MC-217528The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a medium-sized area of powder snow by using the command provided below.
/fill ~5 ~ ~5 ~-5 ~ ~-5 minecraft:powder_snow
- Set the weather to "thunder" and give yourself a trident enchanted with channeling by using the command provided below.
/give @s minecraft:trident[minecraft:enchantments={levels:{"minecraft:channeling":1}}] - Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow and throw your trident enchanted with channeling at it.
- Take note as to whether or not the channeling enchantment works when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work.
Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would work.
Linked Issues
Low
![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
The channeling enchantment does not work when the mob is inside of powder snow
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment does not work when the mob is inside of powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Set the weather to thunder.
/weather thunder
- Give yourself a trident enchanted with channeling.
/give @s trident{Enchantments:[{id:"channeling",lvl:1}]}
- Spawn an entity inside of powder snow.
- Throw your trident at it.
→Notice how the entity isn't struck with lightning.
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Anthony Cicinelli](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Adrian Östergård](../../../data/assets/gravatar/nighter.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Mod] LateLag](../../../data/avatars/users/92884.png){kind=small}
![[Helper] Johnibur](../../../data/avatars/users/28381.png){kind=small}
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment does not work when the mob is inside of powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Set the weather to thunder.
/weather thunder
- Give yourself a trident enchanted with channeling.
/give @s minecraft:trident{Enchantments:[{id:"channeling",lvl:1}]}
- Spawn an entity inside of powder snow.
- Throw your trident at it.
→
The Bug:
The
channeling enchantment doesnot work when the mob isinside of powder snow.Steps to Reproduce:
Set the weather to thunder./weather thunder
Give yourselfa trident enchanted with channeling./give @s minecraft:trident{Enchantments:[{id:"channeling",lvl:1}]}
- Spawn an entity inside of powder snow.
- Throw your trident at it.
→entity isn't struck with lightning.The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't function if entities are inside of powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
/fill ~5 ~ ~5 ~-5 ~ ~-5 minecraft:powder_snow
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
/give @s minecraft:trident{Enchantments:[{id:"channeling",lvl:1}]}
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow.
- Throw your enchanted trident at it.
- →
The channeling enchantment doesnot work when the mob isinside of powder snowThe channeling enchantment doesn't function if entities are inside of powder snow
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't function if entities are inside of powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
/fill ~5 ~ ~5 ~-5 ~ ~-5 minecraft:powder_snow
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
/give @s minecraft:trident{Enchantments:[{id:"channeling",lvl:1}]}
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow.
- Throw your enchanted trident at it.
- →
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't function if entities are inside of powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow.
- Throw your enchanted trident at it.
- →
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't function if entities are inside of powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow.
- Throw your enchanted trident at it.
- →
Expected Behavior:
The expected behavior would be that the channeling enchantment functions correctly when entities are inside of powder snow.
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't function if entities are inside of powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow.
- Throw your enchanted trident at it.
- →
Expected Behavior:
The
expected behavior would be that thechanneling enchantment functions correctly whenentities are inside of powder snow.The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't function if entities are inside of powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow.
- Throw your enchanted trident at it.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't function if entities are inside of powder snow.
Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would function even if entities are inside of powder snow.
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't
function ifentitiesareinsideofpowder snow.Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow.
- Throw your enchanted trident at it.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't
function ifentitiesareinsideofpowder snow.Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would
function even ifentitiesareinsideofpowder snow.The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow and throw your trident enchanted with channeling at it.
- Take note as to whether or not the channeling enchantment works when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
The channeling enchantment doesn'tfunction ifentitiesareinsideofpowder snowThe channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow and throw your trident enchanted with channeling at it.
- Take note as to whether or not the channeling enchantment works when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to thunder and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow and throw your trident enchanted with channeling at it.
- Take note as to whether or not the channeling enchantment works when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work
when thrown at entities inside powder snow.Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would work
when thrown at entities inside powder snow.The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to "thunder" and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow and throw your trident enchanted with channeling at it.
- Take note as to whether or not the channeling enchantment works when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work.
Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would work.
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a large area of powder snow.
- Set the weather to "thunder" and obtain a trident enchanted with channeling.
- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow and throw your trident enchanted with channeling at it.
- Take note as to whether or not the channeling enchantment works when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work.
Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would work.
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a medium-sized area of powder snow by using the command provided below.
/fill ~5 ~ ~5 ~-5 ~ ~-5 minecraft:powder_snow- Set the weather to "thunder" and give yourself a trident enchanted with channeling by using the command provided below.
/give @s minecraft:trident{Enchantments:[{id:"minecraft:channeling",lvl:1}]}- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow and throw your trident enchanted with channeling at it.
- Take note as to whether or not the channeling enchantment works when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work.
Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would work.
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a medium-sized area of powder snow by using the command provided below.
/fill ~5 ~ ~5 ~-5 ~ ~-5 minecraft:powder_snow- Set the weather to "thunder" and give yourself a trident enchanted with channeling by using the command provided below.
/give @s minecraft:trident{Enchantments:[{id:"minecraft:channeling",lvl:1}]}- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow and throw your trident enchanted with channeling at it.
- Take note as to whether or not the channeling enchantment works when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work.
Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would work.
The Bug:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a medium-sized area of powder snow by using the command provided below.
/fill ~5 ~ ~5 ~-5 ~ ~-5 minecraft:powder_snow- Set the weather to "thunder" and give yourself a trident enchanted with channeling by using the command provided below.
/give @s minecraft:trident[minecraft:enchantments={levels:{"minecraft:channeling":1}}]- Spawn any entity inside of the powder snow and throw your trident enchanted with channeling at it.
- Take note as to whether or not the channeling enchantment works when thrown at entities inside powder snow.
Observed Behavior:
The channeling enchantment doesn't work.
Expected Behavior:
The channeling enchantment would work.
I would assume the cause of this bug (as well as MC-125773 and MC-217528) to be that Channeling checks for sky exposure at a mob's feet level. So when mobs are standing on non-full blocks that block sky light, their feet technically don't have sky access, therefore Channeling doesn't work. Similarly, when mobs are riding boats/minecarts, their hitboxes extend below the bottom of the vehicles, observable using F3 + B. Hopefully someone can do a code analysis on this, so my speculation can be confirmed.
Does MC-134920 describe your issue?
I'd said no. Powder snow does not match the description of this report, therefore it should be related and not marked as a duplicate. Also relates to MC-125773.
Can confirm
Duplicate of MC-134920
Justin Zheng, this is not a duplicate of MC-134920. See the above conversation.
As owner of MC-134920 I have updated the description by adding powder snow. My ticket is just more generic than yours as it covers every blocks/entities affected, I don't know if this could be considered a duplicate or not.