's how you can see the difference for yourself.
- Place 15 - 20 scaffolding blocks upright
- Place 15- 20 cactus blocks upright (make sure there is a sand block at the bottom)
- Place 15 - 20 sugar cane upright
- Destroy the scaffolding and cactus blocks (watch them closely)
- Then destroy the sugar cane.
- Notice the difference
PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF THIS IS A BUG OR NOT!
Linked Issues
relates to5
MC-151622Breaking the bottom of a stack of snow layers breaks all snow layers above instantaneouslyConfirmedMC-151623Breaking the bottom of a stack of carpets breaks all other carpets instantaneouslyConfirmedMC-151624Vines which become disconnected from a block all break at the same time
LowMC-151625Breaking the base of stacked signs or wall signs causes them to all break at the same timeConfirmedMC-147061Kelp gets destroyed all at the same time when the bottom block is broken, unlike sugar cane, bamboo, and cactusFixed
Created Issue:
Destroying sugar cane from bottom doesn't destroy the sugar canes one at a time
LET ME EXPLAIN! Currently cactus and scaffolding have physics that if you destroy one from the bottom then it will very quickly destroy all of them from the ground up. But with sugar cane, it all destroys instantly. I have a video showing what I mean:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1PN7VGmYuYupnZkMcNuu7SfRoCwF-7Tpc/view
Here's how you can see the difference for yourself.
- Place 15 - 20 scaffolding blocks upright
- Place 15- 20 cactus blocks upright (make sure there is a sand block at the bottom)
- Place 15 - 20 sugar cane upright
- Destroy the scaffolding and cactus blocks watch them closely
- Then destroy the sugar cane.
- Notice the difference
PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF THIS IS A BUG OR NOT!
LET ME EXPLAIN! Currently cactus and scaffolding have physics that if you destroy one from the bottom then it will very quickly destroy all of them from the ground up. But with sugar cane, it all destroys instantly. I have a video showing what I mean:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1PN7VGmYuYupnZkMcNuu7SfRoCwF-7Tpc/view
Here's how you can see the difference for yourself.
- Place 15 - 20 scaffolding blocks upright
- Place 15- 20 cactus blocks upright (make sure there is a sand block at the bottom)
- Place 15 - 20 sugar cane upright
- Destroy the scaffolding and cactus blocks (watch them closely)
- Then destroy the sugar cane.
- Notice the difference
PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF THIS IS A BUG OR NOT!
LET ME EXPLAIN! Currently cactus and scaffolding have physics that if you destroy one from the bottom then it will very quickly destroy all of them from the ground up. But with sugar cane, it all destroys instantly. I have a video showing what I mean:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1PN7VGmYuYupnZkMcNuu7SfRoCwF-7Tpc/view
Here's how you can see the difference for yourself.
- Place 15 - 20 scaffolding blocks upright
- Place 15- 20 cactus blocks upright (make sure there is a sand block at the bottom)
- Place 15 - 20 sugar cane upright
- Destroy the scaffolding and cactus blocks (watch them closely)
- Then destroy the sugar cane.
- Notice the difference
PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF THIS IS A BUG OR NOT!
Currently cactus and scaffolding have physics that if you destroy one from the bottom then it will very quickly destroy all of them from the ground up. But with sugar cane, it all destroys instantly. I have a video showing what I mean:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1PN7VGmYuYupnZkMcNuu7SfRoCwF-7Tpc/view
Here's how you can see the difference for yourself.
- Place 15 - 20 scaffolding blocks upright
- Place 15- 20 cactus blocks upright (make sure there is a sand block at the bottom)
- Place 15 - 20 sugar cane upright
- Destroy the scaffolding and cactus blocks (watch them closely)
- Then destroy the sugar cane.
- Notice the difference
PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF THIS IS A BUG OR NOT!
![[Mojang] Adrian Östergård](../../../data/assets/gravatar/nighter.jpeg){kind=small}
rockenroll4life (Josh Letellier)![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
![[Bot] Piston](../../../data/avatars/users/31202.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Mod] NeunEinser](../../../data/avatars/users/39263.png){kind=small}
![[Helper] gaspoweredpick](../../../data/avatars/users/80904.png){kind=small}
Relates to MC-139273
One would expect that, in line with the resultion of MC-139273 and MC-147061, that the breaking would spread outwards from the point of breakage, however this is not the case and all of the blocks break instantaneously instead. Since the nether portal is two-dimensional, this can result in sound flanging and lag for very large portals, as well as maxing out the amount of sounds that can be played at a time. I've even been able to cause server crashes due to the amount of portal blocks that break, especially when using /fill, but this could very likely be done just as well by breaking enough sufficiently large nether portals in quick succession.
To test, punch out a nether portal block in creative or displace one using a water bucket.
![[Mod] ampolive](../../../data/avatars/users/18949.svg){kind=small}
Well, did it ever destroy them one at a time. I thik Sugar cane and cactus were different in that regard to begin with.
I am pretty sure that's how the devs want Minecraft physics to work. So surely this must be the case with the sugar cane. It doesn't make sense why it wouldn't work like all the other - destroy the bottom block and they all get destroyed blocks.
Sugar can has always broken this way it's nothing new.
Pretty sure the devs want all the blocks to fall down this way. (What I mean by all is all the blocks that when you break bottom they all get destroyed)
Sugar cane are hardly an exception. Only scaffolding and chorus fruit break one at a time, unlike sugar cane, cactus, bamboo, vines, signs, banners...
I see what you mean. I really don't know if its bug or its just purposely put into the game.
This is not only fixed for sugar cane, but also for bamboo.
This is not fixed for kelp, even though it is very similar to sugar cane and similar plants. See
MC-147061.